Finding the perfect purple blouse for the holiday party only to learn the store doesn't have it in your size is not an experience limited to the mall. Online shoppers are just as likely to see their size crossed out when they try to place an order.
“You’re always having out-of-stock situations” on websites, said Peter Sheldon, vice president and principal analyst with Forrester Research.
The retail staff trying to keep merchandise flowing smoothly through traditional stores have issues, too. Not enough size 8 purple blouses in one store, and too many size 2s that may have to be marked down. And no blouses at all at a store in the next town.
“Retailers have sort of lived in silos to some extent,” said Mr. Sheldon.

This year might be described as the moment that retailers tore down the wall between inventory for online customers held in a warehouse and the inventory at stores across the country.
Industry players like Macy’s and Toys R Us had begun moving in that direction in recent years, said Mr. Sheldon, but this year estimates indicate more than three-fourths of U.S. retailers have implemented or are rolling out programs that allow filling online orders from store inventories.
“I think we’re down to that point of critical mass,” Mr. Sheldon said.
One factor pushing the trend is that technology that has made it easier to put such systems in place, he said.
Plus retailers have decided their real estate holdings give them a competitive tool to battle rivals like Amazon. The online retail giant has been adding distribution sites around the country, including one in Crafton, so it can shorten even further the time between ordering and a package landing on the doorstep.
Consumers might not notice the shipping arms race, although it could mean good things for them: There should be fewer items listed as out of stock online. Orders could show up faster if they’re filled at a store near a customer’s home, rather than sent from a distribution center several states away. And customers in stores should find it easier to get merchandise sitting in stock at other stores.
But pay no attention to that inventory slight-of-hand. The goal is to make the ship-from-store programs fit neatly and seamlessly into existing operations, sight unseen.
That’s the vision at American Eagle Outfitters, which began piloting its B.O.S.S. — buy online, ship from store — program late in 2013. Before Black Friday arrives this year, 530 of the chain’s stores will be on the job processing online orders and sending packages to customers, in between checking shoppers out at the cash register.
A few hundred remaining stores will get with the program early next year. The South Side teen clothing retailer didn't want to move so fast that orders got messed up or the work disrupted in-store sales.
Even before tests began at stores like the one on East Carson Street near the company’s headquarters, American Eagle had to work on its technology.
“What we had to do was put in a system that gave us a searchable real-time view of the inventory across the enterprise,” said Michael Rempell, chief operating officer.
Odd at it sounds, the company didn't have that before. The online store and the bricks-and-mortar versions operated separately.
Purchases made via digital tools — PCs, smartphones and tablets that now account for about 15 percent of the company’s sales — were filled at the American Eagle distribution center in Kansas.
Even if a customer was standing in a store and could tell on her smartphone that the right size and color was sitting in a store elsewhere in the chain, if it was not available at the distribution center, it couldn't be had.
“We couldn't order it for you,” said Mr. Rempell. “It sounds funny but that was the reality.”
And there were “orphan products,” items bought online that weren't typically carried in stores but might end up in the backroom of a store somewhere destined for a clearance rack. That happened because the company let customers return goods ordered online to their neighborhood store.
“It was very customer friendly. It wasn't very efficient,” said Mr. Rempell.
Now those orphans can get a second chance if someone orders them online and they’re shipped from the store that took them in.
Annie Schmitz, American Eagle’s manager of store operations, has spent much of the year helping establish training systems so thousands of store employees can learn how to handle orders.
“The stores really love this,” said Ms. Schmitz in a recent walk-through of the East Carson Street’s backroom, which is set up to handle online orders in addition to keeping the sales floor out front well stocked.
Orders arrive each day via computer — up to 60 per store, with each location starting out with a few and then picking up more as the store proves itself. Like a mini-distribution center, the order area is stocked with bags and labels for packing items and scan guns to check bar codes.
Stores can fill orders until 2 p.m., at which point packages have to be ready for the delivery service.
The South Side store’s backroom was also outfitted with signs along the shelving fixtures to show where items are stored. Flip boards were hung within reach to make it easy to double-check the packing steps.
If store associates don’t pack items properly, consumers notice. Even more of a problem, things can be broken in transit or customers can get the wrong goods, Mr. Sheldon noted. That’s been a challenge across the industry.
While a really good ship-from-store algorithm has the potential to optimize the opportunity — perhaps by shifting sales to underperforming stores or by steering orders away from locations socked in by snow — it’s just another part of the distribution puzzle.
“Ship-from-store is by no means a magic elixir that’s going to solve all the retailer’s problems,” said Mr. Sheldon, adding, “A distribution center is still far more efficient at packing and picking, and can do it at a lower cost than a store.”
Mr. Rempell sees the new American Eagle system as a beginning in adapting to the new fulfillment needs created by more customers shopping digitally. “We started here because it lays down the infrastructure for future services,” he said.
More innovations are coming. Like a few other retailers, Findlay-based Dick’s Sporting Goods has rolled out services that allow shoppers to buy online and then drive to a nearby store to pick up the goods.
American Eagle isn’t there yet, but the company does foresee — maybe as early as next year — letting customers go online to reserve merchandise in a store and then swing by within 24 hours to complete the purchase.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.