The U.S. housing market went for a wild ride in 2021, thanks to COVID-19, raging politics, low interest rates and a roller coaster year we’ll never forget.
Pittsburgh’s market was just as bumpy. From Lawrenceville to Beechview, Perry Hilltop to the South Side Slopes, properties sometimes sold within days of being listed for the asking price or more. Some lasted for a few months and sold for less — but not many.
Here’s a look at what happened to some of the city properties featured in Buying Here in 2021:

Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Joe Musgrove was traded to the San Diego Padres in January. For Musgrove that meant going home to California and selling his Lawrenceville condominium with spectacular views of the city. His condo was priced at $740,000 in June and sold in August for $700,000.

Like Musgrove, Jim Lucot loved urban living at his Downtown loft on Liberty Avenue. His condominium in the Cultural District offered easy access to restaurants and shows — when the pandemic wasn’t shrinking hours and forcing productions online. Lucot added to his loft’s industrial feel by refinishing its hardwood floors himself and was rewarded when he sold the condo listed in July for $289,900 in August for $288,000.

Heading up Liberty Avenue to the border of Polish Hill and the Upper Hill District, we found a house that was as colorful as it was earth-friendly, with lots of creative reuse. Laurel Coniglio wasn’t afraid to make some noise with vibrant paint on her two-story row house on quiet Ajax Street. It went on the market in April priced at $220,000 and sold in August for $172,500. She still misses this place. “I’ve moved to West Texas in the middle of nowhere, but Pittsburgh will always be my home,” she said.
Read More
This city has more postcard views from every angle than any other. In the North Side’s Perry Hilltop neighborhood, we found a condominium with a view that rivals some of Pittsburgh’s best. High school choral director Aaron Magill said it was the nighttime vistas from the huge deck that made him buy.

Ready to retire and move out west, he put his two-bedroom, two-bath condo on Clayton Avenue on the market for $189,900 in September. Not surprisingly it didn’t hang around long, selling for his asking price in mid-October. Now that’s a sweet tune.

University of Pittsburgh medical student Laura Marengo was in a hurry to sell her one-bedroom, one-bath condominium in the Glass Lofts in Garfield. She was about to graduate and start a residency at a Boston hospital.
Her two-floor condo was priced at $259,900 in April and sold for $243,990 in May, leaving her plenty of time to get to her new job in Boston. Bet she doesn’t have a Primanti Brothers restaurant on the ground floor of her new home!

One of the quickest sales in Buying Here this year was a charming red-brick house on Milan Avenue in Brookline. After the first open house, the owners received numerous offers and had a sales contract within a few days. It sold for $160,000, $5,000 over the asking price. Trista McMahon loved the magnolia tree in the front yard. “Watching my kids grow up, playing in that tree in the front yard, they used it a lot,” she said. Happily, their new home also has a big tree to climb.

Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods are filled with old houses that recall its history and sometimes the industrialists who lived there. The house at 820 Devonshire St. in Shadyside offers an opulent picture of the Gilded Age and was once owned by banker and philanthropist Benjamin Thaw Sr., whose infamous cousin Harry shot architect Stanford White in the early 1900s. The house has been carefully preserved even as the bathrooms and kitchens were updated. Priced just under $2 million in September, it sold for $1.76 million in November.

The new owners of 946 Davis Ave. in Brighton Heights picked the right time to move into the neighborhood as the city begins work on a new pedestrian and bike bridge linking Davis Avenue to Riverview Park on the North Side. The Craftsman-style bungalow, on the market in July for $250,000, sold for $240,000 later that month.

Lovers of modern homes may not think of Lawrenceville as a place to buy. But they would be delighted to visit 3932 Woolslayer Way. The three-story townhouse was designed by architect Justine Cipriani and developed by Jan Tisdale and Peggy Walkush. With open plan living and a rooftop, the house was on the market in April for $589,000 and sold for $575,000 in May.

Across the Allegheny River is the historic North Side neighborhood of Troy Hill. A Second Empire house on Harpster Street features both history and the creative touch of owner Felina Ami. She has planted thousands of bulbs and other plants to create “my garden sanctuary, my own secret garden.” A world unto itself, the home was on the market at $300,000 in October and is currently under agreement.
Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.