Five years ago, architect Bob Baumbach and his brother, Jeff, bought a North Side building that housed EJ’s Auto Parts for more than 60 years. The goal was to renovate it with reverence for the history of the building and the history of the surrounding Deutschtown neighborhood.

The three-story brick building was built in the 1870s in a neighborhood named for the German immigrants who settled there from 1850 to 1900. The first floor of the building at 424 Suismon St. is still a storefront; 412 Apothecary has sold hair and skincare products, candles and gifts there since July 2020.

The Baumbachs have turned the upper floors into a two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment that will be available Oct. 1. The 1,150-square-foot apartment rents for $2,100 per month.

The architect, who grew up in Ross, moved to Deutschtown in 2000 and has his office in a former blacksmith’s shop on Middle Street. Working as an architect for 16 years, he estimates that about half of his business is redesigns and rehabs on the North Side. One of his first clients was Mark McCormick, who brought along his 3-year-old son Malcolm when he visited Baumbach’s studio.

Advertise with us

That little boy grew up to become Mac Miller, the late Pittsburgh-born rapper. In January 2020, before 412 Apothecary moved in, about 3,000 people came to a party in this storefront to launch Miller’s posthumous album, “Circles.” Portraits and photos of the Allderdice High School alumnus were displayed on the exposed-brick walls.

The exterior of the building, which Baumbach said is Victorian with some Italianate touches, retains many original details The only bricks that were not painted blue are those on the side, which still bears a painted sign for EJ’s Auto Parts.

“When we were renovating, neighbors asked us to keep the EJ signs,” Bauman said. “It was important to a lot of people. We talked about having an artist touch it up, but we decided to leave it as it is, with the original fading and chipped paint.”

The apartment has some of the old architectural elements but is also very modern. The general contractor was Kevin Lager of Lager Construction. Greg Janney installed the floors, quarter-sawn white oak supplied by Allegheny Mountain Hardwood Flooring in Emlenton, Pa. Paul McDonnell, a friend of Baumbach’s, fabricated and installed the steel staircase that links the second and third floors.

Because the building is on the end, the apartment gets lots of sunlight from 12 new thermal windows that face south and east. There is a south-facing terrace/balcony on the third floor, accessed by French doors.

Advertise with us

The kitchen has quartz counter tops. The bathrooms have ceramic tile.

There is a washer and dryer in one of the bedrooms. The electrical and plumbing systems are new, as is the furnace and central air conditioning. The entire building has spray foam insulation that increases energy efficiency and lowers utility bills.

One off-street parking space is available for $100 per month.

The neighborhood has many bars, restaurants and shops nearby. Deutschtown, a national and city historic district, is a 15-minute walk from Downtown. Also within walking distance are The Andy Warhol Museum, Mattress Factory, National Aviary, Three Rivers Heritage Trail, PNC Park and Heinz Field. The neighborhood is the site of the annual Deutschtown Musical Festival and PumpkinFest.

To arrange a tour of 424 Suismon St., call 412-900-2477.

Linda Wilson Fuoco: lfuoco@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1953.