Headlines are constant reminders of the havoc that cybersecurity breaches cause. Investors are among the victims.

“It’s become a weekly occurrence and that’s certainly not lost on investors,” said David Jaffe, a business transactions attorney in the Pittsburgh office of Fox Rothschild.

Mr. Jaffe said understanding companies’ cybersecurity risks is an emerging priority for institutional investors.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission requires companies to disclose “timely, comprehensive and accurate information ... that a reasonable investor would consider important to an investment decision,” according to cybersecurity-related guidance the agency gave in 2011.

Advertise with us

SEC officials said if cybersecurity issues are among the biggest factors that make investing in a public company risky or speculative, investors should be informed of those risks. But companies don’t have to provide information that would compromise security, SEC officials said.

Several Pittsburgh companies disclosed cybersecurity risk last year after federal prosecutors indicted five members of the Chinese military for hacking Allegheny Technologies, U.S. Steel, Westinghouse and Alcoa as well as the United Steelworkers union. The indictment alleged the crimes included obtaining 7,000 passwords of Allegheny Technologies employees and breaching U.S. Steel’s system.

In its next quarterly SEC filing, Allegheny Technologies acknowledged cybersecurity risks and said that, despite its best efforts, “Our facilities and our systems and those of our third-party service providers may be vulnerable to security breaches.”

U.S. Steel’s next quarterly SEC filing mentioned the indictment and disclosed that the company “has experienced cyber security attacks.”

“Based on information known to date, the company is currently unable to determine the materiality, if any, of these events,” U.S. Steel disclosed.

Advertise with us

Alcoa’s 2014 annual report stated it had been the victim of hackers, but the incidents did not have a material impact on finances or operations. “Due to the evolving nature of cybersecurity threats, the scope and impact of any future incident cannot be predicted,” Alcoa said.

Given the lack of substance in such disclosures, some investment managers don’t believe there is much to learn from them.

Jonathan Art, a senior portfolio manager for Federated Investors, said investors aren’t equipped to judge how secure one company’s computers system is compared to competitors’ systems. He said there isn’t much to disclose unless a company’s computers have been hacked. In the absence of that, “What would they disclose? What could they really disclose?” Mr. Art asked.

Malcolm Polley, president and chief investment officer of Stewart Capital Advisors in Indiana, Pa., said risk disclosures don’t really matter much to the firm. “We are more concerned about how companies handle the problem once it surfaces and the impact on company financials when it does happen,” he said.

Deciding which cybersecurity incidents to report and when to report them can be difficult. It often takes time to determine the extent of a breach and the potential damage. The decision is more complicated when law enforcement is involved.

Advertise with us

Attorney Rich Green said it is possible for a company to comply with the wishes of law enforcement officials who don’t want to jeopardize an ongoing investigation but to risk running afoul of SEC disclosure requirements. He cited the Sony case, where disclosures were delayed after breaches in 2011 and 2014, as an example.

Mr. Green, who specializes in technology, outsourcing and data security law with McCarter & English, said many expect the SEC to provide some indication of its direction on cybersecurity policy when the agency issues its exam priorities for 2016. Recent passage of legislation that permits companies to share data with government agencies without being liable for violating privacy laws leads some to believe the SEC may provide more detailed guidance, he said.

“We’re all expecting something cyber-related in there,” he said. “It could be really deep. There are some indications it might be if you see what the [Obama] administration did with the information sharing act.”

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.