If you were wondering whether fish remains a holiday favorite, look to the sold-out Feast of the Seven Fishes dinner tonight at Stagioni on the South Side.

Feast of the Seven Fishes has been a ritual for as long as the city has been home to Southern Italian immigrants. But with the increasing popularity of fish more people are celebrating in restaurants and at home.

The dinner is Stagioni’s largest Sunday dinner since the restaurant moved from Bloomfield to the South Side in 2012. Manager Cara DelSignore planned on booking 45 seats and “we kept expanding the dinner until we ran out of chairs,” she said. The restaurant sold 80 seats in a week and a half.

“I think Feast of the Seven Fishes is a fond memory for lots of people, whether their family is Italian or they’ve been invited to someone else’s dinner,” she said. She looks forward to celebrating with her family, with her father cooking the Christmas Eve meal when she was growing up, making his signature salt cod fritters as one of the dishes. She and chef Stephen Felder transferred the ritual to the restaurant last year when enough regulars asked.

Advertise with us

What is Festa dei sette pesci, better known to Italian-Americans as the Feast of the Seven Fishes? “It’s what Italians do when they say they’re fasting,” Mario Batali quipped to Epicurious.com. Traditionally held on Christmas Eve, Feast of the Seven Fishes is also known as La Vigilia, marked by serving at least seven types of fish. This honors the practice that Catholics abstain from meat on Christmas Eve, as well a being a holdover from the days when meat was more of a luxury than fish. The number seven references the sacraments although some Italian Catholic families serve 11 dishes or 13 dishes in reference to the Apostles, without Judas or with Jesus.

Although the restaurants connected to Penn Avenue Fish Company in the Strip and Downtown won’t have a Feast of the Seven Fishes dinner, co-owner Henry Dewey said Dec. 23 is the busiest day of the year in the fish market because of the celebration. Last year, he worked 20 hours straight, the longest day he’s ever worked since he got into the fish business decades ago.

This year he expects to do the same. “We have to get all fired up because we know we’re going to get crushed,” he said.

Gone are the days when Pittsburghers would order eel and octopus for the feast. Still Mr. Dewey expects to sell 10 to 15 orders of those “for the hardcore Italians.”

Instead, customers are looking for smelts, calamari, baccala, shrimp and clams, as well as lobster tails. And, of course, salmon, salmon, salmon. “People can’t get enough salmon,” he said. Raw fish has also gained popularity, he said, as people are becoming more adventurous and as Penn Avenue Fish Company’s restaurant side carves its reputation on its newly expanded sushi bar.

Advertise with us

Over at Wholey’s Market, also in the Strip, calamari, smelt and cod remain popular. Jim Wholey said the market holds “Seafood School,” on Saturday mornings at 10 a.m. in the upstairs dining room to teach them how to clean and prepare fish. The class started as staff training until Mr. Wholey opened it to the public.

Yet another sign that people are into the feast is the swift sellout of 30 seats to the Dec. 13 talk from Mary Menniti of the North Side-based Italian Garden Project on the history of the celebration at the Heinz History Center. The talk includes information on the health benefits of fish from a UPMC health coach, as well as sample dishes and recipes.

For those who don’t intend to cook seven fishes at home, a handful of restaurants aside from Stagioni will be hosting the feast closer to Christmas Eve.

La Tavola Italiana in Mount Washington holds a four-course, BYOB celebration 6:30 p.m. Dec. 18 for $75 per person. And on Dec. 21, chef owner Sam DiBattista will offer dinner at 3 p.m. for $70 a person at Vivo Kitchen in Sewickley. The following day Bar Marco in the Strip will offer the feast for its No Menu Monday. Bar Marco partner and chef Justin Steel has invited Chad Townsend, former chef at Salt of the Earth in Garfield and the founder of Millie’s Ice Cream, along with Rick Easton of the soon-to-open Bread and Salt Bakery in Bloomfield, to prepare the feast. The menu includes scungilli salad, baccala, linguini with clams and stewed eel, served family-style for $55 per person.

San Lorenzo in Lawrenceville will also host two seatings to celebrate the feast at 6 and 8:30 p.m. Dec. 23, which includes six courses for $49 per person. And on Christmas Eve at Lidia’s in the Strip, the restaurant serves the family-style dinner for $55 per person, with an additional $30 for wine pairings. Past courses have included spicy calamari with fregola, raisins, capers and pine nuts and gnocchi with Baccala mantecato — whipped salt cod — and truffle among dishes.

Advertise with us

Back at Stagioni, this year’s menu departs from last year’s, which was inspired by Ms. DelSignore’s family traditions. Mr. Felder is serving salmon rillettes, baccala with olives, capers and celery; raw tuna with apples, radish and fennel; calamari, mussels and clams with chickpeas and olives; octopus with potatoes and smoked paprika aioli; squid ink gnocchi and bottarga; followed by poached cod with citrus and pistachio.

Cookies and fruit cake round out the dessert course. Also known as panettone, the cake is soaked in Jannamico Super Punch known as the Pittsburgh amari. If you’ve had this intensely sweet liqueur, you’ll know that the finale to Stagioni’s feast includes a sense of humor.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.