When Dean Kolocouris and Mike O’Neill decided to tackle their fourth renovation in lower Garfield, they had their hands full.
“It looked like a 2,000-pound ball was dropped in the middle of it,” Mr. Kolocouris said. “There was a small fire and other damage from the previous owner.”
They gutted the interior and put on a new roof, then starting rebuilding the century-old home at 5444 Kincaid St. into a four-bedroom, two-bath house with an open floor plan. It is now on the market for $250,000 (MLS No. 1388381) with Michael L. McAndrews of RE/MAX Select Real Estate (724-779-1209 or www.remax.com). It is open by appointment.
The brick exterior has been painted a dark gray that contrasts nicely with new white vinyl windows and trim. A new front porch measures 21 by 8 feet. The stoop and entry are level with the street.
The house’s original floor plan was typical of the time it was built, with a long hall and staircase along an outer wall. The living space has grown from 1,880 square feet to 2,500 square feet, including an expanded third floor.
On the first floor, the kitchen is in the same place but walls around it have been removed. Two laminated support beams made the open floor plan possible. The contractors then installed new wiring, plumbing, recessed lighting and wood floors.
The new kitchen has white Shaker-style cabinets and black concrete counter tops with a gloss finish to match the glass tile backsplash. An island seats two and the Samsung stainless-steel appliances include a gas range, dishwasher and microwave over the stove.
Nearby is a new powder room and a mudroom that has been turned into a small dining area with access to a back deck with a view overlooking Highland Park.
“It’s a little wow factor,” Mr. Kolocouris said. “The rear landscaping has not been completed. Since it isn’t done yet, a buyer could have some say.”
The new industrial-style staircase railing was made from wood and metal conduit. The second floor features three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, recessed lighting and roomy closets. The bathrooms have a combination of porcelain and ceramic tile in neutral tones, white vanities, chrome fixtures and showers. There is no tub in the home. Space was carved out for a second-floor laundry.
“You can open the double doors for wide access,” Mr. Kolocouris said. “All of the hookups are there.”
The finished third floor has dormer wall in front and higher ceilings than the old attic. Like the rest of the house, it has HVAC ducting and central air conditioning.
The Allegheny County assessed value of the property is $53,400 and has not been changed since the renovation. Over the last four years, 12 houses have sold in the 5400 block of Kincaid Street for prices ranging from $2,284 in April 2017 to $109,000 in December 2015 (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/realestate).
The house is in lower Garfield above Negley Avenue in one of the last sections of the neighborhood to be redeveloped. New apartments and townhouses are being developed a block away at Penn and Negley avenues.
“You cannot buy a new house for $100 a square foot,” Mr. Kolocouris said. “This house is definitely new from the inside out.”
Rosa Colucci: rcolucci@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.