Sidney Crosby figurines, a newly released Superman comic, and a Mega Manectric Pokémon card are among the more than nine million collectibles vaulted in a Cheswick warehouse.
Tuesday morning, those collectibles hit a new online marketplace called The Authority, a brand of Cheswick-based payment tech company, Dynamics Inc.
“If you are a parent at home who has a bunch of Pokémon cards, you can just send us a box,” said Dynamics Inc. founder Jeffrey Mullen. “We will identify the collectibles, we will authenticate and encapsulate them.”
Every item is graded for quality and encapsulated in a protective, plastic casing called a “slab.” The slab is ultrasonically welded shut to preserve the item’s condition. Anyone can visit The Authority’s website to peruse their personal “vault” virtually.
It is also a social marketplace to buy, sell, negotiate and trade millions of collectible items instantaneously.
Sitting in front of shelves full of paraphernalia on Monday, Mr. Mullen held up a Funko Pop figurine of Sidney Crosby. An item like that, stored and authenticated by The Authority, can exchange hands instantly online without ever leaving its vault in Cheswick.
Read More
“When people buy and sell on The Authority, there is no shipping that’s required,” Mr. Mullen said. “While you’re watching Sid play a game, that collectible could be transacted 10 times.”
Grading system designed to set it apart
Dan Means is the owner of Sports World Specialties on Smithfield Street. The store opened in 1986 and Mr. Means joined as owner in 2001. He has been in the collecting world since the 1990s.
In a global collectibles industry that market research and consulting firm UnivDatos valued at $462.82 billion in 2024, The Authority will have competition. Competing with grading giants alone, such as the industry leader in sports-card grading Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), Mr. Means said newcomers all have their work cut for them. He has used PSA for decades.
“Is it possible? I guess it is, if you have the right experts,” he said. “I don’t doubt any of that. What I doubt is trying to take the share away from PSA.”
If The Authority can do it all — not only authenticating and vaulting, but grading too — he said that would be “amazing.” But The Authority could possibly be working with the likes of PSA, Mr. Mullen said.
“We will be working with a number of companies in the hobby, but cannot comment further at this time,” Mr. Mullen said on Tuesday.
Coming from years in the credit and debit card industry with Dynamics, Mr. Mullen is well-versed with security and authentication.
“The collectible industry is getting really harmed with really advanced fraud and counterfeiting and hustling and people being able to misrepresent things,” he said, later adding that “before the items are actually put on sale for retail, they’re authenticated and encapsulated, so that they can’t be modified by wrongdoers in the future.”
Dynamics has three business arms: electronics, security, and safety and collectibles.
The Authority marketplace combines all of the company’s technologies — from “hardcore manufacturing,” to robotics, to web software, to secure transaction systems, to data management.
Mr. Mullen said that The Authority’s grading system sets it apart.
“Everyone can actually see why these have a grade of an eight or a nine or a 10, and they can actually check our work, which isn’t [typically] done,” he said.
Grading is a sore subject in the collecting world, he said.
Not unlike the diamond industry, collectible paraphernalia are graded on their condition, typically on a scale of 1 to 10. But, he said, it lacks consistency.
The Authority has used its universal system with retailers for the past three years. On its new website, users can decide to grade items at any time, separate from authentication, by paying a fee that “reveals” the grade — meaning that if a user submits a Tom Brady card from before his first game, they could pay grade him after he throws a touchdown, or wait years down the line.
By creating a universal standard — what he called a “tremendously engineering-oriented task” — The Authority is trying to build credibility.
“We plan to use the industry’s first public grading standard to teach millions of collectors how to grade their collectibles with precision and consistency,” Mr. Mullen said in an announcement Tuesday.
Authenticating on a large scale from a seven-acre facility (three acres of which are covered) in Cheswick takes a team. Mr. Mullen said Dynamics has hired more than 100 people this year, and plans to add another 50.
“We have a countless number of local grads,” said Mr. Mullen, a Carnegie Mellon University alum. “We hire predominantly locally from the region, except we are [also] trying to bring in experts in certain fields, like the best comic book experts and trading-card experts.”
‘Closer to your collectibles’
Although Mr. Mullen has degrees in engineering, law and business, he was a collector first.
As a kid, his father, a Wall Street trader, took Mr. Mullen and his best friends to conventions.
“He gave me and my best friends each 100 bucks. And he said, ‘whoever comes out with the most money wins, and gets another $100,” Mr. Mullen recalled. “It was about making relationships, learning what people needed and connecting them. So you may walk in with $100 to a trading card show, but you might walk out with $200-worth of cards and another $200 in cash, if you knew what you were doing.”
Still, Mr. Mullen said that at the core of it all — beyond the collecting and beyond the grading — the point is building friendships. After all, he said, “the reason you collect, is to find other people with you.”
Selling part of his own collection actually helped fund Mr. Mullen’s time at CMU for business school, and provided the seed money for Dynamics, he said.
Collectibles companies started coming to Dynamics in 2011 for secure financial transaction expertise. Working directly with auction houses and channel retailers, such as long-time trading card retailer Upper Deck, also will allow customers to synchronize inventories.
“Channel retailers are sending us their collectibles, and we are encapsulating them and grading them so that when you buy them from retailers, you can just press a button and they instantly transfer into your collection,” Mr. Mullen said.
Even though inventory can be traded in seconds, the actual items go nowhere — not until a collector decides to ship items from Cheswick to their front door.
Mr. Means, of Sports World Specialties, personally likes to display his collections.
While every collector is different, Mr. Means never understood the need to send collectibles to vaults, like PSA’s and now, The Authority’s. Sending items to a company to keep for you, he said, means “you have to have a lot of trust as a collector.”
“It seems to me like if you have things that are that valuable, you also would have a way to keep it secure,” Mr. Means said.
But Mr. Mullen said having a searchable online vault instead of a cluttered closet at home actually “brings you closer to your collectibles.”
“This puts your collection in your pocket,” he said. “It puts your collection everywhere you go.”
And this way, collectors don’t have to wait for the store to open.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.