The Economist Intelligence Unit has once again rated Pittsburgh as the most livable city in the continental U.S., as part of the unit’s 2014 annual livability survey.
The viability of food establishments and restaurants is an essential contributor to a city’s growth and appeal.
Although Pittsburgh’s recent restaurant boom points to a robust industry, not everything is rosy. In fact, I think we’re headed for a shakeout.
Here’s why. There’s an increasing tension between value and style, between old Pittsburgh and new Pittsburgh.
I see it in new restaurants with $15 cocktails and fancy dishes assembled by cooks with the same skill set as guys making wings in dive bars selling $3 drafts.
More customers are getting fleeced by restaurants charging breathtaking prices that would be expensive in expensive cities, particularly when it comes to drinks.
They’re also paying more at Pittsburgh’s farmers markets and specialty food shops because the demand, infrastructure or competition hasn’t fully developed.
How do we know? Their prices are often higher than they are at Dupont Circle’s Freshfarm Market in Washington, D.C., and in some cases at Union Square Market in New York. Yet the farmers and shop owners here are still struggling financially. Neil Stauffer, general manager for Penn’s Corner Farm Alliance told me he consults with 35 farmers in his network to develop niche products so they can make money.
There are many signs that restaurants are feeling the pinch. Some owners have told me as much. Some restaurants are scaling back menus, ingredient costs and portion sizes. Some restaurants have started lunch service to bring in additional customers.
Here’s another factor that’s become more of an issue since I moved here two years ago: The city doesn’t have the labor force to support all of these restaurants.
There are two reasons for this. With the closing of Le Cordon Bleu College of Culinary Arts in 2011, fewer people are going from classroom to the kitchen.
And while a handful of people are moving here to open restaurants, the industry continues to lose highly trained people such as Bob Broskey; the former sous chef at Notion in East Liberty has gone to Chicago’s highly regarded L20. It’s why the young wine guru Sarah Thomas, formerly of Bar Marco, will move to New York to work as a sommelier for a concept from Eric Ripert of Le Bernardin. They’re looking for jobs at which they can hone their knowledge and find a community that will push them. It’s not here yet.
Pittsburgh restaurants also are strapped because the area has such a small immigrant population and of that group few are here to work in restaurants. Yet they’re the backbone of the industry in flourishing cities of comparable size and larger.
The next phase may be a string of restaurant closures in the city limits. I’m not the only one who’s anticipating this. At least five restaurant owners have come to me hand-wringing over the future of their businesses. Some restaurateurs have casually asked me when I think restaurants are going to close.
For now we need to look at the many things Pittsburgh does well and capitalize on that instead of mimicking what works in other cities.
Real talk is the only way Pittsburgh will become a national dining destination. More open conversation can lead to sustainable growth, as opposed to a blip that props up the city for the short term.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.