On a rainy Monday morning in November, an event space on 62nd Street was sardined with highly caffeinated people mingling over a networking breakfast — geeky problem-solvers and coders rubbing elbows with sharply dressed investors and marketers rubbing elbows with men donning flannel and scraggly beards rubbing elbows with environmentalists and restaurateurs.
The format — billed as a summit with a daylong series of speakers and panels hosted at Tree Pittsburgh’s freshly built offices in Upper Lawrenceville — was not uncommon in Pittsburgh, where a constellation of tech startups meets frequently to pitch artificial intelligence, machine learning and big data solutions to a range of industries.
This diverse crowd banded together to plot something different — a new type of challenge just as complicated, risky and ambitious as an autonomous car: a revolution in the Pittsburgh region’s food system.
In recent weeks, a fledgling group of companies has mobilized to help struggling small farms more efficiently manage their crops and livestock and boost their business.
The thinking goes that, with sensors to remotely monitor cows, horses and greenhouses; predictive analytics to increase crop yield; and drones that capture field conditions, farms cannot only survive but also thrive on consumers’ demand for healthier, locally sourced food.
“I care about the fact that my lettuce comes from 5,000 miles away, that my tomatoes come from Canada, and my other vegetables come from Chile or Mexico — and yet we’re surrounded by farms,” said Stefan Vantchev, who organized the ag-tech summit and grows more animated the longer he talks about the food system.
Read More
“It’s time for us to start taking this seriously.”
Mr. Vantchev, who grew up on his family’s farm in Bulgaria and ended up falling in love with software development, has settled down in Toronto, Ohio, built his own greenhouse and taught himself how to grow food.
With lessons learned from that experience, he co-founded Panacea.ag, a startup producing smart greenhouse automation systems, in 2017. Simple sensors that measure variables such as temperature and humidity and control lights and ventilation can shave utility costs and save a greenhouse owner lots of time.

He recently dropped off his sensors at the Drew Mathieson Center for Horticulture and Agricultural Technology in Manchester, a wholesale dealer of flowers that plans to begin growing food in its acre of greenhouse next year.
It didn’t take him long to realize the ag-tech scene in Pittsburgh was surprisingly quiet.
He decided to ask around: Why can’t a group of excited entrepreneurs start something big?
Looking nationwide, his interest in ag-tech is not exactly bleeding-edge thinking.
Agriculture is an inherently risky business at the mercy of unpredictable weather, large swings in global prices and political whims. Removing some of that uncertainty is the goal of startups and venture capital firms concentrated in Silicon Valley and Midwest farming hubs like St. Louis and Kansas City.
But many of those efforts are targeted to factory farms. And they perpetuate the food system that Mr. Vantchev and others believe is broken — delivering food that is nutritionally deficient, easily contaminated and traveling unnecessarily long distances.
The technology often leaves behind small farms in Pennsylvania.
In 2017, Pennsylvania recorded 58,000 farms operating on 7.6 million acres, according to an annual survey by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. While the average U.S. farm spanned 444 acres that year, Pennsylvania farms averaged about 132 acres, near the bottom of major farming states.
Many farmers in the Pittsburgh region can’t support themselves on growing food alone and have day jobs so they can keep operating — or they sell to a real estate developer.

Tech to save horses
A neighboring farm property was being razed on a recent afternoon as Rob and Tammy Crouthamel fed their horses peppermint candy treats about 45 minutes north of Pittsburgh in Butler County.
The married couple, who have owned the horse farm since 2000, recently turned to sensors to track their animals and notify them in the event of an emergency.
Until recently, they were managing the farm with day jobs: Rob was an engineer for Industrial Scientific and then a startup focused on workplace safety, and Tammy worked in communications for a nonprofit.
One morning, they found one of their horses had died overnight of a stomach condition.
Reviewing camera footage, the couple felt they could have saved the horse’s life with simple intervention. A tube passed through the horse’s nose through the stomach could have dispensed fluids to hydrate and broken up the blockages.
Horses, like any animal, show signs of injury and illness in subtle ways, they said. On another day, Mrs. Crouthamel noticed a horse was choking based on the angle it was holding its head.
Years of painful experiences and ideas jotted down in a notebook led them to start Farm Jenny, a company that makes sensors to track animals, collect large amounts of data, and send alerts to farmers.
“If you can catch illnesses and injuries early, you can intervene, reduce vet costs and save lives,” Mrs. Crouthamel said.
Plenty of headwinds
Success for tech companies in farming hinges on reversing large-scale trends in a broader American food system built on factory farms in places such as the Great Plains and California.
To scale up production in Western Pennsylvania, the smattering of local farms and greenhouses would have to fit in with large food distributors like Sysco and grocers like O’Hara-based Giant Eagle. Ultimately, consumers on a wider scale would have to care enough to put their dollars into locally grown food.
Tech startups here, regardless of application, can also face roadblocks in getting capital. Pittsburgh has such a dearth of venture capital firms compared to other tech-minded cities that the startup community often calls it a “valley of death.”
The timing of the push to scale up farming technology may be favorable, as tech firms could find a powerful ally in state officials. Pennsylvania agriculture officials are looking for ways to build a local food system around Pittsburgh.
“In tech, we say, fail fast and iterate, but there’s really no failing fast in agriculture because the growing cycle is so long.”
Nicole Muise-Kielkucki, director of impact innovations for Idea Foundry
Perhaps the biggest code to crack? Selling skeptical farmers on largely unproven technology.
“Farmers and business people rely heavily on their neighbors and competitors to see who’s tried this before,” said Nicole Muise-Kielkucki, director of impact innovations for Idea Foundry, which sponsored the ag-tech summit. “There has to be a lot of buy-in from the ground up.”
In 2016, Idea Foundry, a nonprofit economic development group in Oakland, began offering revolving loans to promising ventures in the food supply chain, with loan repayment based on revenues eventually earned. That can take out some of the risk for borrowers, who can vary from techies to farmers. Idea Foundry has supported almost two dozen food- and agriculture-related ventures, Ms. Muise-Kielkucki said.
“We’ve seen a level of risk aversion to adopting new methods and practices because of the long growing cycle,” Ms. Muise-Kielkucki said.
“In tech, we say, fail fast and iterate, but there’s really no failing fast in agriculture because the growing cycle is so long.”
Truefit, a Downtown software firm that works with a variety of industries, is trying to bridge that gap, said Amanda Yarger, a business development manager. The company makes a dashboard that a farmer would see on their phone or computer — organizing the raw data and code to the person who needs to make sense of it, she explained.
When working, Truefit uses focus groups and a two-way mirror so a tech creator can watch farmers’ genuine reaction.
“A lot of [tech developers] are in a stage in which they have a working prototype on the hardware, but they’re just now trying to make sense of the data,” Ms. Yarger said. “It’s working, but it’s not necessary going to be what the [farmer] is going to buy.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.

Taking risk is necessary for growth. This series profiles the region's entrepreneurs, policymakers, scientists and others who have embraced challenges and incorporated new ideas – sometimes the kind that seem a little crazy – into their plans. 

Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.