Oakland is a sea of buildings, some tall, some short, including single-family homes and a towering medical center sheathed in glass, as well as apartment buildings adjacent to cathedrals with patches of green in between.
Then there is 540 N. Neville St.
Designed by Herbert Seigle and built in 1972, The Winchester is a mammoth structure wrapped in 9-by-9-inch jade-colored tiles that is hard to ignore. The building stands out in a good way and appears to covered in ivy in the right light.
The design was considered a bold departure from traditional architecture and featured contemporary design on the interior. It has been well-maintained over the years and, in many ways, is very on trend with the current love of mid-century modern aesthetics.
“What attracted me to it was that tile,” said Kathy McCallister, owner of Apt. 303. “It was like ‘Where did you come from? You look like you’ve lost your way. What are you doing here in the midst of all this?’”
Her two-bedroom, two-bath condominium was renovated by the previous owner, blending the living and dining areas into an open floorplan that is illuminated by tall windows.
McCallister said its 1,680 square feet of living space was perfect after living in a larger home in the suburbs. Now, after four years, she has put it on the market for $365,000 with Gina Giampietro of RE/MAX Select Realty (remax.com or 412-606-4842). The homeowners association fee is $964 per month, with no pets or subletting allowed.
The kitchen has stainless-steel appliances from the GE Profile line and a U-shaped layout. The upper cabinets feature glass doors and the lower cabinets are topped with granite. The flooring is tile, a change from the bamboo floors found in the rest of the condominium. A large closet holds mechanicals and offers more storage.
The primary bedroom includes two closets and an ensuite bath with a walk-in, tiled shower and a double sink. The other bathroom has a tub and shower combination. According to the previous owner, it was never used, so it is in excellent condition.
“It has big rooms, I’ll tell you. I didn’t need all this space,” McCallister said. “I could have gone with maybe 900 [square feet], so they’re spacious.”
Topping the nine-story building is a spacious roof deck for residents’ use with panoramic views of Oakland and the Downtown skyline.
Condo services and amenities include indoor 24-hour valet parking with two spaces per unit, trash pickup, basic cable, a storage locker and an exercise room. The Winchester also has an indoor pool and sauna. The HOA fee also covers common area maintenance, security and building insurance.
The laundry is currently located in a utility room that is shared with another unit. However, there are laundry hookups in the condo’s hall closet.
McCallister also noted that a guest apartment is available to residents for a minimal fee. It has come in handy when her football-loving family comes to town.
She loves walking and exploring her neighborhood and will miss wandering in Shadyside and Oakland. She will also miss the convenience of a city lifestyle that doesn’t require a car.
“The reason I moved here, and this is true, this is a place that has everything you want within walking distance … except like, a Giant Eagle,” she said. “I moved to Oakland from the suburbs with the idea that I could walk everywhere.”
The Allegheny County property assessment is $163,400. Over the last two years, 11 units have sold in The Winchester for prices ranging from $100,000 in March 2025 to $475,000 in April 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us)
The Winchester is close to Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh, both of which offer classes for seniors through the Osher Lifelong Learning Institute. Schenley Park, Carnegie Museums and the main branch of the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh are also within walking distance.
“If I walk up two blocks, I’m in Shadyside. In the summer or spring, whenever it’s nice, I can walk around and see all these big old houses and their beautiful grounds. It’s a nice walk, really level,” McCallister said.
She said the homeowners association does not allow rentals, short-term or long, and is very strict about that. She feels it helps the place maintain its value, and she’s happy about that.
“Once you get people renting, they move in and out a lot. People tend to stay here long. I’m like a baby here in terms of years. Some have been here for 30 or 40 years.”
She also enjoys the social atmosphere.
“They don’t have official things like some have. What they have here are people who like that kind of stuff,” McCallister said.
“How I met people was on the elevator. I’m friendly, and they would say, ‘Come on down. We’re having a little brunch.’”
McCallister said she is leaving only because of a health issue, and is moving closer to her family.
“The kids are concerned about me, but I wouldn’t be moving out of here if it wasn’t for that.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.