Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation’s founding members were just citizens who believed community building meant buying and restoring century-old houses.

PHLF started its mission of historic preservation in 1964, in Manchester. Back then, the city was planning to demolish houses that had fallen into serious disrepair on the North Side. Manchester’s Historic District was formed in 1975 and today protects more than 600 homes. If not for changing attitudes, one that would have surely seen its demise is 1410 Pennsylvania Ave.

Built in 1867, the Gothic Revival-style house is back on the market for the first time in 17 years. With four bedrooms and 3½ baths, it is listed for $659,000 (MLS No. 1381699) with Kathe Barge of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (www.howardhanna.com or 412-779-6060). An open house will be held from 1 to 4 p.m. Sunday.

Kim Brown and her husband, David Oney, purchased the house in the fall of 2002.

Advertise with us

“The owners we purchased it from had saved the house,” she said. “They actually slept in it when they noticed that someone had stolen the front door and the newel post.”

Those owners, Christopher Kerr and Michael Santmyer, restored the house in High Victorian style in time for the 1998 Historic Manchester House and Garden Tour. Ms. Brown and Mr. Oney took its restoration to new heights and opened it for the 2009 house tour.

The original house had two major additions before 1900, the couple said. All of its Gothic windows and trim are still intact. The exterior has been repainted twice with historic colors. And that stolen front door? It’s been replaced again, with oak on the interior.

“The front door is a custom door,” Ms. Brown said. “The door was made to match the sidelights. Four different people worked on the door.”

It leads to a spectacular 13-by-13-foot entry with Bradbury & Bradbury historic wallpaper that runs up the staircase and into the second-floor hallway.

Advertise with us

“The paper has flecks of gold. We could not use the coordinating ceiling paper because of the special trim so we had patterns from the paper hand-painted on the ceiling, including the gold flecks,” Ms. Brown said.

In the dining room, judge’s paneling and built-in cabinets are topped by a hand-painted silk wall covering by Joyway Papers Co., which also made a special patterned paper for the ceiling that has ladybugs for good luck.

Other notable features include a crystal chandelier and matching sconces by Schoenbeck, and new period-appropriate pink marble surrounding the fireplace.

The parlor features Bradbury & Bradbury papers on the frieze, ceiling and alcoves. The original fireplace is oak with hand-carved capitals.

The 16-by-10-foot kitchen and butler’s pantry underwent a two-year renovation. Professional-grade appliances include a 48-inch Wolf double oven and range. The counters are black honed granite and the backsplash has subway tiles with a handmade crackled finish. On one wall, classic William Morris fruit wallpaper adds a pop of color.

Advertise with us

“We had the fireplace wall removed ... to allow for more cabinetry,” Ms. Brown said. “We had a craftsman hand-make all of the cabinets out of white quartersawn oak.”

The same cabinets were used in the butler’s pantry, which has its own dishwasher for entertaining.

Even the first-floor powder room is a showplace, with an antique buffet as a vanity, a Chinese porcelain sink, a stained-glass window and more William Morris wallpaper. The floors are encaustic tile with zoned radiant heat.

Upstairs, the 17-by-16-foot master bedroom was updated with crown molding, wainscoting and wallpaper. Two other bedrooms were turned into a second-floor laundry and a master closet with custom roll-out drawers.

The master bathroom has its original soaking tub, a marble shower and basketweave marble tile floor. “It was the last renovation we did on the house,” Ms. Brown said.

Advertise with us

One bedroom has a window seat. Another is currently used as an office and has a marble fireplace. The third floor has a large bedroom, bathroom and playroom. Windows offer a view of the Downtown skyline.

“We don’t have to go anywhere to see the fireworks over the city,” Ms. Brown said.

For more information about the house and its history, visit https://mhspittsburgh.org/history-of-1410-pennsylvania-avenue/.

The house’s assessed value is $238,000. Over the last two years, four houses have sold in the 1400 block of Pennsylvania Avenue for prices ranging from $80,000 in May 2017 to $494,159 in December 2018 (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/realestate/).

In back is an aggregate concrete patio, driveway and two-car garage.

Advertise with us

Ms. Brown said she and her husband have loved living in Manchester.

“We were there for 15 years. It was a privilege to bring the beauty back to such a diverse neighborhood,” she said. “It’s just a peaceful, beautiful house.”

Rosa Colucci: rcolluci@post-gazette.com.