Guillermo Jose, a 40-year-old information systems professional with four master’s degrees and an interminable resume, radiates confidence that he has what it takes to bring big data to health care, finance and human resources.
But after a frustrating seven months looking for a job in Pittsburgh, he isn’t so sure that this is the place to do it.
He estimates he put in some 60 applications and was called in for a handful of interviews. But on Wednesday, Mr. Jose’s temporary visa expired and he went back to his home country of Mexico, leaving behind his fiancee Elena Gutierrez McKelligan, who has a consulting job in Pittsburgh.
For Mr. Jose, the vexation went beyond being turned away from jobs he said he believes he’s qualified to do. It’s that Pittsburgh businesses are publicly embracing technology, while privately failing to notice a disconnect on their front lines of hiring.
“They say, ‘Well, what does data analysis have to do with finance?’ ” Mr. Jose said, generalizing conversations he’s had with some hiring managers. “And I think, I can’t believe you’re asking that question.”
Mr. Jose’s situation is not an isolated case.
As Pittsburgh positions itself as a hub for technology companies, aspiring tech workers — many of them immigrants from India, Mexico and the Middle East, and educated at schools like Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh — are struggling to find work with large employers.
At the same time, large companies in finance, health care and professional services are being confronted by changes in technology: racing to solve challenges like cyber-security and customer privacy and to harness opportunities with big data, such as using predictive analytics.
That undercurrent in the hiring process in Pittsburgh was amplified in May when the Allegheny Conference on Community Development urged companies to rethink job descriptions.
If employers don’t work with educators to adjust their recruitment to fit with new skills and competencies, the group found, the regional workforce could come up short by 80,000 people by 2025.
“I think when companies complain about not being able to find talent, and talent complains about not being able to get an interview and be hired, there’s this disconnect,” said Laura Fisher, senior vice president of special projects and workforce for the Allegheny Conference.
The mismatch of skills in tech jobs is representative of a larger problem for southwestern Pennsylvania, Ms. Fisher said: Just 43 percent of people who graduate with bachelor’s degrees from regional schools find a job here, according to the Allegheny Conference report. For associate’s degrees, that number is 62 percent.
“That’s not a great track record,” Ms. Fisher said. “If we did a better job of retaining that talent, it would go a long way toward resolving the workforce challenge.”
More flexibility needed
The challenge is not news to Vera Krekanova Krofcheck, chief strategy officer for the Three Rivers Workforce Investment Board. The Downtown agency, which helps people find steady jobs and careers, has been working to match job seekers with employers by better defining a “tech job,” she said.
“There are a lot of jobs being transformed by technology, but they’re not being understood as technology jobs,” said Ms. Krofcheck, part of a working group involved in the Allegheny Conference report.
If workers “are aspiring pretty high, they see that the market is very small in Pittsburgh and they go to Silicon Valley” to work for giants like Google and Apple. “They don’t necessarily consider the jobs in the next tier: tech jobs embedded in other industries like health and banking.”
At the same time, large employers must be willing to break with conventional wisdom when crafting job descriptions.
As an example, a way for corporations to filter for inexperienced candidates is to require three to five years of experience. Yet that’s not a good measurement for tech-centric jobs. “It’s very tricky because there are technologies that haven’t been in place for three to five years,” Ms. Krofcheck said.
Employers have also piled on skills required for certain jobs. Called “upcredentialing” in workforce lingo, it’s a trend that has its origins in the 2008 recession, when employers had their pick of the most skilled workers, said Ms. Fisher.
More flexibility in hiring might have retained Deepthi Ramakrishna, a 28-year-old who came to CMU from India and graduated in May with a master’s degree in information systems management. She began putting in applications last winter, when she was still a student.
Her husband had been working in the city for several years. “For raising a family, I thought Pittsburgh would be a very nice option,” Ms. Ramakrishna said. “It’s the right size and affordable.”
But the companies that responded would not commit to hiring someone still in school or before that person had certain experience, she said. In April, she got a job offer from Oracle, the computer software giant based in San Francisco.
Ms. Ramakrishna is allowed, through her student visa, a one-year extension beyond graduation. After that expires, Oracle would have to apply for a work permit on her behalf called an H-1B.
Her husband moved with her, leaving his Pittsburgh office of The Learning House, a Louisville, Ky.-based online education technology company, and is working remotely.
Cultural misunderstandings
Others say there are barriers for foreign workers that go beyond the job description. Edward Barr, a CMU adjunct professor who teaches business communication, blames cultural misunderstandings for forcing many foreign students to look for jobs elsewhere.
Such job seekers “build different resumes, interview differently and in general comport themselves differently than Americans,” said Mr. Barr, who frequently helps his students reformat resumes and prep for interviews.
Mr. Barr is working with Ron Alvarado, chairperson of the Pittsburgh Metropolitan Area Hispanic Chamber of Commerce and president of Novus Group, LLC, a Robinson-based staffing agency, on training human resources departments to identify when cultural biases are creeping into hiring decisions.
Mr. Alvarado, who was among a large group of corporate officials that first received the Allegheny Conference report, met Mr. Jose less than a month ago and pressed local companies to consider him. Mr. Jose got a handful of interviews for a position at Highmark Health, but the company did not offer him a position before his visa expired on June 29.
“Our region’s employers need to act aggressively and creatively to keep talent like Guillermo here,” Mr. Alvarado said. “I want to say, ‘here’s a solution for you. You guys addressed the issue. This is how we can fix it.’ ”
One way to solve it is to find ways to measure a commitment to diversity. Some organizations use labor market data as a baseline to determine how much diversity should be represented within their workforce, said James E. Taylor, who became UPMC’s chief diversity and inclusion officer in March.
Other companies quantify diversity through inclusion programs and use of diverse vendors and suppliers, he said. At UPMC, middle managers are required to measure their progress toward corporate diversity goals — which includes women making up more than two-thirds of managers and leaders.
“Diverse job candidates continue to disprove the ongoing myth among some hiring managers — if I hire for diversity, I am reducing my standards for quality, expertise, and work experience,” he said.
The visa hurdle
Perhaps the most tangible hurdle for employers to recruit foreign workers are visa requirements. “It’s not the easy thing to do and it costs the employer time and money to do it,” said Abbie Alejandro Rosario, an associate at JBM Legal, LLC, a Pittsburgh immigration law firm.
The government caps the number of H-1B visas, which allow U.S. companies to employ foreign workers for certain positions that require a four-year degree, at 65,000 each year. An additional 20,000 foreign workers who have a master’s degree or higher are eligible for H-1B. Due to exemptions, the actual number of H-1B visas each year is more than 100,000.
Mr. Jose, whose departure resulted from the expiration of a temporary tourist visa, was drawn to the United States for the first time to study at CMU in 2006. After his student visa expired in 2008, he worked a variety of jobs in Mexico City. He is seeking a so-called TN visa, another permit that allows citizens of Canada and Mexico to work in the United States.
In the meantime, he plans to move to Canada for job opportunities. In the short-term, Elena Gutierrez McKelligan, also from Mexico, will join him.
As only the most recent export of Pittsburgh-educated talent, Mr. Jose said he will be just fine — he describes himself as a “citizen of the world.” But he lamented that he couldn’t seize an opportunity that was so apparent to him.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.