Kathleen Cullinan had one basic reason for showing up unscheduled one morning last month with her ill, 13-year-old beagle, Tillie, at Frankie’s Friends, a veterinary clinic in New Kensington that caters mostly to rescued cats.

“I heard they’re good and when you walk in the door here there isn’t an office charge,” said Mrs. Cullinan, 67, a retired nurse from Arnold. “Any other vet charges you $50 just to walk in the door.”

She knew that because Frankie’s Friends, as well as her regular veterinarian and most other veterinary clinics tell pet owners up front how much a checkup, a blood test or an annual vaccination will cost. They’ll also give an estimate of any other procedure pet owners seek.

Asked if her human doctor will do that, Mrs. Cullinan, who is covered by Medicare, replied: “No. And I don’t ask because my coverage usually covers everything.”

Advertise with us

And therein lies the essential difference between animal medicine and human medicine and the ability to shop for health care.

“People need to know the costs,” said Becky Morrow, founder of Frankie’s Friends and president of the Western Pennsylvania Veterinary Medical Association. “That’s because it helps in the decisions on treatment that they decide to do because they know they will be paying it.”

That is starting to change for human medicine. As co-pays and deductibles get higher, people are wondering more and more about their out-of-pocket costs. As a result, doctors, nurses and health care administrators are fielding more questions about them, too.

“With higher out-of-pocket costs people want to know more now,” said state Rep. Mike Reese, R-Mount Pleasant. “And with the Affordable Care Act insurance, we’re seeing even higher costs for consumers. The health care patient has to be wise to what it’s going to cost.”

Mr. Reese has proposed a bill in the state House that would require the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council, a state agency known as PHC4, to collect and report to the public data from all of the state’s health care facilities on the prices they charge for services.

Advertise with us

“I just think with this information people could do a little health care shopping and compare prices,” he said. “I think you have to become a savvy consumer. You should be able to go online and do some research. I mean, you can if you’re buying a car or a jet ski. Why not health care?”

At least in the Pittsburgh area, only one local hospital, physician practice or insurance company — Heritage Valley Health System — has yet printed on its public website the prices it charges or payments it makes for various procedures, and Heritage Valley warns that the prices are only the cash prices for non-insured patients.

Many practices, however, are exploring the idea, anticipating it becoming the norm. They’re watching the impact of pioneers like the Oklahoma City Surgery Center, which began publishing its prices in 2009, and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina, which put up a public website earlier this year that estimates costs for 1,400 procedures in that state.

“I do think this is coming,” said Mark Kissinger, executive director of Genesis Medical Associates, one of the Pittsburgh area’s largest independent physician practices with 46 doctors. “Patients should have transparency. They should have the ability to understand what the costs are.”

If everyone’s costs are published, he said, the doctors in his independent practice would look good by comparison.

Advertise with us

But at the same time, he said that listing costs leaves him a little concerned. “Because if we publish price and charges, we’re still missing quality and I want my patients to know that I’m a Patient-Centered Medical Home [a quality standard] and that we’re a Medicare Center of Excellence.”

The concept of publishing quality data to help reduce costs was the reason behind how PHC4, the state agency, was created in the early 1980s by a strange-bedfellows-coalition of business and labor groups who were concerned about skyrocketing health insurance costs.

“The idea was to gather data that could be used to put pressure on the providers to improve quality and thereby reduce costs,” said Ernest Sessa, who was PHC4’s first executive director when it began in 1986.

Joe Martin, the current PHC4 executive director, said in an emailed statement that “we believe we have had a modest but important impact on costs as well as quality, and they are connected. Better quality means lower costs. There’s always more to be done.”

He cited a study that showed mortality rates in Pennsylvania hospitals have dropped from “significantly above” to “significantly below” national averages between 1991 and 2010, a period after PHC4 began publishing its data on issues like mortality, quality of care, infections and other measures. “PHC4 estimates a savings of approximately 72,000 lives and $2.8 billion in hospital charges can be attributed to this trend,” Mr. Martin said.

Advertise with us

But are we any closer to seeing published facility-by-facility, or doctor-by-doctor cost estimates that would truly bring costs down in a real health care free market?

“The hospitals will put up all sort of arguments” to not publish procedure costs or estimates, said Karen Wolk Feinstein, CEO of the Jewish Healthcare Foundation in Pittsburgh. “But your [hospital] computers can do this. We know it can do this. There’s no doubt it’s doable and the arguments against it are weak.”

“I think [cost shopping] is the most uncharted frontier in health care,” she said. “And it is coming.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579