When Phil Laboon’s phone erupted in a torrent of buzzes during a Sunday evening dinner party at a friend’s home, the last thing he expected to hear was that his company, Internet marketing firm Eyeflow, was the victim of a terrorist attack.

“Everybody here is kind of looking at each other like ‘What’s happening?’ ” he said. “I felt like I had a better chance of buying a winning Powerball ticket than I did being one of a half-dozen companies being hacked by an organization that claims to be extremist.”

At least a dozen small businesses across the globe scrambled to repair their websites this past weekend after a series of cyberattacks allegedly carried out by the Islamic State group shut them down. Reports of the attacks began trickling in on Saturday and continued through Sunday, with South Side-based Eyeflow and the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre in Ireland all suffering the same invasion.

The attacks dismantled Eyeflow’s websites by deleting their original information and replacing it with a black page featuring white Arabic writing followed by the English message “Hacked by Islamic State (ISIS) We are everywhere.” ISIS is one of the acronyms associated with the extremists who broke with the al-Qaida network and have established a caliphate in parts of Iraq and Syria.

Advertise with us

The compromised page also featured a link to an inoperative Facebook page and played an Arabic song on a loop.

And while Mr. Laboon laments being one of the unlucky few who took a hit, the consensus among tech and counterterrorism experts is that it’s highly unlikely Eyeflow hit the anti-jackpot and landed in extremists’ direct line of fire.

“In terms of my understanding of ISIS and what they’re trying to do, I don’t think hacking small businesses in the U.S. is necessarily high on their list of priorities, although the truth is we don’t know who’s behind these attacks at this point,” said Michael Kinney, associate professor of international affairs at the University of Pittsburgh.

Historically, Mr. Kinney said, the Islamic State has used its presence on the Internet for recruitment and to disseminate propaganda and graphic images, such as a video of the beheading of Peter Kassig a former U.S. Army Ranger and aid worker. If the organization shifts gears from propaganda to cyberterror, Mr. Kinney believes, it won’t waste its resources on a handful of small businesses.

“I would think ISIS would be more interested in hacking government websites or if they couldn’t get to those, if those were too protected, I’d think ISIS would be interested in hacking companies that are directly involved in providing security services, other sorts of services involved in counterterrorism,” he said.

Advertise with us

Emphasizing that it’s too early to speculate, Mr. Kinney said his best guess was that the attack was carried out by either Islmaic State sympathizers in the U.S. or someone out to poke fun at a company’s expense.

Martin Lindner, principal engineer at the CERT Division of Carnegie Mellon University’s Software Engineering Institute, said that if it’s not for laughs, it could be an individual hacker’s attempt to draw attention to his work.

Mr. Laboon said he and his staff reactivated the site within hours of shutdown and ran through “hundreds of thousands of lines of code” to check for any points of entry. And while they said they don’t believe the Islamic State was behind the attack, the incident showed them anything is possible.

“I’m pretty confident they’re going to say we weren’t a target, but if they say we’re a target for X, Y or Z it will be one interesting phone call,” he said.