There’s little that’s common about the Commoner and Commoner Corner, the restaurants for Kimpton’s Hotel Monaco that will open Downtown Tuesday.
The 248-room Hotel Monaco in the former Reed Smith building between Sixth Avenue and Strawberry Way has drawn a lot of attention because it’s among the first of a handful of boutique hotels opening in Pittsburgh. The Ace Hotel and Hotel Indigo in East Liberty are set to open this spring; Distrikt Hotel and Forbes Hotel, both Downtown, are in the works for 2016.
With 62 hotels in 29 cities, the San Francisco-based Kimpton has drafted chef Dennis Marron from within the organization to run the restaurant. Mr. Marron was the head of the kitchen at the popular Poste Moderne Brasserie in Washington, D.C., where Michelle Obama celebrated her birthday last year. He also steered kitchens at Jackson 20 Restaurant & Tavern and the more formal Grille at Morrison House, both in Alexandria, Va.
How The Commoner got its name
Hotel Monaco’s The Commoner restaurant was nearly named something a little more courtly — “Elderburgh” — after William Pitt the Elder, the fiery 18th-century earl of Chatham who helped Britain win the Seven Years’ War. He’s also the man for whom Pittsburgh is named. The Commoner, decided by the hotel management, is a reference to Pitt for his refusal to accept a title until he was 58.
The Commoner “had a better ring to it,” said Commoner chef Dennis Marron of the switch. “It conveyed a more egalitarian image, one that Pittsburgh would embrace.”
For the 120-seat Commoner restaurant, Mr. Marron has put together a tavern menu that includes Pennsylvania foods from pierogies to pizzelles on a cookie table-inspired dessert. The entrance to Commoner Corner, a dozen-seat carvery, can be accessed from inside the restaurant and from a walk-up window that faces Strawberry Way. It will focus on smoked meats for sandwiches with choose-your-own toppings; pressed juices, milkshakes and coffee from Seattle-based Caffe Vita.
A staff of 75 will run the restaurant, with most of the upper management coming from other cities. Even Mr. Marron is still getting settled. He moved into his new Mt. Lebanon home just a few weeks ago after spending the summer with his in-laws in Greensburg.
In the kitchen
When I visited a couple of weeks ago, much of the dining room was ready for business. Whitewashed hardwood floors were dry-stenciled with a quilt design, chandeliers were alit in starbursts of Edison bulbs, and a weathered mirror imprinted with a map of the city had been installed days earlier.
Mr. Marron was tweaking the opening menu, which includes a couple of his favorites, such as braised Karabuta pork cheeks served with parsnip puree, bacon lardon and cipollini onion or the onion soup burger topped with caramelized onions and gruyere cheese.
“I’ve been building a menu for this kind of restaurant for a long time,” he said. Mr. Marron’s cooking has been for more formal dining rooms, with the exception of Jackson 20. He is excited about region-specific pub food with better ingredients.

PG map: Hotel Monaco
(Click image for larger version)
He was sitting at a marble top table in the dining room surrounded by a stack of cookbooks. “Smoke & Pickles” by Eddie Lee and “Pickles, Pigs & Whiskey” by John Currence pointed to food of the American South, while Fergus Henderson’s “The Whole Beast: Nose to Tail Eating” and “The Slovak-American Cookbook” from the Catholic Slovak Ladies Association represent traditional books for very different kinds of cooks. They’ve all served as inspiration for this restaurant.
From the stacks, he pulled “The Complete Irish Pub Cookbook” from Parragon Books and flipped through photos. “The soda bread recipe doesn’t come from here,” he said. “It actually comes from my mom.” A few days earlier, Mr. Marron made the recipe for Amanda Erckert, who will be in charge of pastry, using Pennsylvania ingredients such as flour from Castle Valley Mill in Doylestown.
Local foods may seem like a given in Pittsburgh. Menus all over town list local purveyors like movie credits.
But with deeper pockets than an average restaurant, Mr. Marron has buying power and with it he plans to buy 75 percent of his ingredients locally. This is significant because many restaurants are having to switch to less expensive purveyors due to higher food costs and more stringent restaurant competition, with so many opening within the past couple of years.
Sourcing in general has been one of Mr. Marron’s challenges because he is just building relationships with purveyors. He started with Penn’s Corner Farm Alliance and Wild Purveyors in Lawrenceville. He’s also using Elysian Fields lamb from Waynesburg, and he’s buying fish from Samuels and Son, a Philadelphia-based company that also sourced seafood in his previous positions.
“I’m used to local guys just coming by the restaurant to sell things,” he said. “We have to open before that will happen.”
During my visit, Mr. Marron had a heritage pig from Wild Purveyors on display in the kitchen, sprawled across a stainless-steel island. He was using it to teach his 35 kitchen workers about butchering and curing guanciale.
“I thought hiring would be the biggest challenge,” he said. “But I’ve gotten a lot of people who want to grow and learn, a staff of cooks who have been executive chefs and sous chefs elsewhere. It’s a really good crew.”
A few feet from the pig, sous chef Wyatt Lash pureed squash with a hand-held blender in a clear Cambro container. Late fall, he left his position as a longtime head chef at the Whip Tavern in Philadelphia. Its menu of smoked salmon bubbles and squeak, Welsh rarebit and meat pies was well-received by the Philadelphia Inquirer’s restaurant critic Craig LaBan. When Mr. Lash moved to the Pittsburgh area, he and his girlfriend settled in McDonald on her family farm. They’re starting out by raising chickens and will farm for the restaurant in the spring.
Mr. Lash is joined by Allentown native Jessica Lewis, who was on “Hell’s Kitchen” season 11 on Fox and cooked at Bagatelle in New York. Ms. Lewis, who is also a sous chef, moved to Pittsburgh a year ago and had been catering for Heinz Field before she was hired at the Commoner. Her Twitter feed is filled with test-run dishes from brick-oven roasted chicken with burnt leeks puree to seafood chowder and pierogi and eggs for brunch.
Behind the bar
The Commoner’s general manager Matthew Rafferty moved here from Philadelphia, where he was managing Square 1682, the restaurant for Kimpton’s Hotel Palomar near Rittenhouse Square.
He will be a liaison between the staff and six bartenders led by bar manager Joshua Holliday. Mr. Holliday moved here from Miami’s 50 Eggs restaurant group, which includes Yardbird Southern Kitchen + Bar. Brian Gastaldi, formerly at Acacia on the South Side, who also has been hired, worked with Mr. Holliday at Yardbird. The pair will anchor a drink program that will focus on brown liquor (bourbon, rye, scotch). The draft program showcases 12 local craft beers, two cocktails and six wines chosen by the aptly named sommelier Emily Wines, who is one of about 130 master sommeliers in the world and the senior director of the national beverage programs for Kimpton Hotels. (Ms. Wines lives in San Francisco.) These selections will likely expand in the spring when a beer garden — now being planned — is expected to open on the ninth floor.
Although the employees new to Pittsburgh are still adjusting to the Steel City, Mr. Marron said it’s been an easy transition at work.
“In D.C., I could have a table of high-powered lobbyists and politicians sitting next to a table of interns, and the kitchen has to bridge a big gap,” he said.
“Here, everyone gets it,” he said. “They’re more likely to be on the same page.”
The Commoner Restaurant and Bar: 458 Strawberry Way, 412-471-1170, thecommonerpgh.com. The restaurant will open Tuesday, serving breakfast and dinner. Lunch service will begin Feb. 2 and weekend brunch will start Feb. 7. Commoner Corner will also open for breakfast and lunch on Tuesday.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.