Two summers ago, avocado toast broke the internet.
For the uninitiated, avocado toast is a delightful snack consisting of a creamy layer of its namesake buttery superfruit with a bit of salt, pepper, lemon juice and whatever fixings you’d like all atop a piece of toasty bread.
And, strange as it may sound, it’s also a stand-in for a generation’s disenchantment with capitalism.
Apparently he forgot the 34k his grandfather bestowed upon him to start said first business. That's lots of avocado toast...
— Mike (@mykleetorres) May 16, 2017
After millionaire Tim Gurner, an Australian property developer, told television news program “60 Minutes” that he thought millennials couldn’t buy homes while also purchasing “smashed avocado for $19,” the internet freaked out.
While his comments about avocado toast were seen as inflammatory to some, Mr. Gurner did point toward a harsh reality for many young adults — under crippling student debt, 20- and 30-somethings are delaying marriage, renting longer and putting off parenthood.
They’re eschewing the “American Dream” and even the underlying economic system that America subscribes to: capitalism. And that’s whether they’re avocado toast junkies, or not.
Read More
“These kids are growing up in a time where financial uncertainty is the highest it’s ever been,” said Milla Stolte, head of strategy at Smith Brothers Agency, a North Shore-based advertising firm. “They’re the first generation not to make more than their parents.”
And, as the middle class continues to shrink (according to a September 2018 Pew Research report, the share of adults in the middle class fell by 10 percentage points between 1971 and 2011), many of these young people are pointing the finger at capitalism — an economic system of free markets, private industry and competition where the winner often takes all.
Their favorite public forum to decry capitalism? Twitter, naturally.
When people claim that capitalism helps people... pic.twitter.com/M00yOkPd5Q
— Millennials for Revolution 🌹 (@Bernlennials) April 4, 2019
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔 pic.twitter.com/RtysU9f6GY
— Millennial Capitalists of America (@milcaps_USA) November 30, 2018
It’s ‘fine to rebel’
Among 18- to 29-year-old Americans, just 42 percent said they support a society built on capitalism, according to a 2016 poll conducted by Harvard’s public policy institute, the Kennedy School.
Expressing disdain for an economic system through online humor feels a bit bizarre.
That’s probably because this kind of criticism would have fallen flat with earlier generations, according to Scott Kiesling, an associate professor of linguistics at the University of Pittsburgh.
“When I thought of capitalism at the millennials’ age, it was aligned with the United States and patriotism. To question it was to be nonpatriotic,” said Mr. Kiesling, who falls somewhere between Gen X and the baby boomer era. “Because the world was decided between capitalists and communists, and those were the bad guys.”
For 20- and 30-somethings, capitalism has always been the dominant economic force. In this case, Mr. Kiesling said, it’s “fine to rebel,” because they can effectively criticize capitalism without aligning with an “evil empire” like the Soviet Union.
When words change connotation or meaning, linguists call this “semantic change.” It’s quite common, Mr. Kiesling said.
He offers the example of “dude,” a word that now mostly associated with young men. “A dude in the past was a guy that was a snappy dresser. It came from [the song] ‘Yankee Doodle Dandy,’” Mr. Kiesling explained.
Down the line, “doodle dandy” was shortened to “dude” and generally kept its meaning of a sharp dresser, but it took on a negative connotation. It was used to describe gangs in the Southwest who dressed well, although “dude” was meant as a derogatory term.
These gangs started to reclaim the term by referring to one another as “dude,” and this use eventually spread to create the meaning we know today.

Memes vs. capitalism
Young adults have repurposed the term “capitalism” by poking fun at larger economic issues that impact them — sometimes satirically “thanking” capitalism for their student loan debt, other times taking a jab at folks in the upper class.
On any given day, you can find tweets referencing Donald Trump’s 2015 comment from the presidential campaign trail that he received a “small loan of a million dollars” from his father.
Over here waiting for a small loan of a million dollars. 🍊 https://t.co/VwKQlOekBo
— Matt. (@kid__matthew) April 7, 2019
Twitter users are, generally speaking, younger and more left-leaning than the rest of the U.S. population, according to a new study Pew Research Center put out on Wednesday.
Specifically, about 63 percent of Twitter users ages 18 to 49 identify as Democrats or lean left, compared to the 55 percent of 18- to 49-year-olds who identify the same way in the real world.
Coupled with the fact that about 80 percent of tweets come from just 10 percent of users — the rest are more “lurkers” who consume content — it’s entirely possible that this segment of the Twittersphere is a vocal minority and that most young adults don’t feel the same disassociation with capitalism.
But maybe the vocal minority speak to a larger truth for their generation.
Given the popularity of presidential candidate Bernie Sanders — a self-described democratic socialist who wants access to health care and free college for everyone — young adults really may be fed up with capitalism. All in all, Mr. Sanders won 43 percent of the popular vote in the 2016 Democratic primaries.

Social media was also an active component of that election cycle. Beyond the Russian troll factory that bought ads on Facebook and used fake Twitter accounts to push for a Trump presidency, there was also the “Bernie Sanders’ Dank Meme Stash” on Facebook.
Users on that page, which supports Mr. Sanders, share images, links to stories and memes that are decidedly non-capitalist. There are posts that point the finger at those donating to rebuild the Notre Dame Cathedral but who haven’t also decided to help end world hunger or poverty. There are posts calling for the end of the private health insurance industry. There are even a few that directly criticize Wall Street.
Laura Brown, an assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Pittsburgh, said memes circulate most often when they characterize the speech of a group or comment on how a particular group speaks or thinks.
“The implications of this [social media] critique in some ways suggest that capitalism is a distinctly millennial problem,” she said.
Reclaiming the avocado
Ms. Stolte at Smith Brothers Agency said it’s no accident that avocados have become the emblem of a generation.
After folks online were initially outraged by the thought that millennials could afford homes if they stopped buying avocado toast, they began using the healthy snack as a sort of inside joke.
“When the recession hit, a lot of millennials started to absolutely feel the crunch, and food became the luxury symbol,” Ms. Stolte said. “Instead of buying cars or clothes for luxury, they started using food to define their personality, status and cool cachet.”
When the Australian real estate developer went after the last luxury that young adults felt they could afford — healthy foods — it was the perfect storm to create a backlash on social media.
Yes, I eat #avocadotoast. No, that's not why I'm not buying a house. #Millennials
— Catie Fowler (@fowler_catie) April 24, 2019
*Also, Squeaky makes his Twitter debut! pic.twitter.com/n9KfFA6SgG
This Millennial suddenly realized I was, in fact, having avocado toast for lunch.
— Chris Branigan (@ChrisBranigan) April 17, 2019
Sometimes, you gotta embrace the stereotype. 😀#avocadotoast
[google it] pic.twitter.com/pzJA6ECbBC
For my millennial followers, here's a great recipe for #AvocadoToast:
— Rep. Steve Knight (@SteveKnight25) February 23, 2018
1) wheat toast
2) crushed avocados
3) salt & pepper
4) paprika
5) sweeping middle class and pro-growth tax cuts#TaxReformWorkshttps://t.co/MLX75NIiad
“To me, as a millennial, seeing the memes online, it’s almost like a tongue-in-cheek replacement for a Chanel logo,” Ms. Stolte said with a laugh. “It’s done in this sarcastic way, as things only born on the internet can be.”
Yet, that joke has become so ingrained into young adult culture that it’s come full circle. Massive companies are, ironically, using the symbol for marketing purposes or to sell products.
Consider the Dallas-based convenience store chain 7-Eleven. The company posted that its newest Slurpie beverage would be flavored like avocado toast. That was an April Fools’ joke, but it was likely intended to engage current and potential new customers.
Introducing Avocado Toast Slurpee! That's right, folks! You asked for it, we've delivered! Sound off below if you can't wait to try it! 🥑🍞 pic.twitter.com/ajGFKvFPSF
— 7-Eleven (@7eleven) April 1, 2019
American Eagle Outfitters, the South Side-based clothing retailer, sells sweatshirts emblazoned with the words “avocado toast.”
Ms. Stolte said the irony of these capitalistic transactions points to the fact that young adults aren’t perfect.
“We’re always caught between having ideals and the walking-the-walk part ... folks agree ideologically about certain things, but millennials are so focused on fixing the big picture that they forget it comes down to their own actions,” she said.
“You just want to go out there and consume. It’s a horrible Catch-22.”
Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.