Follow the money, the old journalistic saw has it. That’s not always as easy as it sounds in politics: While the city of Pittsburgh requires monthly financial disclosures from candidates seeking election, at least two city officials are ignoring the rules. But with the May 16 Democratic primary just six weeks away, and March financial reports due in yesterday, the money is pointing toward a neck-and-neck race in City Council District 4.
The South Hills district, which includes Beechview, Brookline, Carrick, Overbrook and adjoining areas, is the site of the only competitive council race: Ashleigh Deemer, an aide to outgoing Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, is vying with roofing contractor Anthony Coghill to replace her boss. And the two are going into April with almost the same amount of money in hand.
Ms. Deemer benefits from a head start, having begun her fundraising efforts in January. Mr. Coghill’s campaign didn’t take shape until February, and he financed it with a $20,000 loan from his own pockets. But he has been making up for lost time, raising $22,400 in March. He spent $12,255.14 of that last month, to end up with $15,044.86.
Mr. Coghill chairs the Democratic Party’s 19th ward, and the bulk of his support came from political committees, led by Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s campaign, which gave $2,700. A committee that supports State Senator Wayne Fontana, a South Hills Democrat and longtime Coghill ally, gave $2,500. Four unions — including the city firefighters union — gave a total of $6,000.
Ms. Deemer started the month with slightly less than $17,000 in the bank. She added $11,726.81 to that in new contributions, but spent $13,441.33. That left her with $15,262.44 going into April -- just over $200 more than Mr. Coghill had.
The vast majority of Ms. Deemer’s support, meanwhile, came from individuals, led by a $1,500 donation from Ms. Rudiak’s aunt, Barbara Rudiak.
Read More
While the fundraising momentum would seem to be with Mr. Coghill at the moment, Deemer campaign manager Jacob Redfern noted Ms. Deemer has outraised him over the long haul: “We’re engaging support from all levels of the community, and we’re proud of the work we’ve done.”
“We’re really honored by the support we’re receiving from the unions and the elected officials to your next-door neighbor,” said Coghill campaign manager Kyle Stewart.
In the city’s mayoral race, incumbent Bill Peduto maintains a commanding lead, at least as far as anyone can tell: City Councilwoman Darlene Harris has been ignoring filing requirements. If she continues to do so, voters may not get a look at her financial picture until state-required reports, which will be filed May 5.
As the Post-Gazette was first to report last month, Mrs. Harris and her attorney have questioned the campaign-finance ordinance’s legality, and have decried it as a means of hamstringing challengers to well-financed incumbents.
Mr. Peduto certainly can lay claim to that distinction. He had $697,835.45 at the end of March, a month in which he raised just over $80,000 and spent nearly $150,000. His other primary rival, Homewood minister John Welch, started the month with $10,741.90, added $9,392 to it and ended up with $9,577.42.
The city’s Ethics Hearing Board, which monitors compliance with the campaign finance regulations, is set to meet Thursday afternoon. Under city law, the board can fine $50 per day for a late filing, and it can either act on a complaint or take up an investigation of its own.
Ms. Harris is not the only candidate on the May ballot who appears to be ignoring the reporting requirements. Daniel Lavelle, who is running unopposed in City Council District 6, had yet to file a report by mid-day Tuesday. As the Post-Gazette reported in mid-March, Mr. Lavelle professed to be unaware of the reporting requirements, even though he voted in favor of them, and has a history of filing state-required reports late with the county. On March 16, Mr. Lavelle said “I will immediately be filing the reports with the ethics hearing [board],” and defined “immediately” as being March 17 or the morning of March 20 at the latest.
Mr. Lavelle had not so far responded to a text query sent at 12:32 Tuesday afternoon.
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @CPotterPGH





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.