Today’s sci-fi media seem to be approaching more science than fiction.
Artificial intelligence is evolving exponentially — teaching itself to respond to the world, animating robots, optimizing algorithms and living on users’ devices, ready to serve at the tap of a button. AI’s supercomputing capabilities are used for everything from advertising to war zones.
But even as the technology is achieving widespread adoption, it is not necessarily welcomed with optimism.
A recent Emerson College poll surveyed 2,000 Pennsylvanians in late November and found that nearly 1 in 3 believe AI poses a “significant threat to humanity.” The poll was sponsored by RealClearPolitics, a political news outlet and polling aggregator.
Like many Americans, residents of the Keystone State see AI seeping into their lives and data centers cropping up in their backyards — and they are wary, the survey finds.
As Athan Koutsiouroumbas, managing director at Long Nyquist and Associates, wrote for RealClearPennsylvania: “The existential dread is real.”
Read More
Their wariness extends beyond an obscure doom for humanity and into a specific skepticism about AI’s benefits for wallets and job opportunities. Polls found 48% of residents in the commonwealth think AI will have “more of a negative impact” on the economy, while 25% anticipated a positive impact.
Pennsylvanians’ outlook on AI’s impact on jobs is bleak, with 55% saying AI will decrease the jobs available in their industry — 16% said AI will increase the number of jobs and 29% said it will have no impact.

But it’s a different story when data centers are in question.
Data centers are a hot topic in neighborhoods and governments across the country — one was approved on Tuesday night in Springdale Borough. One of the most common talking points surrounding their development, separate from energy demand and electricity bills, is whether data centers will power jobs.
The November survey found that roughly 61% of Pennsylvanians think it is likely that “data centers will create a significant number of new jobs.”
Still, 20% of southwestern Pennsylvanians “strongly oppose” data centers being built near them, while 12% “strongly support.” Across the state, the survey group’s top three concerns were environmental impacts, taxpayer and utility costs, and energy demand on the grid.
‘This is not out of our hands’
What Pennsylvanians are feeling is nothing new, but it is deeply personal, said Emily DeJeu, a professor of business communication at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business.
Ms. DeJeu said all technological innovation throughout history was met with fear, and that “any enthusiasm is met with a healthy degree of skepticism.” For Pennsylvanians, she said, reactions are rooted in a “niche history” dealing with industries that are heavy on promises.
“I think we have a history of turning to industry, believing the promises, and then being so badly burned when it became clear, ‘Oh, there isn’t any loyalty to this place or these people. This really was always about a ruthless bottom-line mindset,’” Ms. DeJeu said. “And I think that’s true for the whole Rust Belt, certainly for the Pittsburgh region.”
Ms. DeJeu lives across from a “giant footprint” of a former steel mill in Beaver Falls. All around, she said, there’s only what used to be of the steel industry. She grew up in the Midwest but has called Western Pennsylvania home for 20 years.
Speaking with her neighbors, whom she said have been there for ages, has made the hurt of that abandonment palpable. Still, she said, there seemed to be something in their bones, “an ancestral tug” that tells them a big employer is going to need them to build something big.
“It’s like they’re hearing it down the ages; like, my dad and my granddad, my great-granddad heard that same story,” Ms. DeJeu said.
She said she saw that dissonance play out in real time at town hall meetings until the Shell Polymers Monaca plant went up in 2022.
“You’d sometimes hear the same person express concerns about the environment and lament that we can’t trust industry, but at the same time express a desire to see a big employer come in and create hundreds of jobs at once,” she said.
That was not the case for Springdale residents Tuesday night. A crowd of roughly 75 residents attended the borough council’s vote to approve a data center permit. There was passionate pushback and distrust of a big developer. To the crowd’s dismay, the council approved the permit in a 5-2 vote. Resident Devon McCullough said the projected tax revenue was not worth it, and the AI boom was “too reminiscent of what we’ve seen before.”
“It’s possible that this data center could theoretically provide exactly what you’re expecting in terms of tax revenue, and it would be a boon for the borough as a whole,” Mr. McCullough said. “Or, this unregulated, massive industry ... could fail, and then you have this massive building that is doing nothing for the town.”
Some council members who voted to approve the data center said they did so to avoid getting sued by the developer.
Ms. DeJeu disagrees with Mr. Koutsiouroumbas’ assertion that “Pennsylvanians understand that this transformation is inevitable, not optional,” a claim made in his RealClearPennsylvania article on the survey.
“I think some of this inevitability talk, it just overlooks the fact that humans have agency, collective action can be quite powerful,” she said. “The future could look a lot of ways. This is not out of our hands.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.