Richard Shelby. John McCain. Chuck Grassley. Thad Cochran. Orrin Hatch. And, yes, Mitch McConnell.

These gentlemen are all current members of the United States Senate. And they were all members of the Senate in 1998, when that body voted 97-0 to confirm Judge Anthony Kennedy, an appointee of President Ronald Reagan, to the Supreme Court of the United States.

A quick refresher: 1988 was a presidential election year, and Mr. Reagan was a lame duck president. He had some difficulties finding the right nominee to replace Lewis Powell, who retired in 1987; Robert Bork was rejected by the Senate for his staunchly conservative views and Douglas Ginsberg withdrew his name after admitting that he smoked marijuana with students while he was a law professor at Harvard. Kennedy was vetted to an unprecedented degree and then unanimously confirmed to the court.

Does any of this sound familiar?

Advertise with us

Let's take a look: 2016 is a presidential election year, and President Barack Obama is a lame duck president. There is a vacancy on the court after the death this weekend of Justice Antonin Scalia, and Mr. Obama said he would fulfill his duty as outlined in Article II, Section Two of the Constitution. Republicans – including Senate Majority Leader McConnell and Mr. Grassley, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee – have already dug in their heels, saying the power to appoint Justice Scalia's replacement should fall to the next president.

Mr. Grassley said it is "standard practice" that the Senate doesn't confirm a Supreme Court nominee during an election year; we're not certain when this became a "standard practice," because that wasn't the case in 1988 ... as Mr. Grassley should recall.

We can look at the rough road that Mr. Reagan had in filling the seat of Justice Powell and apply one precedent to 2016; if Mr. Obama nominates an ideologue – as Mr. Reagan did with the nomination of Mr. Bork – he should expect to lose. But this is not, as Republican presidential candidate Sen. Ted Cruz said over the weekend, a "decision for the people"; as mentioned previously, the Constitution makes that crystal clear.