For Mary Beth Pastorius, the building at 136 E. High St. in Waynesburg is more than bricks, mortar and glass. It is a story of families, a small town's past and possibly, its future.

“I’m a historian and I love history, which is why I bought the house,” she said. “It’s really a love story about a house and giving back to my hometown and all its history.”

She grew up in Waynesburg and went to Penn State University, where she met Pennsylvania Brewing Co. founder Tom Pastorius, who died in 2012. The couple lived in Germany for eight years, then returned to Western Pennsylvania and settled in Sewickley.

“We bought a historic house in Sewickley, and I guess that was the start of my becoming interested in preservation,” she said.

Advertise with us

That love of architectural history led them to purchase two 19th-century properties in Waynesburg, where she grew up.

“A little less than 20 years after we started [the brewery], Tom said, ‘Honey, you’ve paid your dues. Now you can do whatever you want.’

“I said I didn’t want to be retired at that point, and I said, ‘I’ve always wanted to buy an old building in a historic town.’”

So they bought two very old buildings in the heart of the borough, the county seat of Greene County.

“They’re one block from the courthouse and two blocks from the university, so location, location, location,” Pastorius said.

Advertise with us

The first one, the Hook-Morgan Building, was bought at a sheriff’s sale, and the second one, Ganiear House, was bought at a treasurer’s sale.

Both were in desperate need of repair. And while it wasn’t possible to do a historical restoration, the buildings have been preserved for posterity. Now, 18 years after the work began, one is on the market.

“Time for the younger generation to take what I have created and go the distance with it,” she said.

The property at 136 E. High St. in Waynesburg is listed for $300,000 (MLS No. 1674153) with Joelynne Scalzo-Koury, an agent with Dan McCown & Co. Inc. (crexi.com or 724-944-5569).

The Pastoriuses bought the Ganiear House after buying and beginning to restore the Hook-Morgan Building.

Advertise with us

“At that point, I was in Waynesburg every third day and every time I was at the Hook-Morgan Building, I would look across the street at the Ganiear House,” she said. “So when it came up for treasurer’s sale, I bought it.”

The Ganiear House is next to the Ganiear Building, known by many in Waynesburg as the Floral Building because it was used as a flower shop.

Cabinet maker James Ganiear and his wife, Rebecca, purchased the house from the estate of William Crawford in 1847, according to Pastorius’ research (viewable at Waynesburg Matters).

Ganiear’s descendants lived in the home until 1976.

Pastorius was delighted to discover she had a connection to the family.

Advertise with us

“I am distantly related, descended from James Ganiear’s wife, Rebecca Johnson,” she said, noting that she told the family.

“They were thrilled, absolutely thrilled.”

For the first couple of years, the couple spent most of their time “removing all the bad stuff,” including a 20-foot addition with bedrooms that had no windows. It was expensive work.

“Tom had a great one-liner. He said, after we had the buildings for one year, and we were really into the rehabbing: ‘There’s nothing more expensive than a cheap building in Waynesburg.’”

This is a mixed-use, commercial/residential building and is part of the Waynesburg Historic District. The home was originally Colonial but is now Italianate, with wide eaves and tall, narrow windows. The front door, framed by side windows and a transom, is centrally located in the facade of handmade bricks.

Advertise with us

Flanking either side of the wide entrance hall are two sets of pocket doors, a discovery made by the Pastoriuses during the renovation. One set had been hidden behind earlier renovations for unknown reasons.

On the second floor are two one-bedroom apartments with fully equipped kitchens and a balcony that runs the length of the building, with stairs leading to the rear parking area. Included in the sale is a 2½-story barn at the rear of the lot with additional living space.

“The barn also sheltered the family cow, horse, buggy and even a horse-drawn hearse,” Pastorius wrote in her blog. “The hearse was necessary because, in addition to making furniture, the Ganiears were undertakers.”

Pastorius has rented the barn to contractors working on the building.

“It was nice to have boots on the ground,” she said. “One person can’t do buildings like this. I had a wonderful team.”

Advertise with us

That team included Bill Whitlatch, the contractor who worked with her throughout the project,; architect Ken Kulak, who understood the historical building code with all its particular needs and requirements; and Fred Smith, co-founder of Allegheny Millwork & Lumber on the South Side.

Smith “speced every door, every piece of hardware, every lock, every hinge,” Pastorius said.

Waynesburg is more than her hometown. It is a keystone that locks all the pieces together. She credits people like archivist Candice Buchanan, the staff at the Cornerstone Genealogical Society and the Greene County Historical Society for their hard work in preserving her beloved Waynesburg.