The universal appeal of the diner is what’s pushing its comeback during this era of straightforward fare. It’s why James Beard-nominated Big Bad Breakfast is popular down in Oxford, Miss., and Birmingham, Ala.  And it’s why the affordable Blue Collar in Miami strikes a chord with comfort food and booze.

But a diner need not have a fancy brand to build loyalty. Diners, like Bob’s Diner in the Pittsburgh area, are the workhorse of the restaurant industry.

Bob Marshall opened and closed two of his diners before he fully committed to them. It took the memory of his father and a bout with cancer to persuade him to fully make the switch.

In 1998, he opened Bob’s Diner on Noblestown Road in Green Tree and closed it after three years. His heart wasn’t in it when his father died in 2000. “I lost my spark,” he said. His father helped nurture his love for diners when his family moved to Fort Lauderdale, Fla., in the ’70s and they became regulars at a 25-seat place called Louie’s. Again in 2003, Mr. Marshall opened and closed a restaurant in a former Greek place he renamed the Bellevue Diner after the neighborhood.

Advertise with us

In both scenarios, he wasn’t yet ready to give up his corporate gig that started with Hallmark Cards. “I realized I couldn’t work two jobs,” he said.

After he beat cancer in 2008, Mr. Marshall tried again, opening a Bob’s Diner in Kennedy in 2009. This time he took to it. He followed it up with locations in Carnegie in 2011 and the newest one on Painters Run Road on the border of Scott and Upper St. Clair in July. Mr. Marshall also owned a diner in Imperial in 2010 and turned it over to a former manager, Stephanie Schofield, in April. He decided on each of his restaurants by staking out spots to monitor traffic patterns during breakfast, lunch and dinner hours. If the area was bustling during the day and there was a need for a breakfast or lunch place, he moved ahead with plans.

Bob’s Diners are traditional, with an updated ingredient or two. The eggs are especially fresh, with marigold-yellow yolks, part of breakfast served all day. Beyond breakfast, Mr. Marshall serves the food he grew up on: pork chops, meatloaf sandwiches and a homemade chicken soup. In the Carnegie and Painters Run locations, he also offers Thanksgiving dinner every Tuesday, which includes a plate of roast turkey with gravy, salad, coleslaw or soup, cranberries, sweet potatoes, mashed potatoes and “real stuffing,” for less than $12.

Mr. Marshall likes diners for the range of clientele they tend to draw, from day laborers to the tuxedo-clad after a formal affair. At 10 a.m. on a Tuesday in the South Hills, it’s a local crowd taking a break from the workday along with retirees. Most of the seats were taken among the booths and at the L-shaped counter with retro-looking high-backed stools. Stainless steel outfits an open kitchen. A sunny mural decorates a back wall. Mr. Marshall invested $100,000 into the space that had formerly been a windowless beauty parlor, a karate studio and a furniture store.

He has a total of 72 employees, many of whom have been with him since his first diner. Gary Reinert Jr., the general manager, oversees the three locations. He started three years ago as a consultant, after being directed there by his wife, a former server at Ruth’s Chris Steakhouse, Downtown, who was asking around to help find a job for her husband. Mr. Reinert was the former owner of Seventh Street Grille, Downtown, and had also run the now-closed Hot Metal Grille on the South Side.

Advertise with us

“This is a very family-oriented place,” he said. “It takes a certain quality of person to work here: someone who is sincere.”

Mr. Marshall said his wife, Dane, and his children, Claire and John Robert, have also worked at the restaurants. (He hosts a radio program with his daughter, “The Bob’s Diner Radio Show,” from 7 to 8 p.m. on KQV 1410 AM every other Wednesday.) Having the family help with the business takes him back to Louie’s in Florida, to his parents 40 years ago. “It felt good. It smelled good. This is what I really like.”

Of the stop-start nature of finally making a go of running diners, he said, “Some things take awhile.”

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.