“Soup puts the heart at ease.”

When French chef Auguste Escoffier wrote those words more than a century ago, little did he know how succinctly he’d be speaking to entire generations of Pittsburghers.

For years, soup has been a pretty big deal at Eat’n Park’s chain of family restaurants, clocking in year after year as the number one takeout item.

Even more than a decade ago, when takeout soup was one of those secret menu items most customers didn’t even know about, it was a number two seller, said Kevin O’Connell, chief marketing officer at Eat’n Park Hospitality Group.

Advertise with us

Pre-coronavirus, it was available on a rotating list of varieties that included wedding, chicken noodle, broccoli-cheddar and stuffed pepper on specific days. The restaurant group also dishes up an awful lot of chili. But there’s one runaway favorite soup that people just can’t seem to get enough of — potato.

Ever since potato soup appeared on the menu in the 1990s, it’s been a hit, and not just in Pittsburgh. Restaurants from West Virginia to Youngstown, Ohio to Erie and Altoona all enjoy an incredible demand for the soup on its designated days of Wednesday and Sunday.

So when the pandemic started becoming a serious concern last month, and restaurants had to pivot from eat-in to takeout and delivery only, Eat’n Park made a decision. Starting on March 25, quarts of potato soup would be available every day of the week at the special price of $5, with a limit of two per person. Chicken noodle soup also was available in quarts along with cups and bowls.

“Suddenly, we were in a one hundred percent takeout world and people needed something to make them smile,” Mr. O’Connell said. “We thought, ‘What can we do?’”

Offering a soup every day that many people plan their week around seemed an easy solution.

Advertise with us

“One thing about these times is that you can do things you might not have done before because there’s nothing to lose,” he said.

It’s a limited offer. The restaurant chain will migrate back to its regular daily soup on May 5. Too much of a good thing, Mr. O’Connell said, and the soup may not retain its crazy popularity and besides, some people will really miss getting their fix of other favorite soups.

The promotion is off to a great start. Already, he said, the growth rate for potato soup on non-Wednesday days has doubled.

While no one is exactly sure when the creamy soup first appeared on Eat’n Park’s menu, we do know about the chef who created it. That would be John Vichie, who in the 1990s was director of product development and responsible for picking and testing the restaurant’s new menu selections. He also was the chef behind the chain’s popular baked scrod entree, which features two delicate North Atlantic cod fillets baked to a golden brown and with a buttery breadcrumb topping.

The recipe for the potato soup is proprietary, of course, and no amount of pleading or sweet talking could get Mr. O’Connell to share. Let’s just say I’ve been trying for years to find out how they make it to no avail.  It was one of my father’s favorite things in the world to eat on Wednesdays and my twin daughters, now grown up and living in metropolitan Washington, D.C., still beg me to bring them a quart whenever I visit.

Advertise with us

The soup was the only thing that made Catherine feel better after getting her braces tightened, and to Olivia was “just like warm happiness in my belly” with “unbeatable” bacon bits.

Mercy Senchur, chief operating officer of Eat’n Park’s restaurant division, said she knows what makes the potato soup so special. That would be the inclusion of celery “and the fact that our soup is like a loaded baked potato.” Many die-hard potato soup lovers take it to the next level, she added, by topping it with more cheese, bacon, croutons and other ingredients from the salad bar.

“It’s just really good,” said Mr. O’Connell. “If you’re missing your old life, you can get it back at Eat’n Park.”

Eat’n Park potato soup also is available at the chain’s sister restaurant, Hello Bistro.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.