Financial problems are nothing new for the Port Authority; nor are public hearings on proposed fare increases and service reductions, like the one scheduled today at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.
More than 300 people have registered to comment. The authority has proposed 25- to 50-cent fare increases scheduled to take effect July 1 and a 35 percent service cut, deepest in its 48-year history, on Sept. 2. The hearing will run from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
Because so many people signed up, the authority will use two rooms simultaneously to take testimony. Speakers will be limited to three minutes.
Testimony at previous hearings has caused authority officials to make minor changes to service reduction plans, but the authority's position has become so dire that it has little room to maneuver, CEO Steve Bland said.
"The truth is ... you're into cutting meat and muscle," he said. "It took the wind out of my lungs when I saw the routes on the elimination list."
He said hearings are an effective way to garner support for public transit. "It's good to be reminded why we're in this business. There's no starker way to bring that into focus than to hear stories of people's hardships."
Since transit ridership peaked here 37 years ago, the Port Authority has lurched from one financial crisis to the next, repeatedly cutting service, raising fares and losing customers.
Ridership has fallen from 109.6 million to 63.3 million, or about 43 percent, in that time. The base fare has increased from 40 cents to $2.25 (scheduled to rise to $2.50 in July), outpacing inflation (today's equivalent of that 40 cents is about $1.70).
The agency's woes stem from its heavy reliance on funding from the state government, whose purse strings are controlled by a Legislature where big-city lawmakers are in the minority and rural members mostly have been transit-averse. State funding to the Port Authority fell by $34.2 million in the fiscal year that ended in June and before that had stayed flat for several years.
Allegheny County's annual contributions to the agency also have remained flat in recent years, despite the enactment of drink and car rental taxes. The county has used the new levies to pay its required 15 percent match of state funding to the authority but has not appreciably increased the contribution, using the drink and car rental money as a substitute for previous funding sources.
Also crushing the authority are pension and benefit costs for retirees, which have exploded during nearly two decades of liberal retirement policies that, ironically, were originally meant to cut costs by getting higher-salaried workers off the payroll.
Now the agency has more than 3,000 retirees, compared with 2,455 active employees, and expects to spend nearly as much this fiscal year on pensions and benefits as on salaries ($134.8 million vs. $135.1 million). The cost of salaries and benefits for employees and retirees works out to about $4.25 for every transit ride provided.
In 1993, to cut payroll costs, the authority began allowing retirement after 25 years of service, regardless of age. Laden with other incentives, the deal was so sweet that nearly 20 percent of the workforce, some as young as 45, took retirement.
The authority bargained an increase in the retirement age to 60 with 30 years of service in the last round of contract talks in 2008, and it has made retiree costs a "primary focus" in negotiations this year on a pact to replace the one that expires June 30. In the meantime, it has eliminated post-retirement health care for nonunion employees and police.
In a budget presentation earlier this year, the authority touted other cost-saving measures, including redesigning bus service to make the system more efficient, eliminating 30 percent of its administrative and managerial staff, freezing nonunion and police salaries and increasing employee contributions toward health care. There have been two 15 percent service reductions since 2007, cutting more than 500 positions from the payroll.
The agency has increased its efficiency, carrying 33 percent more passengers per service hour on buses and rail vehicles in 2011 compared with 2006, when Mr. Bland took over as CEO.
Still, to balance the budget for the current fiscal year, which ends June 30, the authority had to use nearly $30 million of its $40 million reserve fund and $11 million in emergency funding that was left over from a $45 million infusion given by then Gov. Ed Rendell just before he left office in January 2011.
While the authority hopes to make gains in contract talks this year, Mr. Bland has said there is no way union concessions can fully plug a projected $64 million deficit in next year's budget.
The agency has pinned its hopes on recommendations by the state's Transportation Funding Advisory Commission in August. The panel, appointed by Gov. Tom Corbett, issued a proposal to raise as much as $2.7 billion in new revenue for highways, bridges and public transit. But Mr. Corbett has yet to embrace the plan and his spokesman has suggested that Port Authority funding is a local rather than state problem.
The July 1 fare increase is likely to occur regardless of whether the state comes up with additional funding. In addition to the 25-cent base fare increase, it would add 50 cents to a two-zone trip, making it $3.25.
It would be the third fare increase in five years.
The service cut would eliminate 46 of the remaining 102 routes and reduce the frequency of trips on the others. It would be the third reduction in six years and leave the region with less than half of the service that existed before the cuts.
A 15 percent reduction last March caused severe overcrowding on some routes, and riders still get passed by buses that are filled to capacity.
Cutting another 35 percent would be "the beginning of the end of transit as a major conveyance in Pittsburgh," Mr. Bland said. "People are going to start to change their patterns. They're going to drive. They're going to move. Employers are going to look outside the city, maybe outside the region."
Public comments also are being accepted at: www.portauthority.org through March 9, and by mail at Port Authority Fare & Service Proposals, Heinz 57 Center, 345 Sixth Ave., Floor 3, Pittsburgh 15222-2527.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.