Whether Springdale is the home of a massive data center is now up to its borough council.
Residents, however, are pushing back with concerns over noise, pollution and aesthetic damage to a neighborhood they said they value for its peace and quiet.
“My fiance and I chose Springdale because we believe this place to be prime real estate for young families looking for a nice, quiet, safe community — to not only just live in, grow, raise children — just be a part of something that’s greater,” said resident James Binnix during public comment Monday night. “But I did not sign up for an opportunity zone for big tech [and] slum lords.”
One week after Springdale’s Planning Commission unanimously approved the project, the borough’s council members, about 50 residents and the project developer Allegheny DC Property Co. team convened for more than five hours of public comment Monday night, sitting under basketball hoops in the borough building’s gymnasium.
The proposed data center would reanimate the site of the former Cheswick Generating Station, with a building size of 565,000 square feet, and another 200,000 square feet of ancillary service buildings. Sitting along the Allegheny River and bordered by South Duquesne Avenue, Pittsburgh Street and Porter Street, the defunct site is in the borough’s Industrial District.
“Legally, your job is to focus on this particular data center and to determine whether it complies with your particular ordinance,” Harlan Stone, the developers’ attorney, told council members. “You’re to do that based on the evidence, the testimony and the documents that we present to you in the context of this hearing — not what you read about on the internet, not what you hear from social media, not what's going on in the newspapers, but what you hear in these hearings.”
Read More
The council will make its decision at a Dec. 16 meeting starting 6 p.m.
Allegheny DC presented six witnesses in a continuation of an October testimony. Mark Bastasch, the principal acoustical engineer for the design firm Jacobs Solutions, said the noises that would emanate from the data center are well within the borough’s ordinance of 85 decibels for residential areas. The developers have repeatedly said it would not exceed the existing sound of traffic.
But council members focused on the issue of noise for the better part of an hour, grilling Mr. Bastasch on just how loud 50 to 75 decibels actually is — Mr. Bastasch compared 55 decibels to the sound of regular conversation heard from about three feet. With a “quick Google search,” councilman Joseph Kern offered that 75 decibels amounts to the sound of a dishwasher running.
But the issue council members and residents had, was the incessant nature of the noise. It would be all day, every day, they said.
Councilman Jeffrey Hartz worried about the effects of constant noise on “our animals, our wildlife [and] autistic children.” With “outdated” ordinances, he said the borough could not have accounted for the nature of a data center.
Because there are no stipulations for data centers in Springdale’s zoning laws, the Allegheny DC team is applying for a “conditional use” permit. Some variances are still in play, awaiting the Zoning Hearing Board’s approval — those include increasing the height of the proposed data center 15 feet above the allowed 60 feet.
Feedback from the Springdale community can help guide the project at every step, said Brian Regli, an Allegheny DC consultant and a spokesman for the project. And sourcing “as much local [talent] as possible” is the goal, he said.
“If you’re willing to say yes, that doesn’t end the conversation,” he said. “The conversation continues until the lights are turned on and there's an operating data center.”
While the developers fielded the “legitimate concerns” of the borough and its residents, Mr. Regli and the development team reminded their crowd of the need to compete with states like Ohio and Maryland. If the opportunities didn’t land here, they would simply relocate, probably out of state.
“It’s a real opportunity to revitalize one of the most important properties that this community has for many generations to come,” Mr. Regli said. “And I think we can do it the right way.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.