Where else can you get a meatball bigger than a softball? At Alla Famiglia, it arrives in a red sea of marinara, stuffed with mozzarella then covered with a blanket of provolone and garnished with a dash of chopped parsley. It's pillowy soft but still comes with a giant steak knife.

When you see a plate like this, you half expect to hear Dean Martin's "That's Amore" in the background and a guy with a pinkie ring at the next table offering you a sip from his bottle of Sambuca.

Alla Famiglia

804 E. Warrington Ave.

Advertise with us

Allentown

412-488-1440

allafamiglia.com

  • Hours: 5 p.m. to last reservation, Monday through Saturday.
  • Basics: A charming destination restaurant, Alla Famiglia offers Italian-American classic dishes in huge portions of quality ingredients.
  • Recommended dishes: hot peppers, assorted antipasti, calamari and shrimp, Alla Famiglia meatball, cacio e pepe, tagliatelli ala ragu, linguini del mare, veal chop Milanese, veal chop pizzaiolo, cotoletta del Monzu.
  • Prices: Stuzzicarelli $12-$16; maccheroni $28-$48; secondi corso $38-$78.
  • Summary: Parking lot, $15 split plate charge; $15 corkage.

Red-sauce restaurants are popular again in cities around the country, driven by the opening of places like Manhattan's Carbone. With shrimp scampi, spicy rigatoni vodka, pork chops and peppers or veal parmesan, these restaurants serve delicious nostalgia with a side of irony.

But Pittsburgh is earnest. And the enthusiasm for red-sauce restaurants has never waned here. As the American South celebrates shrimp and grits or collards with potlikker, Italian-American cuisine is the food of the city's past and present.

Advertise with us

Back in the heyday, it must have seemed like every neighborhood had a red-sauce restaurant. But tastes change and such institutions have been dying out, as demonstrated by the closing over the past couple of years of Tambellini's Downtown, Minutello's in Shadyside and Davio in Beechview.

Yet their demise doesn't point to a loss of appetite for Italian-American cuisine, just a craving for it in more lively spaces. Count Alla Famiglia among the stalwarts that are not only hanging on, but also flourishing. The house-turned restaurant that opened in 1998 in Allentown supersizes the glory of Italian-American food.

While restaurants open at a breakneck clip in the neighborhoods below this hilltop destination, chef-owner Jonathan Vlasic, who bought the business in 2005 at age 28, isn't stymied by competition as he grows the business like an Italian family. He added the upstairs Trenta cocktail lounge as well as a patio and is in the process of expanding to the property next door. His second, more casual, restaurant in a former schoolhouse, Arlecchino, opened in Peters in 2011, and in 2013, he opened his residence and working farm to include an event space.

Upon arrival to Alla Famiglia, diners sit in one of two wallpapered rooms at four-tops dressed in white tablecloths. Before the food even arrives the center is overloaded with things to try. A dish of Frantoia new-crop olive oil sits next to another one with hot peppers. A bowl with chickpeas, peppers and provolone tucks beside a goat cheese and olive spread. Bread arrives warm. If only it were better.

But all these dishes are reminders that you should sit with a mixture of anticipation and trepidation, because you will likely eat so much you may hate yourself by the end. Don't forget that every dish arrives with a hearty salad with gorgonzola, dressed in red wine vinaigrette, followed by a heaping serving of pasta alla vodka, each serving enough for a family of four.

Advertise with us

Back to starters. In addition to the meatball, plan on the carciofi ghiotta, with imported artichokes, tomato, capers, steeped raisins, garlic and pignoli nuts or alternatively, the trifolata of mushrooms, raisins, currants and Marsala cream. Both dishes show off fine ingredients and a lovely interplay of flavors.

Cacio e pepe is a show, a special request that's not listed on the menu. People love to watch as a server stands over a cart with a giant wheel of pecorino, its center worn into a canyon from sessions of her twirling pasta. And yes, it's a bit schmaltzy, but isn't that why you're here?

This dish may look simple but is one of the hardest to make right, a balance of quality and quantity of ingredients -- cheese, pasta, salt and pepper -- and timing. Do it wrong and it's a starchy, sticky mess. You'll know a perfect plate when you see it, with cheese that evenly silkens every strand. (Some restaurants, like this one, add cream as a crutch.)

The other show is the veal chop, more for size than presentation. The $68 secondi that's 24 to 28 ounces, is larger and more decadent than any dish in town. Consider paying the $15 plate share fee or consider it dinner for the week.

Pounded to half an inch thick, the chef seasons it and dredges it in egg, followed by flour and bread crumbs and fries the chop in clarified butter. It's finished in the oven and baked to medium. The Milanese chop is served on the bone with a garnish of pine nuts, green onions, jumbo lump crab meat and shaved Parmesan. And it's available in two other variations, as the pizzaiola, with San Marzanos, peppers, sausage, onions and provolone, and griglia, stuffed with ham, provolone and sage, grilled and finished with mushrooms and a demi-glace reduction.

Advertise with us

The sleeper dish is the cotoletta del Monzu, a less brawny veal serving pounded thin, pan fried and served with fresh mozzarella, pine nuts, lemon butter and arugula.

A few side notes. If you care about Italian wines, reds in particular, prepare to splurge on wine such as an elegant Barbaresco (Produttori del Barbaresco 2007) or a rich Barolo (Elvio Cogno, Ravera 2006). The list also suggests an array of Sicilians that have raised their profile in recent years.

The service usually starts at a fluid clip, although it slacks as the meal progresses. A server hands a gentleman a knife by the blade, for example. The water glasses aren't filled. A table forgot its leftovers when it couldn't find a server to retrieve them. But there's a warmth that feels familial.

During the four times I visited, I saw Mr. Vlasic once. But no matter. Like that Dean Martin song, the cooks at Alla Famiglia know the dishes by heart.