In the end, it was all just too much: Katie McGinty rode a wave of endorsements and financial support to be Pennsylvania Democrats’ choice to take on first-term Republican Sen. Pat Toomey in the fall. Unofficial election results showed her with a comfortable lead over former Congressman Joe Sestak, Braddock Mayor John Fetterman, and McKees Rocks businessman Joseph Vodvarka.
Speaking to supporters in Philadelphia, Ms. McGinty said, “It’s your turn to trust that the people you elect to the Senate are actually doing their job and not allowing partisan politics to shutdown our government, disrupt our economy and threaten our future.”
“As your Senator, I will stand with your family in every fight,” she said.
If she were to win in the fall, Ms. McGinty would be the only woman in Pennsylvania’s Congressional delegation, and she was backed by EMILY's List, which seeks to elect women to office, along with unions and Democrtaic officials, including the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
It was a victory that didn't gel until April, with Democratic voters sitting on the sidelines until the race's closing weeks. In a campaign season dominated by outsider politics, Ms. McGinty's Democratic rivals tried to hold her institutional support against her. But it may have been the backing of President Barack Obama in late March that tilted the race in her favor.
For much of the campaign, Mr. Sestak enjoyed a respectable lead. But the tide began turning on March 30, when Ms. McGinty earned Mr. Obama's endorsement and that of his Vice President, Joe Biden. Republicans ridiculed the move as “a final act of desperation” by the Democratic establishment, but Ms. McGinty began surging shortly afterward.
Polling by Franklin & Marshall College, which previously showed Ms. McGinty with support in the low teens, showed a near-doubling, to 27 percent, in Democratic support between March and April. A mid-April poll showed Ms. McGinty and Mr. Sestak neck-and-neck; a Harper Polling survey in the race's final weekend showed Ms. McGinty leading Mr. Sestak by 6.
“There have been a lot of late deciders — but as people tuned into the race, there were signs she was getting across to voters,” said Chris Borick, a pollster and political science professor at Muhlenberg College. “I think the support of the president has certainly helped her.”
No statement from the Sestak camp was forthcoming by press time, but Mr. Fetterman brought his own unlikely campaign to a close shortly after 10 p.m. last night, telling supporters, “We came up short. But we created a movement in this state. We are the progressive standard-bearer for Pennsylvania now.”
“It doesn't stop tonight,” said Mr. Fetterman, whose unorthodox image — he stands a notably tattooed 6 foot 8 inches tall — as well as his political message caught the imagination of many progressive voters. “We are in this race for the forgotten cities like my own all across Pennsylvania.”
At his own primary-night party at Green Tree’s DoubleTree hotel, Mr. Toomey acknowledged, “This election result for us tonight is not the most suspenseful.” As he has done throughout his campaign, he struck a careful balance between appealing to a defiant Republican base, while pledging to work across the aisle where possible.
Sen. Toomey said he had “stood up to the mistaken policies of this administration when I thought it was appropriate,” but said “Pennsylvanians did not send me to Washington just to vote no. ... The other responsibility I have is to actively pursue those policies that enable Pennsylvanians to build a better life for themselves, for their families, and I've done that as well.”
Mr. Toomey, who faced no Republican opponent, has kept a low profile during primary season, airing positive ads that tout his support of police, among other causes. As a result, he had $9.4 million in cash as of early April — nearly three-and-a-half times what his three major Democratic opponents had combined.
Democrats, who see an opportunity to take back control of the Senate this year, would dearly love to replace Mr. Toomey, and the numbers say it's possible. An early April poll showed Mr. Toomey leading Ms. McGinty by less than 10 points, With his own support just shy of the 50 percent threshold.
Mr. Borick said the primary fight would leave Ms. McGinty “not weak, but poor. She had to compete hard. I don't think it was a real negative race per se, but she'll certainly be more cash-strapped than you'd like.”
“Katie McGinty is a much tougher candidate for Sen. Toomey to beat than Joe Sestak would have been,” said Mr. Rendell, who chaired Ms. McGinty's campaign. “Particularly with Hillary Cliinton at the top of the ticket you’re going to see a lot of very, very strong support from women voters.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.