When Oren and Rena Levy were thinking about moving in 2014, Pittsburgh was not on their radar.
They were living in Queens, N.Y., and wanted a city that was affordable and a good place to raise their children. A chance conversation with a friend sent them in a new direction, to a city they knew only for steel mills and football.
“Somebody who lived around the corner from us was from Pittsburgh,” recalled Mr. Levy. “And he was the one who said, ‘Did you think about Squirrel Hill in Pittsburgh? It’s kind of like what you were describing.’
“At the time I laughed at him and I said, ‘It’s like dead down there.’”
Then he did a bit of digging, and he liked what he found.
The house at 6429 Bartlett St. in Squirrel Hill didn’t initially interest him because it lacked one thing he especially wanted.
“When this house came on the market in 2014, I originally nixed it because there was no driveway. It was in the right area, so quiet and peaceful and close to everything. My wife said, ‘Let’s just check it out. Maybe there’s ample on-street parking. Let’s just give it a shot.”
When they visited, they fell in love with the house.
“We spoke to the neighbors on each side and they said there was always ample parking and for the past 11 years, very rarely we are unable to park in front of our house. On rare occasions we may have to park a few spots down,” he said.
“When it snows in New York, you start digging out your car, and you have a line of people waiting to take your spot. Here, in Pittsburgh, everyone is so respectful. You dig out your spot and you put a chair there and nobody even thinks twice.”
With life changes, the Levys have decided it's time to sell the home with seven bedrooms, three full baths, one powder room and a remodeled basement. It’s listed for $750,000 (MLS No. 1696647) with Andrea Ehrenreich of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (howardhanna.com or 412-327-7665).
One of the biggest projects the couple took on was the basement; the large area followed the footprint of the home, but was not the most welcoming of spaces.
“We turned it from one of those old Pittsburgh dungeons into a beautiful playroom for our kids,” said Mr. Levy.
It wasn’t a quick project, but the timing couldn’t have been better — a year before the COVID-19 pandemic began.
“Before we finished the basement, we installed a French drain and a sump pump. And once we had that for a year — we went a year with no water infiltration — we redid the whole basement, the carpeting, the laundry room. That was a big project.”
That basement became a favorite space for the Levy family, with enough room for study and to toss around a ball. The large fenced-in backyard became a playground that came with a history lesson that their daughter discovered one afternoon.
“During COVID, we would go to the backyard every day after virtual school. One day, my daughter found a metal coin holder, and there was one coin in the holder, a dime. We washed it off with vinegar and a toothbrush, and it was from 1911,” Mr. Levy recalled.
“We envisioned the original owners of the house or maybe the workers who were building it, having a smoke break, schmoozing, and dropping the coin. Then, over a hundred years later, we found it.”
The couple believes the house dates to 1914. It features beautiful stained-glass windows in the living room, on the stair landing and in several of the bedrooms. Mr. Levy’s grandmother, who passed away at the age of 101, believed they were by Tiffany Studios.
The house also features original woodwork in the foyer, a series of arched doorways and an ornate, curved balustrade on the stairs that leads to the half landing with its large stained-glass window.
The first floor, including a large formal dining room, features original oak flooring. Thinner planks are laid out in designs that are hard to find, with planks running the perimeter framing the center of the room. There are four chimney stacks; three have been closed, but the one in the living room is open and could be used for the fireplace.
The eat-in kitchen has granite countertops, an island, a tiled backsplash and many cabinets. Most of the appliances have been replaced in the last four or five years, and include an LG refrigerator, a Whirlpool gas range with an over-the-stove microwave and an LG dishwasher. The LG washer and dryer in the basement were purchased earlier this year.
The table in one corner of the room was installed by the previous owner, a home inspector, so it is tied into the staircase, with a ledge.
Other major projects included creating a primary suite, adding air-conditioning to the third floor and revamping the primary bathroom on the second floor.
“It probably hadn’t been done since the 1960s,” said Mr. Levy. “We updated that bathroom right before COVID, adding a built-in vanity with marble countertop, and redid the shower/bath combination. It had a clawfoot tub from the 1930s. We tried to sell it, but it seemed everybody in Pittsburgh has a clawfoot tub — no market.”
A closet and new carpet was added to their daughter’s bedroom, which is painted a shade of pink that complements bay windows topped with a stained-glass transom.
The couple hired an Amish craftsman to create cabinets in the primary bedroom, which also has a walk-in shower with a bench.
“We just recently installed air-conditioning on the third floor, a mini split unit, and the dropped ceiling,” said Mr. Levy.
The third floor includes three bedrooms and a bathroom and offers potential for a home offices or media/craft rooms.
“The water tank is brand new, just had it replaced this last winter. The AC was replaced two years ago and the furnace three years ago, so that’s pretty updated,” said Mr. Levy.
While not new, he believes the roof was replaced in 2002 and he has had it inspected each year.
The 2025 Allegheny County assessment is $391,000 and annual taxes are $9,009. Over the last five years, five homes have sold in the 6400 block of Bartlett Street for prices ranging from $335,000 in August 2020 to $695,000 for houses sold in October and November 2021 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).
“I can’t speak enough about the location. It’s so quiet and so close to everything, the best of both worlds,” said Mr. Levy.
Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.