Legal experts say the lawsuits filed in the Penn State University child sex abuse case will complicate and extend what already is shaping up as a marathon of litigation for the parties involved.

Two suits have been started in the civil division of Philadelphia County Common Pleas Court, both filed by attorneys for men who say they were sexually assaulted as boys by former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky. Based on public comments by other attorneys representing alleged victims, more lawsuits are likely.

Mr. Sandusky already was facing 40 criminal counts of sexual abuse involving eight children, a case that resides in Centre County Common Pleas Court.

How the civil and criminal cases impact one another, and the timing of each, will depend on lawyers' strategies and rulings by judges, said Richard Serbin, an Altoona attorney. He has represented 156 sex abuse victims, including an Ohio man who won more than $2 million in damages from the Catholic Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown.

Advertise with us

Lawyers in the civil suits likely will wait until the criminal case is over before taking their cases to trial, said William Caroselli, a civil litigator with 45 years of experience whose firm, Caroselli Beachler McTiernan & Conboy, represents children victimized in the Luzerne County "cash for kids" scandal.

That is because the evidence and testimony in the criminal proceeding might be helpful in the civil case. "You haven't completed your discovery" until the criminal trial is over, Mr. Caroselli said. "You haven't turned over every rock."

Witnesses at the trials of two judges convicted in the Luzerne County case also are witnesses in the civil proceedings, he said. "Now we have a pretty good idea of what they are going to say."

The other obstacle for civil lawyers is that if they try to take Mr. Sandusky's deposition before the criminal trial, he probably would invoke his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, the lawyers said.

But that doesn't mean the lawsuits will be dormant while the criminal case is prosecuted. Lawyers will subpoena documents and conduct sworn depositions of other potential witnesses. And that activity could impact the criminal case, said Julie Blackman, a trial strategy consultant for 30 years.

Advertise with us

"The civil case creates more sworn records. The deposition testimony, the discovery just creates a wealth of additional information that can be used to impeach witnesses," said Ms. Blackman, vice president and managing director at DOAR Litigation Consulting.

The trauma of sex abuse can affect the victims' memories, showing up as inconsistencies in their various interviews and statements to authorities, Ms. Blackman said. Often, the victim delays and then minimizes his initial reporting of abuse incidents out of humiliation and out of concern for the listener.

Then, a fuller accounting that is given later can be exploited by defense attorneys as inconsistent. "The hardest part of these cases is to watch the victim's credibility being impeached," she said.

Filing of civil suits by victims can weaken the criminal case in another way: Jurors may conclude that they're in it for the money, Ms. Blackman said. She recalled one rape case in which the prosecutor dropped charges after learning the accuser had also filed a civil suit.

All of the experts acknowledged that an ongoing stream of lawsuits will generate more publicity about the case -- Ms. Blackman saw news of the first lawsuit on a crawl in Times Square while walking to work -- but said there has already been so much of it, it won't make a big difference.

Advertise with us

Mr. Caroselli said picking a fair and impartial jury would've been "extremely tough" even without the latest news about the lawsuits.

Options for dealing with the publicity issue include moving the trial out of Centre County, bringing in an out-of-county jury and having the judge impose a gag order on the parties involved, Mr. Serbin said.

Jury selection is likely to include extensive questioning of prospective jurors, he said. In his suit against the diocese over sex abuse by the Rev. Francis Luddy, jurors filled out lengthy written questionnaires. "That'll probably happen here," he said.

"There are still, amazingly, people who don't know a lot about things. They're busy, they're not attuned to the news. But you can have knowledge or information about the case. Can you put aside anything you've seen or read and be fair and impartial? If the answer's yes, you can serve," he said.

The duration of the various legal proceedings will depend on how resolute the parties are about fighting rather than settling. Mr. Serbin's said his contentious case against the diocese spanned 20 years and included three separate appeals to the state Supreme Court.

Advertise with us

"I would certainly hope for the sake of the survivors in this case that it doesn't take as long," he said.

Noting that two other defendants -- Penn State athletic director Timothy Curley and retired vice president Gary Schultz, both charged with perjury and failure to report the possible sexual abuse of a child -- haven't even had preliminary hearings yet, Mr. Caroselli estimated that the criminal proceedings alone could take up to three years to complete.

There has been some speculation that a plea bargain could avert a trial, but Mr. Sandusky's lawyer, Jerry Amendola told The Philadelphia Inquirer on Thursday that his client "has never considered and is not currently considering a plea in his case."

Ms. Blackman said Penn State faces a serious problem of ongoing damage to its reputation as litigation stretches on and on.

"Penn State wants to stay in business, wants students to continue to apply. They have to be in damage control mode," she said. "They may want to settle these cases as quickly as possible and get them off the radar screen."

Advertise with us

She said that would be her advice to the university.

Multiple civil trials will serve as reminders that Penn State officials fell far short of doing everything in their power to stop the abuse, Ms. Blackman said.

Settling with the victims "would send the message that the university is prepared to step up and do the right thing," she said.