DEAR NATALIE: My fiance wants to “share” with another couple. She’s considerably younger than me, so I understand that we may be in different places in our lives, but the idea of being with another woman does nothing for me. I am in love with her and I’m a one-woman kind of guy. I tried to explain that I wasn’t interested, but she got upset about it. We are supposed to get married next month. I’m 46 and she’s 29. Do you think she’s just having cold feet or do you think she’s been cheating on me? I am not sure what to do. I love her and don’t want to lose her.  — NO SHARING

DEAR NO SHARING: While these conversations can be uncomfortable, I applaud you both for speaking up as to what you need and want from each other. Marriage is a huge commitment and if she is having any doubts, better to put on the brakes now and work this out.

I have no idea if she’s cheating, but her willingness to discuss what she wants is a good sign because it means she does care about your perspective and thoughts on the situation. Part of this is an age thing, too, you are right. She hasn’t had as many life experiences as you have, and maybe she is nervous about the idea of being with the same person for the rest of her life. Whatever is going on needs to be sorted out sooner than later.

Is she able to give up the idea of “sharing” to marry you? Are you willing to let her have experiences outside of your relationship? What are your deal breakers and what are hers? I recommend you both write them down and see if there is any intersection or ability to compromise. If there is, great. If there isn’t, you may want to reconsider walking down the aisle and save both of you a lot of heartache in the process.

Advertise with us

Ask Natalie advice: What would you do if your boyfriend was catcalling women in front of you?

DEAR NATALIE: My wife and I just celebrated our 30-year anniversary. In 2016, I found out about an affair that she was having. I suspected it for a couple of years but every time I asked my wife she denied it and said that she and our neighbor were just friends. I found cell phones three different times. When I ask her about them, she gets rid of them. Then she started playing racquetball with our neighbor, who is single.

She joined the club to play racquetball with this guy and pretty soon it was four times a week. The guy has moved out of the neighborhood but lives nearby. We separated for five months (fourth separation in three years). She came back but she is still being very private about a lot of things. I have asked her to go to counseling but she said it didn’t work for us the last time. I told her it didn’t work because she wasn’t ready to quit the affair.

This has caused me to drink more heavily and in September 2017 I got a DWI. I will be on probation for four years. I have been sober for 13 weeks and go to Alcoholics Anonymous on Monday nights. My wife also drinks and doesn’t want to stop. Our kids don’t think she can but she refuses to get help.

I believe she is still having an affair. I recently found $250 hidden behind some clothes. I have found out from her friends about other affairs she denies. My brothers and friends ask me why I continue to try to keep this marriage going. I honestly don’t have a good answer but I want to find a support group to help me. Any help will be appreciated.  — FEELING HOPELESS ABOUT MARRIAGE

DEAR FEELING HOPELESS: You need to separate. Even if you aren’t ready to divorce her, living in the same house with her is hurting you. The drinking, the lying, the cheating — no wonder you feel defeated and hopeless. I'm so sorry that you are going through this.

Advertise with us

Separate and continue therapy alone and work on yourself. When you have been with someone who has treated you poorly for so long, it can be hard to imagine what life without that person feels like. There’s a freedom in that, but also fear of the unknown, too. There are so many trust issues here, so many layers to unpack, and nothing can be built on a foundation of sand. If she isn't able to be monogamous and that is the expectation you have, you can't continue to live like this. Divorce, move forward, find some peace.

She clearly has her own demons to contend with and being in this marriage together is toxic. I know it can be hard to let go, but the longer you continue down this path, I worry for what your future may bring. Take some time apart, focus on yourself and when you get the courage to file for divorce, do it. Your health and happiness are worth more than this toxic woman. Set yourself free by setting both of you free.

Natalie’s Networking Tip of the Week: Instead of asking someone the dreaded question “What do you do?”, try this instead: “Working on anything interesting?” That opens the door to learn more about them professionally, but avoids the trap of getting a resume-like answer.

Natalie Bencivenga is the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Seen and society editor. She has a master’s degree in social work from the University of Pittsburgh. Need advice? Send questions to nbencivenga@post-gazette.com. Follow Natalie on Twitter @NBSeen and on Instagram @NatalieBenci.