Is Anthony Coghill genuinely concerned that a Beechview developer is supporting Ashleigh Deemer for Pittsburgh City Council District 4? Or is he just upset that he didn’t get a check too?

Those questions have surfaced days before the May 16 Democratic primary, when Mr. Coghill and Ms. Deemer square off in a district that encompasses Beechview and other South Hills communities. But the dispute took root in January, when two officials with Atlas Development Company, Daniel Berkowitz and Benjamin Samson, gave Ms. Deemer’s campaign $2,700 each.

Those are the largest contributions individuals can make under city law, and they place Atlas among Ms. Deemer’s largest supporters.

“We were shocked to see that she’s in the pocket of Berkowitz,” said Mr. Coghill. While he praised Atlas’ projects and said its “heart was in the right place,” Mr. Berkowitz “is a businessman. He gave her that money because he’s counting on her influence.”

Advertise with us

“That’s ridiculous,” said Ms. Deemer, who like Mr. Coghill lives in Beechview. As chief of staff to outgoing City Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, she said, “I’ve put Atlas through the wringer” by compelling frequent meetings with residents about its plans.

Mr. Berkowitz agreed, saying Ms. Deemer had at times been “our biggest critic.” By contrast, he said, Mr. Coghill was merely hypocritical. Emails and other communications, he said, proved that Mr. Coghill has been “simultaneously attacking us and attempting to coordinate a campaign donation from us.”

Atlas owns 37 rental units in Beechview, along with a building it is converting to office space on the 1600 block of Broadway Avenue. On the same block, Atlas has proposed building a jazz club, retail space and rental housing on two parcels owned by the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority.

But Beechview is reeling from the legacy of Bernardo Katz, who over a decade ago bought a dozen Beechview properties with URA financing. Mr. Katz left for Brazil after being charged with mortgage fraud, leaving the area in limbo. Given that history, said Mr. Coghill, “to throw all our eggs in one basket with one developer is too fast for me.”

While “the trauma from Bernardo Katz is not to be dismissed,” Ms. Rudiak countered, “these buildings have been vacant for 15 years.” Mr. Berkowitz, she said, had proven himself as “a community guy, not just a real estate guy.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Berkowitz said Atlas usually supports incumbents, and that he felt Ms. Deemer qualified as Ms. Rudiak’s aide. But the contributions, and Deemer signs that Atlas posted on some properties, drew Mr. Coghill’s attention.

He and his campaign chair, Moira Kaleida, met with Mr. Berkowitz in March. Mr. Berkowitz recalls being warned that his support “could put [Ms. Deemer] in a vulnerable position for them to attack her as being in the pocket of a developer.”

Mr. Berkowitz said he asked how he could stay out of the fray, and both sides agree that Mr. Coghill asked him to remove the Deemer signs. (They came down in April.)

“I said, ‘It would be nice to take the signs down if you want to take a neutral role,’” Mr. Coghill said.

But Mr. Berkowitz said Mr. Coghill also floated the possibility of donating to his own campaign. Initially, he said, Mr. Coghill told him, “We’re not sure if we want that money because the political hay would be worth more.” But Mr. Berkowitz said the two later agreed Atlas would contribute, which “I felt was the most prudent course.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Coghill offered a different account. “I don’t think either of us mentioned a contribution” in March, he said. “There was never an offer made, and had it been, we would not have taken it.”

“Follow-up calls and emails from his campaign indicate otherwise,” retorted Mr. Berkowitz.

He provided email exchanges between himself and Ms. Kaleida, “a step we would normally never take,” but that was necessary “to protect the integrity of the Atlas Development Company and to shine a light on the Coghill campaign’s methods.”

In an April 10 email, Ms. Kaleida wrote: “I wanted to check in on where we are as far as financial support and the Deemer signs in your properties.” And in a May 2 email response, Mr. Berkowitz recounted his interactions with Mr. Coghill in a narrative similar to the one he gave the Post-Gazette. Ms. Kaleida’s response neither confirmed nor denied the account, instead scheduling a phone conversation the next day.

Ms. Kaleida said she sent the earlier email because “as far as we knew, he was still contemplating giving us money — not that we were going to take it.” She said she also wanted to learn whether other Atlas executives would support Ms. Deemer.

Advertise with us

Mr. Berkowitz’s May 2 email, she said, “was trying to make a paper trail that never happened. My response was ‘we can talk,’ because I wasn’t going to put anything in writing.”

Mr. Berkowitz said he intended to donate to Mr. Coghill by May 5, but then “a number of residents contacted me and [said] he’d used the very line of attack he agreed not to use” — calling out Atlas’ support of Ms. Deemer while door-knocking.

While they discussed that concern in a phone call, Mr. Berkowitz did not send the check by May 5, a Friday. Mr. Coghill contacted the Post-Gazette about Atlas’ support of Ms. Deemer that weekend.

Mr. Coghill said he only spoke about Mr. Berkowitz with one resident, a Deemer supporter, “to see how she felt” about the developer’s support. “If he was offering me a contribution, why would I be out there saying that?” said Mr. Coghill.

Laurel Brandstetter, a former prosecutor with the state Attorney General’s office, said it’s not illegal to pressure a donor along the lines Mr. Berkowitz described — even assuming that’s what happened. “This is the yucky gray area of politics,” she said.

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.