ALLENTOWN — Displaced laborers and blue-collar workers in struggling industries made all the difference Tuesday night. And Pennsylvania, with its defunct mills, inactive mines and shuttered manufacturing plants, had enough of them to swing the purple state toward Donald Trump.
Pollsters and pundits failed to account for their influence because many who voted Tuesday were screened out of surveys as a result of their past records of missing most elections. But Mr. Trump, whose presidential campaign put personality ahead of policy, inspired them to turn out and seal the divisive Republican’s victory.
North Carolina and Ohio, which have similar demographics, also helped push Mr. Trump to victory.
“We didn’t anticipate this huge outpouring of white, working-class voters. We were stunned by the outpouring of them,” Franklin & Marshall University pollster G. Terry Madonna said Wednesday.
Pollsters would have missed many of those voters because their surveys target likely voters – namely those who voted in past elections. Higher than usual voter turnout means many people who normally don’t vote were inspired to turn out this time. And that skewed the polls.
“These are the people whose families a couple decades ago were doing steel and iron and paint and manufacturing – the things that made our state’s industrial economy one of the top in the country. Now that’s all gone, and these people are living marginal lives,” Mr. Madonna said. “These are people with high school educations or less who are working at jobs that provide them with a bare living, and [Mr. Trump] appealed to them.”
Read More
He also appealed to union workers who once earned good wages and now find themselves in dying industries.
The United Mine Works of America, which did not endorse either Mr. Trump or Democrat Hillary Clinton, issued a statement Wednesday about the election.
“Working families in our nation’s coalfields are very concerned about their future, and they made their voices heard loud and clear,” union president Cecil E. Roberts said. “President-elect Trump has spoken many times about addressing the serious economic disaster that is affecting large areas of Appalachia and other coal-producing areas of our country by putting coal miners back to work. No one is more interested in doing just exactly that than the UMWA.”
Exit polls showed that Mr. Trump also held strong appeal for college-educated white voters. Many of them were affected by the recession, think they’ve been left behind in the recovery, and blame the government establishment, Mr. Madonna said.
People who aren’t satisfied with the status quo see Mr. Trump as the candidate of change, and they turned up at the polls in droves, said Wilkes University political scientist Tom Baldino.
Change was on the mind of voters such as Allentown physician James A. Pantano, who was at Republican U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey’s victory party Tuesday night. Dr. Pantano stayed until the wee hours of Wednesday morning, when Mr. Trump was declared the victor.
“It’s unreal. The whole shebang. The Senate, the House, the presidency and the Supreme Court,” he marveled as the party wound down. “That changes the world. The whole world is going to be different.”
Pollsters didn’t expect that outcome.
“We were looking at it in the face and we didn’t see it even with the huge crowds he drew,” Mr. Madonna said. “People were very excited and very enthusiastic about his candidacy, and that was not reflected in the polls.”
Mr. Baldino said the big overall turnout suggests that people are angry, they’re fearful and they’re motivated by change. Mr. Trump succeeded in playing into all of that.
“He understood where the electorate was and he stoked the anger,” Mr. Baldino said. “That message was particularly important to people in Luzerne County and people in Erie County – traditional blue areas that went red” on Tuesday.
Mr. Trump’s win sent a message to top Democratic leaders in Pennsylvania.
“This was a clear sign to myself and others that we have work to do with our [suburban and rural] voters across Pennsylvania,” who don’t think their government represents them, said state Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills. “We have to do a better job of understanding the issues they’re concerned about.”
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com, 703-996-9292 or @pgPoliTweets. Harrisburg bureau chief Karen Langley contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.