Getting every U.S. home and business connected to the internet will take longer than planned as Pennsylvania and every other state scrambles to compete again for government-funded broadband expansion money, experts say.
The Pennsylvania Broadband Development Authority had anticipated awarding contracts for expanded high-speed broadband service by the end of the year, but those plans have been pushed back a year or more by new U.S. Department of Commerce bidding rules. Instead of improving internet access, though, experts say the new criteria disadvantage Rural America by adding an internet service option that is more costly and slower than other technologies.
The broadband authority said the final proposals for expansion projects must be submitted to the government by Sept. 4.
“The PBDA is on track to meet that deadline and moving quickly to connect every Pennsylvanian to high-speed, affordable internet by 2030,” the authority said in a prepared statement Tuesday. The authority’s next public meeting is July 17.
Drew Garner, director of policy engagement at the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society, a nonprofit, nonpartisan public policy outfit based in Wilmette, Ill., said the new round of bidding will favor technologies with the lowest upfront costs, which will include satellite service that costs less initially, but is ultimately more expensive and less reliable than fiber-optic cable.
U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said the new bidding rules are “technology neutral,” which will reduce the cost of getting speedy broadband to every address in the U.S. But Mr. Garner said the technology-agnostic approach will lead to cost-cutting that would hurt consumers.
Read More
“The lowest cost wins, a model that has failed in the past,” he said. “It’s kind of a race to the bottom at this point. We could already have had shovels in the ground if they hadn’t done all this.”
Satellite internet connections are excellent for reaching remote areas that cannot be reached by fiber-optic cable, the industry’s gold standard, Mr. Garner said, and the upfront costs of connection are lower than fiber optic. But the monthly fees for satellites are about double those for fiber-optic connections — $120 versus $50 to $60 — and the service is slower and less reliable.
Pennsylvania has been allotted $1.16 billion by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration to hook up every home and business to speedy, reliable internet service in a state where some 255,000 sites are essentially in digital darkness. Counties have joined private internet service companies in bidding on internet expansion work.
Now, they have to draft new bids because of the change in government bidding criteria.
“Our goal was to come up with a plan to cover everybody” in Fayette County, where about 8,000 addresses are without good broadband connections, said Fayette County Commissioner Vince Vicites. “And we did it. We accomplished it.
“Now, unfortunately, it’s going to delay this even further,” he said. “It’ll set us back years and there’s nothing we can do about it.”
In a statement Tuesday, the broadband authority said cost would not be the only consideration in awarding bids.
“Proposals must also meet technical requirements and must be scalable to meet future demands,” according to the statement.
Starlink, a division of Elon Musk’s SpaceX, is among the providers of satellite internet service in Pennsylvania. The company did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday.
Fayette County resident John Detisch knows well the problems of rural broadband; by Monday, he had been without an internet connection for three days and service representatives, who he had reached out to at least four times, had not been helpful, he said.
“They just say there’s a service outage, but they don’t bother telling us why,” the 73-year-old retired facilities director said, adding that shuddering video and frequent outages are common. “The service is just terrible here.”
Even his internet telephone is not reliable inside his house, he said. A telephone landline is his backup communications plan in a sparsely populated pocket of Luzerne Township, where more than 100 beehive ovens once made coke from coal.
The cost of Mr. Detisch’s cable internet service: $235 a month.
“Your life really does center around that piece of electronics,” he said. “So when things go out, it’s really bad.”
Quincy, Mass.-based Breezeline, a division of Cogeco Communications Inc. of Montreal, is Mr. Detisch’s cable internet provider.
A company spokesman said the power outages and heat wave in the Uniontown area of Fayette County over the past 10 days can affect service, which include power spikes that often accompany outages.
“We've had both heavy rainfall and a serious heat wave in the area, which contributed both to utility company power outages as well as some likely technology issues to address in the field,” said Criss Bubacz, director of Network Surveillance at Breezeline.
In the past, private internet service companies submitting bids for federal Broadband Equity Access & Deployment funding had been encouraged to offer moderately priced plans for lower-income consumers to win favor in ranking awards, but that provision was axed in the new bidding guidelines. Broadband companies are still encouraged to offer high-speed service at reasonable costs, but there’s no mechanism for enforcement, the Benton Institute’s Mr. Garner said.
“It’s self-certification now. It’s toothless,” he said. “High cost is the number one reason people can’t get online.”
Low-income residents also suffered a setback in May when Trump canceled $2.75 billion in Digital Equity Act funding, which included about $37 million for laptops and internet training in Pennsylvania. Trump called the program “racist” and “unconstitutional.”
Vermont, Maine, Wisconsin and Idaho are among the states that were weighing a legal challenge to the funding cut.
The Benton Institute’s Mr. Garner said the government’s ambitious plan to bring high-speed internet access to every U.S. address had gone off the rails with new priorities that will slow progress.
“We will likely end up kind of building bridges to nowhere,” he said. “If we build these bridges out there, what was the point?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.