On April 16, the first day of the statewide trout season, a fisherman lugged a stringer of trout along a new section of trail hugging Turtle Creek on the Westmoreland-Allegheny county line. The Westmoreland Heritage Trail eventually will link to the Great Allegheny Passage trail, but for now the unfinished path just makes it easier for anglers to access the water.

“I hate it,” said Todd, from nearby Trafford, his fish dripping onto his boots. “I have a good spot back there that most don’t go to because it’s too hard to get to. This year I come up early and already there’s guys there. This trail opened up this valley, and now everybody’s going to come.”

Todd asked that his last name not be published because, he said, “some of my neighbors probably like [the trail].” But he’s not alone in resisting the development of new rails-to-trails projects. Initial opposition is so common, said one veteran trail developer, it’s “practically routine.”

“That has been the history of the whole Great Allegheny Passage,” said Linda McKenna Boxx, former president and current board secretary of the Allegheny Trail Alliance, which maintains the Great Allegheny Passage and the Montour Trail. “A lot of times, people in rural areas just want things to stay the way they are, and it takes a while for them to get used to all the new faces.”

Advertise with us

Some people in larger communities — she mentioned Meyersdale, Somerset County — get excited about the social and commercial opportunities brought by bicyclists. But Ms. McKenna Boxx can rattle off stories about challenging times during the 30-year development of the Great Allegheny Passage.

“What happens is a culture clash. The local people see the trail connecting them to places where people do things differently. The expensive bikes, all the gear — they don’t know what to expect,” she said.

She remembers attending a public meeting where a person said that someone on a bicycle would break into his house and steal his television.

“The people who are using the trail are outdoors enthusiasts,” she said. “Happy, well-educated, prosperous. They’re there to enjoy the recreational aspect, not to make trouble in the local community.”

In Fayette County, 2 miles have been laid of the future 34-mile Sheepskin Trail that will cross Fayette County and link to Great Allegheny Passage.

Advertise with us

“People were a little apprehensive,” said Donna Holdorf, executive director of the National Road Heritage Corridor, which is shepherding project. “Who are these bikers? Will they urinate on my driveway? Will I be picking up trash forever? We have NIMBYs for sure. There are problems in Dunbar with vandals tearing out a split-rail fence, ripping out a sign.”

When the Westmoreland Heritage Trail is finished, the defensive angler will share his spot with bikers traveling 22 miles from Saltsburg, Indiana County, to Trafford on the Allegheny County line.

“We have the same slow transition with some of the people riding their quads on the new section from Trafford to Murrysville,” said Jeff Richards of Westmoreland County Parks and Recreation. “But they eventually come around. The first 5 miles from Saltsburg to Slickville opened in 2008, and it’s fine now. People get used to the traffic.”

Some entrepreneurs count on the economic development brought by the trails. When what is now a section of the Great Allegheny Passage originally opened near West Newton, local kids blocked the trail, threw rocks at riders and egged them from an overpass. But at the Yough Twister ice cream stand, across the street from the bike path, the new customers were welcome. Three years ago, its owners spun off the Driscoll & Sons Cafe next to the ice cream stand.

“Right now, 25 percent of my restaurant business comes off the trail for lunch,” said co-owner Justin Richel. “At a lot of places’ restrooms are for patrons only, but we welcome everybody. Some bikers come in and don’t buy anything and we’re not 100 percent happy about that, but we don’t want any bad vibes.”

Advertise with us

Most trail developers learn, said Ms. McKenna Boxx, that most people eventually learn to get along.

“The communities start having festivals along the trail and selling food and things to drink to the bikers and their neighbors,” she said. “Bikers come for the charm of the neighborhood, and the local people get that and begin to accept them.”

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.