When Verizon Wireless introduced its new "Share Everything" mobile service plans, I decided to take advantage of the calculators on the company's website to do some of my homework. But I found the results were not exactly what I would expect -- and in fact misleading.

The Share Everything calculator (http://www.verizonwireless.com/b2c/splash/shareEverythingCalculator.jsp) lets you pick the types of devices that you have (or will have). Then enter how much you plan to use your devices in aggregate, with the goal of seeing how big a Share Everything plan you'll need to purchase to minimize your monthly cost. The questions are easy to understand, although it may not be as easy to figure out which answers to pick from the multiple choices provided.

For instance, it asks for the total number of minutes used on all the devices on your account. That requires you to make some guesses. If you already have a plan, you should look it up on your previous statements or in your online account from Verizon Wireless -- or from whatever cell phone vendor you had been using.

The other two main questions are how many text messages sent and received, and how much data you use. You should enter the values based on your average month of usage.

Advertise with us

If you have already decided to move to the Share Everything plan, the questions about talk minutes and texts are really not needed because the Share Everything plans included unlimited amounts of both. But that data question would seem to be very important, because your choice of data bundle could cause a difference of $90 or more to your monthly bill.

But wait. If I tell the calculator I need 2 to 5 GB monthly, it should suggest a plan for 4GB ($70/month) or 6 GB ($80/month). If I say 10+ GB, it should calculate $100 for my data (plus overages); and maybe even if I select 5 to 10 GB, suggest that same maximum plan.

Yet if I tell the calculator I need 2 to 5 GB of data for five smartphones, it suggests that I purchase the maximum 10 GB plan, perhaps costing me an additional $30/month. No matter how much data I say I need, if I choose five smartphones, it recommends 10 GB.

So I played around with the calculator to see how I can force the calculator to recommend something other than the maximum plan. I found I had to change the number of phones. Apparently, it suggests 2 GB for every device, no matter how much data you say you will consume. And it adds a footnote: "Verizon Wireless data devices average between 1 and 2 GBs of data a month."

Interpreted another way, they are saying they don't believe when you say you will use less than average amounts, and want to charge you for at least the average for the number of devices you have on your plan. After all, if you select higher than average usage, it makes higher recommendations than it does for average usage -- just not lower. Like Garrison Keillor's Lake Wobegon, where every kid is above average.

Advertise with us

So I would not recommend even using that calculator.

On the other hand, the company's data calculator (http://www.verizonwireless.com/b2c/splash/datacalculator.jsp) is a great aid. It helps you figure out how much data you'll actually use (even if the other calculator doesn't believe the answer). With the data calculator, you give it your habits -- how many emails you send, Web pages you visit, photos you upload and media (songs and videos) you consume. Then it tells you graphically how many GBs you'll need to do that.