'FAHRENHEIT 9/11'
(Columbia Tristar)
Now, it's in people's homes.
Charges that President Bush ignored the warnings of Sept. 11 and that the Bush family was in the Saudis' pockets. Footage of U.S. soldiers playing war like it was a video game and of their mutilated bodies in a veterans' hospital.
Video Bits
New this week:
"Fahrenheit 9/11" -- See review.
"Aladdin: Platinum Edition" -- The Robin Williams blockbuster is back, in a two-disc set that includes the deleted song "Proud of Your Boy" among the bonus features.
"Saved" -- Outsiders band together to navigate the treacherous halls of a Christian high school in this smart comedy with Mandy Moore, Jena Malone, Macaulay Culkin.
"Michael Moore DVD Collector's Set" -- The Oscar-winning "Bowling for Columbine" is being paired with "The Big One," along with a bonus disc with "39 Cities in 23 Days," documenting Moore's book tour for "Dude, Where's My Country?"
"Horns and Halos" -- The unlikely connection among three men -- George W. Bush, a discredited author and an underground publisher -- is explored in this documentary.
"Friday the 13th -- From Crystal Lake to Manhattan" -- This is being billed as the ultimate DVD collection, with all eight movies, plus special features that salute makeup master and special-effects designer Tom Savini.
TV on DVD: "North and South: The Complete Collection"; second seasons of "Roswell," "SpongeBob SquarePants" and "What's Happening"; "The Dame Edna Experience: The Complete Series Two" and "The Dame Edna Experience: the Christmas Specials."
Also: DVD of "The War Room," with new remarks from the filmmakers about their access to the 1992 Bill Clinton presidential race; "Born Rich," a documentary about the rich (including Ivanka Trump) by the rich; and special editions of "The Shawshank Redemption," "The Untouchables" and "Deep Impact."
The tears of Lila Lipscomb, a Michigan woman who lost her son in the war, and of a grieving Iraqi woman screaming to Allah and cursing the Americans.
Michael Moore pushed all the buttons in "Fahrenheit 9/11," a broad, aggressive, heartbreaking, comic and, yes, one-sided view of the events that have transpired since Sept. 11.
It hit theaters in late June and hung around to be the summer's political talking point. In the end, the attempts to discredit Moore on the individual facts didn't seem to stick. The more effective argument from Bush supporters was that Moore added 2 and 2 and got 5, that pictures of the Bushes shaking hands with Saudis and revelations about Bin Ladens flying out of the country when planes were grounded didn't add up to conspiracy.
Conservatives also explained away Bush's decision -- if you want to call it that -- to continue listening to "My Pet Goat" in a Florida classroom after the second plane hit as a show of strength and confidence in front of a group of schoolchildren.
Moore, without even throwing a bone to the other side's opinion, crafted "Fahrenheit 9/11" into an attack on the Bush administration that was by turns humorous and devastating. Like sorting through the post-debate spins, we're left having to make up our own minds, partly on the facts, partly how it hits us on an emotional level.
Judging by the early campaign polls, the movie didn't swing much popular opinion away from the president. Now, the DVD release is timed to reach those people who do their viewing at home.
In the extras, there are no October surprises. In fact, they're a bit ho-hum. The featurette on "The Release of Fahrenheit 9/11" is mostly a post-film pep rally with folks such as Quentin Tarantino, Tony Bennett, Julian Bond and Moby weighing in. A Marine who served in Iraq poignantly says "This movie showed for the first time my nightmares." Al Sharpton is on hand to note how amazing it is that people who haven't even seen the film "have made up their mind whether they like it or not."
There are deleted scenes of old retirees patrolling the waters in Miami and of angry Iraqis outside the gates of Abu Ghraib prison, wondering "Is this the freedom they were talking about?" A segment on Arab-American comedians after 9/11 is amusing, particularly one comic who opens his show, "My name is Ahmed Ahmed and I can't fly anywhere."
Condoleezza Rice is shown testifying before the 9/11 Commission that an Aug. 6 CIA memo titled "Bin Laden Determined to Strike in US" did not seem like a "warning." Bush, meanwhile, appears in the Rose Garden after his joint testimony with Cheney before the commission talking about it as if they just went to a spa: "I came away good about the session," he says.
The best of the extras involve two sober voices in this wartime debate: Marine Lance Cpl. Abdul Henderson and Swedish journalist Urban Hamid. Henderson was a memorable presence in the film, discussing his refusal to return to combat. On the DVD, he talks further of how he felt betrayed by the war, how he felt like someone from the future going back in time to kill Third World people.
Hamid delivers footage from December 2003, depicting middle-of-the-night raids on Iraqi homes, of U.S. soldiers dragging suspects out, putting hoods over their heads and, ultimately, violating their private parts. "Iraqis," he warns, "are an incredibly proud people. They are not going to accept this."
What's missing in the extras is more of Moore. It would have been nice to have seen an in-depth interview with him responding to his critics, one of his fiery speeches or even something along the line of the sparring match he had with Katie Couric over whether or not the mainstream media did enough to question the war buildup.
It also would have been interesting to have heard Moore's take on the Democrats' choice to face off against Bush. If you read his book, you know who he wanted: Oprah.
For better or worse -- depending on your political stripe -- "Fahrenheit 9/11" is out there now for everyone to see, as close as the video store, and simply saying that Michael Moore eats too many doughnuts isn't going to make his message go away.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.