These days, expected growth in solar energy is framed in exponential terms.
Solar’s costs have dropped by as much as 65 percent, according to government figures, and now compete with other sources of power on the grid. Rooftop solar is heating up, evidenced by SolarCity Corp.’s decision to build an operations center in Pittsburgh.
And a solar industry trade group estimates utility-scale solar power could more than quadruple to nearly 74,000 megawatts when plants currently being constructed or under development are finished.
Against this backdrop, General Electric this month made a striking announcement that it will shutter a manufacturing plant in O’Hara by the end of this year that produced equipment for the solar industry.
Nearly 400 workers will be disrupted — 250 workers will lose their jobs, and another 130 who work there will either be transferred to Houston, Texas, or keep their jobs as contractors for the U.S. Navy and work at other locations in the Pittsburgh region, Tim Waldee, GE’s manager at the site, told the Post-Gazette earlier this month.
Attempts to get additional comment from Mr. Waldee and Paul Floren, a GE spokesman based in France, were not successful.
While there’s no indication that solar’s growth will slow — and while General Electric’s business, which raked in $117 billion in revenue last year, is doing fine — it does show how businesses feeding the rise of the solar industry can misfire.
GE’s plant produces 4-megawatt inverters for utility-scale solar energy projects. Inverter panels take in as much as 1,500 volts of direct current produced by the photovoltaic cells and convert it into alternating current used by the electric grid and appliances in homes and businesses.
The 1,500-volt inverter was developed for European solar plants by French engineering company Converteam, which GE acquired in 2011 for $3.2 billion and folded into its Power Conversion business. With the transaction, GE brought that technology to U.S. plants, which were using primarily 600-megawatt inverters.
The higher-voltage inverters have rapidly become the industry standard as developers could squeeze more of out their projects, reported PV-Tech, a solar trade publication, in November. That month, GE signed a deal to provide its 1,500V inverters for 150 megawatts of projects being built by developer Solargise in India.
But a problem surfaced when GE began expanding the capacity of its inverters, under a similar logic that attracted developers to higher-voltage inverters. GE has touted 4-megawatt inverters as saving solar farms up to 30 percent on maintenance costs when compared to 2-megawatt version. It has reportedly eyed devices as large as 30 megawatts.
It turned out to be a miscalculation that the solar industry was ready for larger equipment, said Scott Moskowitz, a New York City-based solar markets analyst for Greentech Media, a clean energy research firm.
“The market has really yet to adopt ultra-large utility inverters,” Mr. Moskowitz said. “There’s some tradeoff. The bigger the product, the bigger the impact if there is some issue. For now, the industry is hovering right around 1- to 2.5-megawatt inverters.”
GE’s solar business has taken off in the last two years, he added, and “now that GE’s business is growing, they’re learning what is working and what isn’t.”
The company hired 130 people at the O’Hara plant last year in anticipation of growing demand, but a dearth of expected orders forced the plant to close altogether.
It’s not the first time a large solar manufacturer took off in Pittsburgh with high expectations and ran aground. Flabeg Solar, U.S. Corp., a $30 million solar plant in Clinton, opened its doors in 2009 and reportedly provided 300 jobs. It shut down and endured a messy bankruptcy in 2013, despite having received $10 million in federal stimulus money.
And this year has been marked by the high-profile bankruptcy of SunEdison Inc., once the fastest-growing renewable energy company in the world. The U.S. company filed for Chapter 11 protection, as years of debt-fueled acquisitions proved unsustainable.
Solar advocates say they see no blip in the positive outlook for the industry.
“Any time you go through a growth period, there are a lot of market dynamics at play,” said Dan Whitten, spokesman for the Solar Energy Industries Association. “Some business models are going to thrive and some may not.”
While there’s 17,000 megawatts worth of projects currently operating, the group’s project database shows nearly 57,000 more megawatts under development and under construction.
He added, “Ultimately, there’s going to be massive growth. How that’s going to manifest itself in the growth of individual companies, I couldn’t say.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.