Counselors at the South Side-based Advantage Credit Counseling service who work with consumers overwhelmed with credit card debt have been seeing more people struggling to pay for items they bought on “buy now, pay later” plans.

“They see it as a small payment and get sucked in,” said Heather Murray, director of compliance and community relations. “If they’re not careful they can really end up in a serious money management crisis, because these payments add up.”

Buy now, pay later— also known as BNPL — is a deferred payment option that doesn’t require a hard credit check and it generally allows the consumer to split a purchase into smaller installments, typically four or less, often with a downpayment of only 25% due at checkout.

This form of payment — which competes with traditional credit cards — has taken the retail industry by storm since the start of the pandemic, and lately has been under more scrutiny by consumer advocate organizations.

Advertise with us

The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has issued a series of orders to the five leading companies offering BNPL credit — Affirm, Afterpay, Klarna, PayPal and Zip — for information to evaluate the debt consumers are accumulating and examine data harvesting in a consumer market that is quickly changing with technology.

Meanwhile, the growing popularity of BNPL has brought problems that include customers paying for items before they receive them due to supply chain disruptions as well as trouble getting refunds or reaching customer service, according to Consumer Reports based in Yonkers, NY.

“If everything works smoothly and you don’t have a problem it’s great. But if you run into a problem it may be more time-consuming to resolve it,” said Chuck Bell, a financial policy advocate with Consumer Reports.

Consumers Reports has come to the conclusion that consumers are usually better protected using a credit card for retail purchases because certain credit industry rules don’t apply to BNPL providers which credit cards companies must abide by.

Matilde Hoffman works on her computer at a coffee shop July 25, 2012 in New York City. Online shoppers are the easiest targets for BNPL companies because the companies make their sales pitches at the checkout point. (Allison Joyce / Getty Images)

When the impulse buy is the form of payment

Advertise with us

Online shoppers are the easiest targets for BNPL companies because the companies make their sales pitches at the checkout point.

Instead of the customer seeing a total cost for the products they are buying, the BNPL companies will offer to accept only 25% of the total amount and allow the customer to make zero-interest installment payments on the other 75%.

More consumers are taking advantage of the chance to buy items and spread the payments out over time to BNPL companies instead of paying the total cost upfront. But those payments are taking sizable chunks of cash out of household budgets, according to Pittsburgh-area credit counselors.

“A lot of clients are using Klarna,” Ms. Murray said. “A lot of people also do it through QVC, which offers four easy payments.

“When you purchase four or five items and they’re all coming out of your checking account every month you can really start to see a negative impact on your cashflow if you’re not planning properly.”

Advertise with us

Advantage Credit Counseling helps people struggling with consumer debt by negotiating settlements with the credit card companies. The consumer makes a single consolidated payment to Advantage Credit Counseling and the agency disperses payments to various creditors.

Since the pandemic, Ms. Murray said Advantage Credit Counseling have had to start including BNPL companies in the monthly payout for debt consolidations they make on behalf of clients.

One of the big selling points BNPL companies use is its quick application process and higher tolerance for serving consumers with scant or subprime credit histories.

One Advantage Credit counselor said she sees BNPL companies more often on credit reports now when she looks them up. Most of the time, the accounts are paid in full because of the short-term nature of the installment agreements.

But the relative ease of acquiring this type of debt is cause for concern in the credit industry.

Advertise with us

“This is a disaster waiting to happen,” Ms. Murray said. “This will start people to financing for longer terms items instead of saving for a purchase.”

Not exactly credit

Some of the problems consumers are bound to encounter with products such as returns, refund requests or contacting customer service make BNPL purchases riskier than using a credit card.

“Not everybody realizes the BNPL is a third-party financing company,” said Mr. Bell at Consumer Reports. “So, a return not only involves making the return to retailers. You have to make sure you get credit for your payment from the financing company.

“That’s something that surprises consumers,” he said. “But if you use BNPL and never have to make a return, you might not even run into that problem.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Bell said since BNPL companies have made the argument that the payment arrangements are installment plans instead of credit, the industry doesn’t need to meet all the rules that credit card companies must meet.

BNPL companies are covered by some financial laws such as the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. But they don’t need to meet the same requirements as credit card companies do for things like sending billing statements or standardized presentation of fees and late charges.

“We’re concerned that some people might miss some of the information they need to know about late payments,” Mr. Bell said. “Or, whether the BNPL plan is using a soft or hard credit check; whether it reports to a credit bureau; and if you don’t pay do they send your debt to debt collectors?

“There’s some evidence people don’t even necessarily think of it as a loan or a credit product,” he said. “They just think it’s some feature being offered by the store to allow you to take the merchandise home today.”

The way the BNPL industry works is the customer buys a retail product for $100, but only pay $25 up front. The BNPL company pays $94 to purchase the account from the retailer. The customer pays $100 back to the BNPL company.

Advertise with us

The retailer receives $94 for the $100 product. The BNPL company makes $6 when the total purchase price is paid by the consumer. The consumer gets the product with no interest or fees, which might have been too expensive to pay for in full at the time of the purchase.

Major retailers participating in the BNPL industry include Adidas, Best Buy, Peloton, Neiman Marcus, Nike and Delta Vacations.

BNPL payments in the U.S. are expected to hit $82 billion this year, according to ResearchAndMarkets.com.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is particularly interested in how BNPL lenders harvest consumer data.(Dreamstime/TNS)

More data on the line

In December, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sent out a big data request to BNPL companies to formally access how the business is working and how consumers are holding up.

Advertise with us

“Buy now, pay later credit is the new version of the old layaway plan, but with modern, faster twists where the consumer gets the product immediately but gets the debt immediately, too,” said Rohit Chopra, CFPB director.

“We have ordered Affirm, Afterpay, Klarna, Paypal and Zip to submit information so that we can report to the public about industry practices and risks.”

The CFPB expects to publish aggregated findings on insights learned from the inquiry.

The federal agency is particularly interested in how consumers are accumulating debt due to the ease of using BNPL; regulatory arbitrage because many BNPL companies do not provide dispute resolution protections available to credit card users; and data harvesting, because BNPL lenders have access to the valuable payment histories of their customers.

“Some have used this collected data to create closed loop shopping apps with partner merchants, pushing specific brands and products, often geared toward younger audiences,” the CFPB said in a statement.

Advertise with us

“As competitive forces pressure the merchant discount, lenders will need to find other sources of revenue to maintain growth and profitability,” the CFPB said. “The Bureau would like to better understand practices around data collection, behavioral targeting, data monetization and the risks they may create for consumers.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591