Jake Wheatley knew he had found the house he was looking for when he started imagining where he would put his Christmas tree.
Five years ago, he saw something in this Queen Anne Victorian that he hadn’t seen in the other houses he had toured, something special.
“I think the number one thing was the character of the house, especially at the time, nothing like that — character you could see,” he said.
But the time has come for Wheatley to move closer to his family and so he’s listed 143 4th St. in McDonald, Washington County, for $300,000 (MLS No. 1617548) with Matt Swab of Piatt Sotheby’s International Realty (412-822-6700 or www.143fourth.com). The property is under contract.
The four-bedroom, 2½-bath was build on a large corner lot and is wrapped on two sides with a wide covered porch that looks out over a landscaped front and side yard.
The house, built in the late 1800s, features a steep roof with cross gables, a polygonal tower and asymmetrical façade. Wheatley says he is only its third owner.
“The original family had nine children, and the youngest child lived there his whole life,” he said. “Once he passed, the owner before me started to reconfigure the home back to what it had been.”
Harry Collins, the son of the original family, turned it into a multi-family house and lived there his whole life.
“Luckily, my next-door neighbor — some called her the town historian — shared some of the home’s history with me,” Wheatley said.
She told him Collins donated a lot to the community, including funds for the tennis court right down the street.
Part of what attracted Wheatley to the home was original details like the deep moldings and high ceilings. The previous owner had already turned it from a multi-family dwelling back to a single-family home.
“It wasn’t quite restored, so there were certain things left to do. I could put my stamp on it,” Wheatley said.
Part of that entailed painting rooms in shades of green, blue and yellow, a Victorian palette and a nice change from the neutrals that dominate the residential market today.
The first floor is spacious with an interesting floor plan. There are individual rooms, but the layout seems open plan, in a way. Wide passageways blend one room into another, spreading light across the first floor while connecting the spaces at the same time.
Two front parlors could both be used as the living room. Right now, one is home to Wheatley’s grand piano and the other is set up as a family room. Off that room is what some may call a three-season room.
“My inner ‘Golden Girls’ fan is always calling it a lanai,” Wheatley said with a laugh.
Three-season or not, he always keeps the interior doors open for Christmas parties since it is warm enough for winter guests to enjoy.
Another unique room is tucked away in what, at one time, was part of one of the upstairs apartments and can only be accessed from the master bedroom.
Call it a home office or a den, it’s Wheatley’s sanctuary of sorts on the third floor. The ceiling curves around the roofline and dormer windows flood the room with light. It is easy to imagine being curled up on a couch with a cup of tea in hand and reading a favorite book in this hideaway.
Wheatley says the owners of several other houses in the neighborhood have created third-floor bedrooms in their attics. That is an option, but it seems a shame to lose such a wonderful space.
Down a set of stairs, the master suite includes a large walk-in closet and three-piece bathroom with a shower-tub combination. It’s not a large bathroom, but it’s nicely decorated and carries on the feeling that this is a private suite.
There are three more bedrooms on the second floor, two with carpeting and one with newer wood flooring. There is a family bathroom and the laundry in the hallway.
Wheatley did discover original wood flooring on the second floor. Sadly, when the house was converted to apartments, the wood flooring bore the brunt of the conversion. He said the upstairs flooring situation is “unpredictable” at best.
“I would be curious as to what you would do [with the second floor]. You would have to replace the center [of the floors] in most of the rooms,” he said.
That’s not the case downstairs. The last owner put in hardwood flooring that runs through the living and family rooms into the entryway, down the hall to the dining room and on into the kitchen.
The U-shaped kitchen has white Shaker-style cabinets, granite countertops and newer stainless-steel appliances that include a nearly new dishwasher, a French door refrigerator with a bottom freezer and a ceramic top range with a microwave/fan combination above.
There is a powder room on the first floor and a decorative fireplace in one of the two parlors.
Wheatley said the one he refers to as a family room is a very special place in the early evening.
“My favorite time of day is right when it’s just getting to sunset,” he said. “You can have all the lights off and enjoy the evening light coming in.”
Outside is a partially fenced yard and a detached three-car garage.
The last owner did the shingle roof; Wheatley believes it’s about 15 years old. The unfinished basement beneath all but the three-season room.
The house has aluminum siding and forced-air gas heat. Half of the double-paned windows were replaced in the last 10 years.
The property assessment is $39,600, according to Property Shark.
It’s a short walk to the shopping area with a pizza shop, Giant Eagle and a local favorite, M.A.’s Ice Cream Shop. Heritage Park is a few blocks over and there is easy access to the new Southern Beltway and Interstate 79.
So where would someone put a Christmas tree?
Wheatley said any of the first-floor ceilings can easily accommodate a 9-foot tree.
Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.