There’s polish but little that’s modern about Joseph Tambellini Restaurant in Highland Park.

I like the place because it offers the best of Old Pittsburgh without caricature. You won’t see framed photos as reminders of the city’s former greatness, or its rise from the ashes. You will not find shtick that’s inevitable at places that have been christened as Pittsburgh institutions by national TV. I also like this restaurant because it’s a reflection of values: how Pittsburghers have wanted to eat when they dressed up to dine out.

Joseph Tambellini Restaurant

5701 Bryant St.

Advertise with us

Highland Park

412-665-9000

  • Hours: 4 p.m. to close, Tuesday through Sunday.
  • Basics: Among the last restaurants with a name that’s familiar to Pittsburghers, Joseph Tambellini Restaurant offers warm service and a menu of Italian-American classics in a polished, intimate dining room.
  • Dishes: Calamari, fried zucchini, crab cakes, signature meatball, classic Caesar, veal parmesan, veal piccata, seafood Melissa, eggplant parmesan, pecan ball.
  • Prices: Antipasti $2-$12; insalate $7-$14; vitello/pollo $23-$28; manzo $32-$44; pesce $29-$36; fresh handmade pasta $23-$25; dolce $7-$8.50.
  • Summary: Street parking, coat check, quiet dining room, event space.Street parking, coat check, quiet dining room, event space.

Although white tablecloth restaurants are on the wane, there are no cobwebs in the corner and other telltale signs that the end is near. During two visits after the holidays, the dining room was abuzz, with every table full on a Saturday night.

Eight years ago, Joseph and his wife Melissa opened Joseph Tambellini Restaurant in the former home of Laforet on Bryant Street. Today, it’s the last Tambellini restaurant within city limits. There’s also one in Bridgeville, founded by Bruno Tambellini that’s now run by his son. Although it’s the same family name, the restaurants are independent.

At peak, eight Tambellini restaurants served Pittsburgh. Louis Tambellini opened the first one on Mount Washington in 1946. By 1981, he moved to Route 51 in Brookline. By 2006, its days were numbered. It’s now an Old Town Buffet.

Advertise with us

Even as the namesake restaurants are closing, Pittsburghers still show respect.

Here’s why. The Tambellinis are meticulous in pampering customers. In my visits to some of the city’s expensive restaurants, service can be slack. I’ve been held captive to servers overshares, handed knives as if someone were about to get stabbed and served dishes with dried food stuck to the plate.

There’s no such amateurism here. When there was a glitch, staff handled it like pros. Occasionally, there’s so much fawning it’s over the top. I was kind of embarrassed when a server offered the cork and decanted a low-budget, food-friendly Chianti (I Fabbri Terra di Lamole, Chianti Classico DOCG 2011 $45). But it’s egalitarian of them, and it’s a nice gesture.

Speaking of wine, check out the website before you go. It shows the iPad wine list that’s heavy with Italians that offer good value. Skip wines by the glass such as Plungerhead Zinfandel ($12) and buy a bottle. Also skip the cocktails unless you’re all right with drinks such as the tinsel bellini made with sparkling wine and blue curacao.

Tambellini is the kind of place a man might wish he wore a jacket, although it’s not required. And despite the formal environs, entree prices are on par with newer places such as Bar Marco in the Strip or Mezzo Downtown.

Advertise with us

Tambellini is also the kind of place you can still get Dover sole on occasion. I prefer when it’s not dressed up and stuffed with crabmeat. Dover sole along with turbot is the king of fishes with the price to show it. It may look unremarkable on the plate, but Dover sole is prized because it’s faintly sweet, mild and firm. It’s primarily found off the shores of Europe.

But I’m getting ahead of myself.

Needless to say there’s no skimping here. Entrees come with a side salad, soup and a side of pasta. I swap the salad for a very good Caesar (with a $9 upcharge) because the tossed salad has the odd inclusion of couscous and chick peas.

Despite conventional wisdom, bigger portions do not necessarily equal fabulous food, although several dishes are very good. Here’s how I’d navigate when I bring my family or out-of-town guests:

I’d start with calamari ($11), whether it’s sauteed, dressed with red sauce, or fried. Sweet and tender, this is how the dish is supposed to be.

Advertise with us

The greens and beans ($10) are not. The serving is a bit obscene and sloppy, with greens resting in broth, garnished with a lone fat sausage link. The stuffed peppers ($10) also get the sausage treatment, as if the kitchen gave up after stuffing them with cheese. More pleasing is the fried zucchini ($10), with a jacket of fried cornmeal.

As far as entrees, stick to classics or the night’s additions. The veal parmesan ($32) is the star, pummeled thin, served with provolone over red sauce. I’m also into the majestic slab of eggplant parmesan ($25) with thin, breaded layers piled high. Veal piccata ($32) is fine, but not great. It’s a little underseasoned and shows evidence of corn starch. It also doesn’t need the artichoke.

The veal Marsala ($32) is a bust, served dry with a sauce marred by soy instead of staying Italian with the ingredients. The Mafalda Giancarlo ($26) reads like a vegetarian afterthought, albeit well-seasoned: sticky noodles tossed with pine nuts, spinach, artichoke hearts and sundried tomatoes.

After such a feast, diners not used to long dinners might panic over the thought of another course. I like the luxury of time with friends, especially when it includes gracious service. Yet diners are reminded of the leisurely pacing when they arrive, with the list of desserts prominent on the main menu as well as a stand-alone after dinner. A night’s selection may include tiramisu ($8), cannoli ($7), butterscotch pound cake ($8) and the Pittsburgh favorite that adamantly rejects localism, the pecan ball ($7, $9 with hot fudge).

Order one. Chances are, you’ll get a fine to lovely dessert, although the espresso could be better. But there’s a reason for staying through to the very end. This is Pittsburgh dining that’s getting harder to come by. And it’s done well.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.