Pittsburgh is known as a city with a low cost of living, but sometimes you wouldn’t know it when it comes to dining out — especially at some of the newer restaurants.
Diners are paying more for less than what customers can get in other cities — less experience and less competition that would bring better service, better sourcing or better wine, for example.
Other times we’re paying for portions — big plates of food and a warm experience, which has been the case here for decades. This is slowly changing as the restaurant renaissance continues. We’re seeing it with chefs and diners moving here from other regions, as local chefs find inspiration from around the world and as travel and posts on Instagram influence diners’ expectations.
Today I’m looking at the cost of popular dishes in Pittsburgh that, combined with a drink, cost at or below $40, pre-tax and tip, and comparing them with those sold in New York. The out-of-town comparisons come from restaurant menus on “The 38 essential New York Restaurants, January 2015” from New York’s Eater.com. They’re places that have worked out the kinks and resonate with diners.
Sure, New York and Pittsburgh are different animals. Their restaurants face different challenges. Rent is higher in New York, but prices for meals are deflating as competition increases. But the point is, in both cities, the market is bearing comparable prices for similar dishes, although portion size, sourcing and the skill of the kitchen may differ.
In the meantime there are more opportunities than ever for Pittsburghers to weigh in with their wallets. And as they do, we’ll see how diners’ spending shapes restaurants and the dishes they’re serving, such as these very good selections below:
Pizza cravings
Ron Molinaro is the guy behind Il Pizzaiolo, which sells two versions of a margherita pizza. The first wears fresh mozzarella, pecorino, San Marzano tomato sauce, basil and olive oil and runs $15. Swap out the fresh cheese for mozzarella di Bufala and replace pecorino with Parmigiano and you’ve got the $17 margherita DOC. Both pies are made with Caputo “00” flour in a two-day process, then cooks in minutes in a custom wood-fired oven. Add an Italian craft beer such as the Birrificio del Ducato Nuova Mattina for $12 and the tab is somewhere between $25 and $29. (8 Market Square, Downtown)
A margherita pizza in Shadyside at the decidedly casual Mercurio’s delivers straightforward ingredients at straightforward prices. For $9, it’s mozzarella pulled in house, sauce, olive oil and basil in an Acunto oven that’s also from Naples. With a glass of wine, $10, a diner can get out of there with a tab just under $20. (5523 Walnut St., Shadyside)
In Brooklyn, N.Y., at the media darling Roberta’s in the Bushwick neighborhood, a straight-up margherita also cooked in a wood-fired oven clocks in at $13. Add caciocavallo, oregano and chili and it’s an extra buck. Pair it with a Forlorn Hope rose for $13, and the tab is $26 or $27. (216 Moore St., Brooklyn)
A classic roast chicken
At The Commoner, which opened Downtown this week in the Kimpton’s Hotel Monaco, executive chef Dennis Marron serves brick chicken with roasted garlic potatoes, burnt leek puree and Brussels sprouts for $26. Stick with a no-booze beverage to keep the tab under $40. (458 Strawberry Way, Downtown)
Over at the decade-old Eleven, one of my favorite restaurants, chef Derek Stevens salts a chicken breast on the bone overnight then roasts and carves it for the restaurant’s roast chicken dish that’s been on the menu “since day one,” he said. He takes the legs off and braises them separately and incorporates the meat into the risotto. The dish is plated with swiss chard and thyme jus. The price is $26, although you’ll have to order a $6 beer or sparkling water or visiting during happy hour to stay under $40. (1150 Smallman St., Strip District)
At the longstanding Balthazar in Manhattan’s SoHo, the Keith McNally restaurant offers roast chicken breast for $29, served with broccoli rabe and fig jus. Coq au vin with pearl onions, smoked bacon and truffled basmati rice rings in at the same price. Stick with sparkling water or a coffee to keep the tab below $40. (80 Spring St., New York)
Cured meats
At Mezzo,the newish mid-floor of the tri-level Sienna Mercato, Downtown, meat is cured in-house by Anthony Castine, chef de cuisine. A large butcher board runs $26, while a small one is $14. Selections can include ciccioli and lomo as well as a housemade cherry mostarda among condiments. With a 6-ounce glass of Beaujolais from Albert Bichot ($9), it’s over budget for the large board but less than $25 for a sampler. (942 Penn Ave., Downtown)
Over at Cure in Lawrenceville, chef de cuisine Nathan Hobart cures meats displayed on a small charcuterie board for $12. A $40 board is terrifically decadent, with more meat than a table of four can finish. My favorite selections are the lardo blended with pimenton, duck speck and bresaola. Add some house-made mustards, pickled red onions and grape must, and it’s becoming one of the most well-known dishes in Pittsburgh. The $12 board with a $10 cocktail fall well under $40. With a two-week wait for reservations, it seems silly to make one for such a small order. (5336 Butler St., Lawrenceville)
In New York, Bar Boulud was a sensation when it opened in 2008. Just after the stock market plummeted, the restaurant helped set trends of doing away with white tablecloths and getting snacky with a selection of charcuterie. It was also one of the first restaurants to have a charcuterier — the guy whose sole job it is to cure meats. Since 2010, Aurelien Dufour has been in charge of the program, that’s $14 for a sample to $40 for Iberico Spanish ham. I’d order the tourte charcutiere ($29) with foie gras, pork jowl and boudin noir. Stick to sparkling water to keep the bill below $40. (1900 Broadway, New York)
Burgers
Most burger dishes in Pittsburgh are usually less than $20, including a drink. Still, at Bar Marco in the Strip, a burger with rosemary aioli and caramelized red onions on brioche costs $12 on its own, $17 with roasted potatoes and aioli. Add a glass of wine for $11 and it’s $28 before tax and tip. (2216 Penn Ave., Strip District)
Over at BRGR in East Liberty, the 8-ounce Prime burger with pickled red onions, blue cheese, arugula and tomatoes is $13, plus $4 for fries tossed with Parmesan and herbs. Add an East End Big Hop IPA for $6 and it’s $23 before tax and tip. (5997 Penn Circle South, East Liberty)
In New York at Andrew Carmellini’s Lafayette in the West Village, a brisket burger on the mid-day menu costs $21 with caramelized onions and raclette on a bun baked in-house, served with a side of fries. Rather than a $15 glass of wine, order a $7 craft beer or a sparkling water. The tally before tax and tip falls close to $28.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.