The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission’s Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement continues to pursue a $19 million penalty against San Francisco-based ride-sharing company Uber for operating illegally in Pennsylvania for six months last year.
“Uber’s complete and utter lack of cooperation is simply unprecedented before the commission,” wrote PUC deputy chief prosecutor Michael Swindler in the agency’s July brief, adding that the ride-sharing giant has displayed “contumacious conduct,” which will be considered in any future dealings with the company before the PUC.
Uber, which received a two-year, experimental license to operate in most of Pennsylvania in November, says in its Friday filing posted recently on the PUC website that it has “no record of non-compliance” and that no penalty, or a least a lower penalty, is what is warranted.
“Instead of engaging the substantive issues that impact the lives of average citizens in Allegheny County, I&E has devoted countless hours and other state resources to a discovery dispute over producing confidential trip data,” Karen Moury, Uber’s Harrisburg-based attorney, wrote in the company’s recent brief.
Uber and the PUC’s enforcement bureau have until Friday to file replies to each other’s assertions. After that, administrative law judges will close the record, and have 90 days after that point to issue a ruling.
The data in question — namely the number of trips Uber provided in the area while under a cease-and-desist order last summer — were provided to the PUC in December, but the enforcement arm could not access the information until May.
Uber and Lyft pair drivers in their own vehicles with passengers seeking rides via smartphone apps. Despite a July 2014 cease-and-desist order from PUC administrative law judges, both companies continued to operate in the region.
Officers with the PUC’s Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement took several trips using Uber and Lyft in Allegheny County last spring. The agency filed formal complaints against both, alleging they were unlicensed brokers of transportation for compensation.
The agency originally sought civil penalties of $130,000 and daily fines of $1,000 against Lyft and $95,000 and daily fines of $1,000 against Uber.
Ms. Moury, the attorney representing Uber, wrote in its brief that past decisions by the PUC commissioners have not led to such hefty fines, and noted that the PUC settled its case against Lyft last month for $250,000.
Under the terms of that agreement, which was approved by administrative law judges July 15, Lyft admitted no wrongdoing.
Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.