Infrastructure gets a bad rap.
It’s because the millions of people who rely on it notice it only when it doesn’t work.
Like when the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority tells 100,000 customers to boil their water for a few days.
Or when a fire during the rehabilitation of the 89-year-old Liberty Bridge closes a major traffic artery for 24 days.
Or when a faltering spillway on California’s Oroville dam causes the evacuation of more than 100,000 residents.
People care about infrastructure only when it fails, laments Gregory Scott, senior engineer at the Pittsburgh office of Buchart Horn, an engineering and architectural firm. In Mr. Scott’s perfect world, people would appreciate how ubiquitous infrastructure is and realize the importance of maintaining, repairing and replacing it.
Read More
“It’s every time you flush your toilet. It’s every time you turn on your lights,” he said.
In addition to the roads and bridges most people think of, infrastructure includes water and sewage treatment systems, ports, airports, railroads, mass transit systems, school buildings, parks, the grid that carries electricity across the nation, natural gas and oil pipelines, and locks and dams that enable river traffic and control flooding.
Mr. Scott pointed out that when explorer Meriwether Lewis left Pittsburgh to launch the Lewis & Clark Expedition, one of the first obstacles he faced was having to pull his boat over sand bars on the shallow Ohio River.
Locks and dams built since then make the river deep enough to accommodate commercial traffic. Most people who admire Pittsburgh’s riverscape don’t realize that, Mr. Scott said.
“Without the locks and dams, what we see does not occur,” he said.
Infrastructure is a major engine powering the economy. But you wouldn’t know that by the way we care for it.
The American Society of Civil Engineers estimates the U.S. needs to invest $4.59 trillion by 2025 to put the nation’s infrastructure in adequate shape. The professional group grades the nation’s infrastructure every four years, and the 2017 report card was not impressive: D+, the same grade as in 2013. Rail earned the highest grade in the latest report card, a B. Transit systems received the lowest grade, a D-.
Some believe it is in the engineering group’s interest to inflate the size of the problem.
“They’re the ones who are going to build whatever this issue is, so they have a little bit of bias going into it,” said Steve Ellis of Taxpayers for Common Sense, a Washington, D.C., watchdog group.
However, there’s no denying the needs are massive.
President Donald Trump’s administration put together a tentative list of 50 infrastructure projects estimated to cost $137.5 billion, with half of the money coming from private investment. The list includes three Pennsylvania projects: $1.7 billion for three sets of Ohio River locks and dams between the Point and Monaca; $900 million for a long-delayed locks and dams project on the lower Monongahela River; and $8 billion for 15 bridges on Interstate 95 in Philadelphia.
Other projects on the wish list include rebuilding rail lines between New York City and Newark, N.J.; replacing a 54-year-old bridge on I-75 connecting Ohio and Kentucky that is ranked as the nation’s 15th worst bridge; and dredging the Mississippi River shipping channel so that it can accommodate the deeper draft vessels moving through the Panama Canal.
The Mississippi River project, first authorized in Congress in 1985, has never been funded. It is only one of many projects that lawmakers have authorized to gain political capital but have failed to fund with actual capital.
Meanwhile, the nation’s infrastructure gets older, less reliable and competitive, and more expensive to maintain.
The 23 sets of locks and dams maintained by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ Pittsburgh office are among the oldest in the country. Designed to last 50 years, many are much older than that. A dam on the Monongahela River at Elizabeth went into operation in 1907.
The Liberty Bridge, built in 1928, was designed to last 50 years. Rated structurally deficient, it’s now the object of an $80 million rehabilitation so it can continue carrying about 55,000 motorists daily.
“A lot of our infrastructure is reaching the end of its design life. They have a finite life,” said Linda Kaplan, senior structural engineer in the Pittsburgh office of TRC, an engineering consulting and construction management firm.
The American Society of Civil Engineers has put a price tag on not replacing aging infrastructure. Last year, the group estimated deteriorating infrastructure will cost each American family $3,400 in disposable income annually until 2025. The group said outdated, inefficient infrastructure increases costs for making and delivering products. That reduces productivity, crimps economic output and reduces employment as well as personal income.
Whatever the magnitude of the problem, there has been a lack of will to address it. Two common objections are demands for “no new taxes” and smaller government.
The status of the federal Highway Trust Fund illustrates the failure to fund. It was created to support the nation’s roads and is funded by a federal gasoline tax. The last time the tax was raised was 1993, when it was increased to 18.4 cents a gallon.
Since then, cars have become more fuel efficient, meaning drivers need less gas to go as far as they did back then. Moreover, the University of Michigan reports that on a per-person and per-household basis, Americans drove about 8 percent fewer miles in 2015 than they did in 2004, when miles-driven rates peaked.
The shrinking source of revenue has led Congress to move more than $1 trillion of general federal revenue in the highway trust fund, Mr. Ellis said. The taxpayer group believes the costs of infrastructure should be borne by those who use it.
Carnegie Mellon University’s David Dzombak, who teaches civil and environmental engineering, said the failure to fund infrastructure has been a nonpartisan issue. Both Democratic and Republican administrations have failed to address the issue for a long time.
“This is a multidecade phenomenon,” he said.
Part of the problem is convincing the public of infrastructure’s importance to the economy, said Coreen Casadei of Collective Efforts, a West View civil and environmental engineering firm.
“As technical people, maybe we don’t present this as well as we could,” Ms. Casadei said.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.