If you’re looking for the soul of Mezzo Downtown, it’s in front of the wood-fired oven where chef owner Matthew Porco is cooking dinner.

The bearded man in a ball cap is usually wearing a gray shirt with a Sienna Mercato patch on the chest, reminiscent of a retro mechanic. He wipes his brow between sliding a pizza from the peel and assembling a charcuterie board for an order.

Mezzo 

942 Penn Ave.

Advertise with us

Downtown

412-281-2810

siennapgh.com

  • Hours: 5 to 10 p.m. Sundays through Thursdays; 5 to 11 p.m. Fridays and Saturdays.
  • Basics: Mezzo is the most tailored of the three restaurants in Downtown’s Sienna Mercato, with a terrific selection of wines and amari, and an array of charcuterie, pizza, greens, pastas and meat-centric mains.
  • Recommended Dishes: Charcuterie, escarole Calabrese, grilled octopus, cotechino, wood-roasted 1⁄2 farm chicken, goat sugo, shrimp fra diavolo, pasta Genovese, spaghetti alla vongole, quatro fromage pizza, clam pizza.
  • Prices: Antipasta $3-$10; insalata $7-$8; cheese plate $11-$20; butcher board $14-$26; panini $11-$13; pizza $15-$18; secondi $19-$21; pasta $15-$18; dessert $8.
  • Summary: No reservations; No Wait app; valet or lot parking; moderately loud to loud dining room.

Can he ever cook, especially when it’s a dish in his repertoire. His list runs deep from his days at Veritas in New York, followed by the now-closed Mio in Aspinwall, at the flagship Sienna Sulla Piazza in Market Square and now here.

Mezzo opened in late September as the most tailored restaurant in the three-tier Sienna Mercato building that includes the family friendly Emporio: A Meatball Joint at street level and Il Tetto, the rooftop beer garden. Mezzo isn’t necessarily a special occasion place, but with a polished dining room, terrific drink choices and a food menu from snacks to big-plate mains, it can be.

Advertise with us

The decor mirrors its siblings with a couple of distinctions. It seems like the place should be loud, but it isn’t. Instead, the room emphasizes intimate dining, with cozy banquettes and a small, L-shaped bar. Black and white wallpaper wears sketches of pigs, while white high-back chairs and ochre upholstery accent the low-lit room.

When you’re hungry, start with the charcuterie, a just-right portion for a table, with a decadent housemade ciccoli that’s the star of the meats. The lomo is also memorable, along with the cherry mostarda, spicy with mustard oil. This is the work of chef de cuisine Derek Blackburn who moved here from Dallas after working under Julian Barsotti of Carbone’s and Nonna. If his charcuterie is evidence, we have a lot to look forward to from Mr. Blackburn.

Octopus resides among first courses at what seems like every restaurant in town. Here it holds its own, pairing deep flavors with chalky white beans. Another starter, cotechino is served over lentils with mosto cotto and soffrito that lend bold flavor.

Among other starters, you can’t go wrong with greens and beans, which Mr. Porco prepares differently at each of his restaurants. Here, they're folded like letters steeped in broth and studded with chopped salumi for an intensely savory dish.

Mr. Porco’s pastas are better than your grandmother's at Sunday supper. The goat sugo over pappardelle is the win, a glossy meat sauce with amped flavor from the soffritto. The Genovese pasta is humble and true, with braised beef, pancetta, onions and pecorino. In the shrimp fra diavolo, orecchiette wears a sauce that's not shy of heat, a mound for meaty shrimp cooked just right.

Advertise with us

The big-dish mains stake a claim among what’s good, particularly the wood-fired half chicken with its blistered skin. Served over rapini and polenta, it is memorable, although something that's easy enough to make as well at home. And Mr. Porco's take on pork and beans also holds its own.

Also worth noting is the heavily European wine list by the glass put together by manager Michael McCoy, with a flinty Soave, an elegant rose from Campagna, and reds that range from a Beaujolais to a Sardinian Cannonau, a grenache.

Here are my quibbles. The pizza selections are thoughtful, but I’m not in love with the dough, despite that it’s leavened for a full 48 hours. If toppings are your thing, the staff is wild about the tartufo, with ricotta, fontina, mushrooms, truffle egg and parmesan. I also like the quattro fromaggi for the addictive pickled cherry tomatoes. It's a filling, cheese-to-the-edge pie with mozzarella, fontina, parmesan and housemade ricotta.

About that ricotta. It’s not always right. Sometimes it’s a pile of rubbery curds instead of creamy, silky-sweet cheese. You’ll also find it as an accompaniment to the fungi sott’olio, an ambitious dish that's not quite right. In three orders over three visits they were served in little Ball jars, swimming in liquid -- and bland. Kudos for the attempt, since it's very expensive and challenging to make in a traditional manner. The blistered gem salad is also underwhelming despite flavorful anchovy vinaigrette, grana padano and peppers. I can go on, but you get the gist. For as many wonderful dishes here, there are a handful that pale in comparison.

Service is worth noting, as it’s clear general manager Chris Clark has focused on the details in training the staff. Mr. Clark moved here from New York after several years at the iconic WD-50, which will close at the end of the month. Though I’ve visited when service is perfectly graceful, there are occasional missteps. On one visit, I felt like I was dining with my server, who told me which dishes her boyfriend likes, course for course. During another visit at a different table, a server and a diner staged a tug-of-war with a plate of pasta she hadn't finished.

Advertise with us

Here’s my advice for your next Mezzo visit. Order well. And be gentle. Like all newish restaurants, it’s working out the kinks. For the moment, it’s my favorite place to dine Downtown.

One more thing. Save room for dessert from pastry chef Erin Ribo, formerly of Restaurant Echo in Cranberry. Her desserts sing, though pear brulee tart is my favorite. And served with the check, those almond brownie cookies -- her grandmother's recipe -- steal the show.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart