Tucked between two apartment buildings, 5935 Fifth Ave. in Shadyside is affectionately known as the Storybook House.

Author and co-owner Elizabeth Rodenz has held writing groups at the house and did a lot of her writing there. Her latest book is “Josephine: A Woman of Indomitable Spirit” (ER, $23.99)

“It was inspired by my great grandmother and the coal patches of Western Pennsylvania,” she said.

The 95-year-old house was a perfect gathering place for storytellers, according to Rodenz.

Advertise with us

“I just like gathering people around the table and letting them have a voice, you know?”

Six members of the writing group contributed stories and poems to the 2022 book “Collected Writings From the Storybook House.”

“The house just has a creative spirit,” she said.

Rodenz and her husband, David Baker, have lived in the four-bedroom, 3½-bath house for nearly seven years and have listed it for $1.35 million (MLS No. 1591319) with Aaron Garland of RE/MAX Select Realty (remax.com or 412-475-8388).

The house was built in 1928 by a doctor, who used the ground floor as his office. He and his family lived on the upper two floors, making for a very easy commute to work.

Advertise with us

“His waiting room included the fireplace, which is still there, and his examining room was on the other side,” explained Rodenz.

“We call this our upside-down house,” she added with a laugh.

“We have a wonderful kitchen with a butler’s pantry on the second floor with a 1954 Chalmers red enamel gas oven. It is phenomenal.”

The bonus of living on the second and third floors is all the sunlight streaming through the large windows.

“I loved the fact that we are in light and the rooms are big,” Rodenz noted. “I also love that the house is elegance and charm combined with coziness and warmth.”

Advertise with us

The four fireplaces contribute to that feeling. All work but the one on the first floor, now part of a guest bedroom, is not used.

“It’s not used, but it is wood-burning,” she said.

The second-floor dining room fireplace and the one in the third-floor bedroom fireplace were both converted to gas. “You just hit the button.”

The living room fireplace still burns wood.

“We wanted the ambiance of wood, especially around Christmas, and the smell of wood is wonderful,” Rodenz said.

Advertise with us

The couple added a powder room on the second floor and seamlessly installed an elevator. Though it’s perfect for aging in place, that wasn’t the reason they wanted it. When they moved in, they had an older dog who could not do stairs.

“We put in the elevator for our dogs. We are dog people and in fact two of my books are about dogs,” she said.

“We also thought it would be easier to get groceries up to the second floor. We made it big enough to get a wheelchair in and just thought it was a great investment, too.”

The elevator is two-sided so someone can enter from the front or rear of the house.

“Every improvement we made we were careful to keep the home’s original feeling rather than ripping everything out,” Rodenz said. “We did not want to lose the charm of the house.”

Advertise with us

The back garden is a favorite of cardinals and mourning doves. During the summer, the writing group would meet in the garden or on the deck.

“Everyone loves the garden,” she said.

The property assessment is $470,000. No single-family homes have sold in the 5900 block of Fifth Avenue since this one for $600,000 in October 2016 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/RealEstate/GeneralInfo.aspx?).

Rodenz, who is originally from Pittsburgh, moved to New York City to work for McGraw Hill Publishing in the 1980s. She then started her own consulting and executive coaching business and moved to San Francisco. After moving back to New York, she and her husband decided they wanted to live someplace more comfortable. That brought them to her hometown.

“David is from England,” Rodenz said. “I was comfortable and knew the city and I love Pitt, where I got all three of my degrees.”

Advertise with us

She taught writing and courses in Jungian psychology at Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh. Now the couple are planning a new adventure in western Mexico.

“I hate leaving the house, but it was time to downsize and do some things to change our life,” she said.

“I love that house and this is really hard for me, but I know this is what we need to do. It’s bittersweet.”

Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.