Pennsylvania’s access to $25.5 million in federal grant money to assure equity in providing speedy internet service for every home and business is uncertain after the state failed to take the first step needed to receive the money.

The Pennsylvania Broadband Development Authority voted April 10 against adopting rules for grant recipients for the state’s Digital Skills & Community Capacity Program, a pot of money allotted to the state in December by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration. In January 2024, Pennsylvania adopted a plan to assure equal access to the internet to all residents, including people living in rural areas, people with low incomes, the disabled, the elderly and others.

The money was part of the federal $2.75 billion Digital Equity Act of 2021.

But a lot has changed since then and the board’s inability to reach consensus on the guidelines reflects bigger questions about the Biden administration’s once-in-a-generation promise to extend speedy internet connections to every home and business in the country.

Advertise with us

The need for internet access is acute in rural areas, where dead spots are common and internet service providers have historically avoided because there are fewer customers than in cities.

The promise of internet for all is on hold with a new administration in Washington, which has already signaled that it plans to change some program requirements.

“We are riding an ever-changing wave, to put it politely,” PBDA Executive Director Brandon Carson said at the board’s April 10 meeting.

Mr. Carson said the authority has been in almost daily contact with the NTIA to keep abreast of potential changes to the program.

Board member Carl Metzgar, a Republican state representative from Somerset, voted against adopting the guidelines, saying there was “almost certainly a mismatch” between the proposed rules and “policies on the way” from Washington, which have eschewed the principles of diversity, equity and inclusion in government contracting.

Advertise with us

Abstaining from the vote was board member Kyle Kopko, who is also executive director of the Center for Rural Pennsylvania, and so the vote failed.

The NTIA has approved $1.16 billion to extend high-speed broadband service to every address in Pennsylvania, but the state has not yet received the money. At the same time, the authority was preparing to issue construction grants to internet service providers on behalf of county and local governments next month as the NTIA operates without a leader.

Arielle Roth, who has been nominated to fill the post, awaits U.S. Senate confirmation as NTIA director.

At the same time, internet companies and local governments have already submitted plans to the state to expand the internet with fiber optic cable, raising the question of whether the plans will have to be revised and resubmitted to meet new Trump administration rules.

“Retroactively changing conditions risks stranding private capital, reducing provider participation and confidence and discouraging future investment in broadband infrastructure expansion,” Kevin Taglang, executive editor at the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society, a Wilmette, Ill.-based trade group, wrote in an opinion piece last month.

Advertise with us

Board member Kristin Phillips-Hill, a Republican state senator from York County who voted in favor of the equity program guidelines, was concerned about the lack of clarity from Washington.

“I think they need to understand this program may never happen,” she said after the meeting. “It’s a little nebulous. I’m hoping we can get that much-needed clarity from the federal government.”

Ms. Roth, who is awaiting Senate confirmation, has already criticized the Biden-era strategy for rolling out expanded broadband, including the required lower-cost internet access service plans for people meeting certain income guidelines, union hiring provisions for cable workers and required climate change considerations. She has also been critical of the program’s preference for fiber optic cable over satellite internet connections in serving remote areas.

Elon Musk’s low-Earth orbiting satellite company Starlink would be a big beneficiary of the “tech neutral” approach promoted by Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, a Trump appointee. The Biden administration favored fiber optic cable connections.

But Ms. Roth has said she would not show favoritism to Starlink and Mr. Lutnick has said that satellites would allow states to “provide internet access for the lowest cost.”

Advertise with us

In 2023, there were more than 280,000 Pennsylvania homes and businesses with slow or lacking internet service, including many rural areas. As questions have arisen about federal support for internet for all, many counties have tapped American Rescue Plan Act grants to get residents connected, including Fayette, Washington and Westmoreland counties.

In Beaver County, ARPA money has been used to install more than 265 miles of fiber optic cable, allowing the county to reach 925 homes. Beaver has identified 2,620 addresses without adequate broadband access.