Forty minutes southwest of Pittsburgh, in Westmoreland and Fayette counties, State Game Land 296 was losing habitat. Slopes near worn trails and puddle-spotted logging roads were eroded, and sediment ran into trout-stocked Jacobs Run and its tributaries. All-terrain vehicle trespass was pervasive there and throughout the 1.4 million-acre state game land system and more than 3 million acres of private property enrolled in the state Game Commission’s Hunter Access Program.
“Give me a break. Hunters and bird watchers have the whole rest of the state,” said Steve, an off-roader from Perryopolis, Fayette County, who asked that his last name be withheld because he frequently rode an ATV at State Game Land 296. “Riding these off-road is what they’re for. I had to pay a state tax to buy [an ATV]. There should be places where I’m allowed to ride it.”
As he and other ATV riders push the limits of legality, public recreation managers and startup businesses across the state are trying to finally find a place for motorized outdoor recreation. It’s a matter of limited supply of trail miles and growing demand. Jason Albright, assistant director of the Bureau of Forestry at the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, said conflicts between user groups are common in the management of public lands, but the use of motorized vehicles is more controversial.
“Hikers, bikers and equestrians — muscle-powered recreationalists — often cite the remote experience provided by large tracts of state forest as key to their enjoyment,” he said in an email exchange. “They want to hear birds singing, streams babbling in the distance. … Motorized recreation is very impactful upon those experiences ….”
Mountain biking and hiking trails generally can sustain foot and bicycle traffic with minimal maintenance, said Mr. Albright. ATVs can damage natural habitats.
“A heavy machine with knobby tires and mechanical acceleration can and will degrade the trail far more quickly,” he said.
Read More
Another complication is space. Most state forest hiking and mountain biking trails are narrower than the 48- to 65-inch width of ATVs and two-seater utility task vehicles or UTVs. An additional safety concern involves speed and line of sight, factors not considered when developing most nonmotorized trails.
By Pennsylvania statute, ATVs may be legally operated only in very specific circumstances: on the owner’s private property; on private property with the landowner’s written permission, on a designated trail system located on public lands, on a designated trail system on private land, and on designated township roads posted with signage saying they’re open to ATV use.
“In every other circumstance,” said Mr. Albright, “riders are in a trespass situation.”
Nevertheless, 777 linear miles are now available to ATV users in Pennsylvania, including 273 miles of off-road trails on state forest lands, according to DCNR. Accommodating ATV riders has been a long haul slowly rolled out on four fronts:
• Game wardens can now enforce laws regulating ATVs and snowmobiles, giving the Game Commission additional legal tools to prosecute violators and discourage the illegal use of game lands.
• The Recreational Use of Land and Water Act was strengthened, protecting landowners from liability when no fee is charged and consent is granted for recreational use of properties, including ATV riding.
• Entrepreneurs invented a for-profit industry in developing private paid ATV courses.
• ATV-accessible trail systems were developed in seven state forest districts.
“It should also be noted that a moratorium on new ATV trail construction on state forests has been in place since 2003,” said Mr. Albright. The ban addressed user conflicts, continuing ATV trespass and environmental impacts.
In 2016, DCNR conducted a user survey to determine ATV riders’ preferences as well as potential public-private opportunities involving state-managed lands. Last year the Bureau of Forestry commissioned a feasibility assessment for developing a corridor linking trail systems in Centre and Clinton counties. The study is expected to be completed this summer.

Southwestern Pennsylvania is conspicuously absent on a map of state forest ATV trails. The websites of DCNR and the Pennsylvania Off-Highway Vehicle Association, a statewide ATV advocacy organization, list eight sites in the state’s southwestern corner where ATVs can be ridden or raced for a fee.
Visit DCNR online at dcnr.pa.gov. Pennsylvania Off-Highway Vehicle Association’s site is paohv.org.
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.