It’s a safe assumption that many students go to college to improve their employment prospects.
But it’s a less safe assumption that college rankings seeking to rate which school is set to improve the students’ earning capacity the most will be accurate measures of a college’s full impact.
Among the many rankings of colleges, at least two rely on employment data of graduates: LinkedIn, a professional social media website, ranks universities based on career outcomes in 10 fields; PayScale, which focuses on compensation, ranks colleges overall rather than by a particular field of study.
Edwin Koc, director of research, public policy and legal affairs for the National Association of Colleges and Employers, whose members provide data on entry-level pay of college graduates by what they studied, said comparing colleges based on employment outcomes “would be against our philosophy.”
Mr. Koc said: “Outcomes are very individual specific. They don’t really capture what the college brings to the individual, not completely. They could very much be an example of what individuals are actually at the college and the kind of backgrounds and life choices and qualities those individuals have rather than any aspect of the college’s performance.”
Carnegie Mellon University graduates in some fields fare the best of any local schools in both the LinkedIn and PayScale rankings.
LinkedIn ranks no more than the top 25 of the nation’s more than 2,800 four-year colleges and universities.
The LinkedIn ratings are aimed at figuring out which schools give students the best chance of getting a desirable job after graduation. A desirable job is defined as one at a “desirable company for the relevant profession.” A desirable company is one that can retain and attract employees.
LinkedIn reviewed employment patterns of more than 300 million LinkedIn members worldwide. Its analysis includes only graduates who earned degrees within the past eight years.
In the 10 fields, CMU placed in half of them: designers, No. 1; software developers at startups, No. 3; software developers, No. 4; sales professionals, No. 10; and marketers, No. 25.
PayScale ranks more than 1,200 colleges and universities. These rankings look at “return on investment” based on information from employees who completed PayScale’s employee survey. The return is based on the difference between the 20-year median pay for graduate with a bachelor’s degree and the 24-year median pay for a high school graduate minus the total four-year college cost.
In the PayScale report, CMU is the top-ranked local school, coming in at 25th place with a return on investment of $688,500. The top amount was $985,300 at Harvey Mudd College in Claremont, Calif.
Some of the other rankings in the PayScale report include Penn State University, in-state, main, No. 215; University of Pittsburgh, in-state, main, No. 310; Duquesne University, No. 502; and Robert Morris University, No. 508.
At CMU, Kevin Monahan, associate dean of student affairs for career and professional development, said it’s “great” to see entities like LinkedIn show that “top employers really value the type of students that come out of Carnegie Mellon.”
He said LinkedIn has a CMU alumni group, with about 27,000 members. He said most CMU students register with LinkedIn by graduation, and some network with alumni, both to find jobs and to learn about the culture at companies that have made offers.
Barmak Nassirian, director of federal relations and policy analysis for the American Association of State Colleges and Universities, said the rankings do not give a full picture nor are they the same throughout an institution.
“It is really critical to understand that outcomes vary as much within each institution as they do among institutions,” he said.
Survey data from the National Association of Colleges and Employers show that employers expect graduates with bachelor’s degrees in the Class of 2015 to have average starting pay ranging from $45,042 for humanities to $62,998 for engineering. The average for petroleum engineering is even higher: $80,600.
Despite the difficulties of making such calculations, Mr. Nassirian said the issue of looking at outcomes of educational experience is an “area of enormous interest in policy research.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.