In a move that could lower the prices of e-books, the Justice Department sued Apple Inc. and five major book publishers Wednesday, saying they colluded to raise the price of the electronic publications.

The suit, which the Justice Department threatened a month ago, alleges that it cost consumers more than $100 million in the past two years by adding $2 to $5 to the price of each e-book.

A separate suit filed in Texas by Puerto Rico and 15 states, including Pennsylvania, seeks to force publishers to refund the overcharges, CNet.com reported.

The government reached a settlement with three of the publishers, Hachette, HarperCollins and Simon & Schuster. But it will proceed with its lawsuit in federal court in New York City against Apple and publishers Macmillan and Penguin Group.

Advertise with us

At issue is the "agency model," a pricing mechanism that Apple and the publishers agreed to in 2010, when Apple introduced its iPad and was seeking content for its new tablet. Under the agency model, a publisher sets a book's price, and the retailer takes a cut -- in Apple's case, 30 percent. The retailer can sell the e-book only for the price set by the publisher.

Fear of Amazon.com's market domination was a major reason that retailers opted for the agency model. The publishers argued that Amazon's discounted pricing not only hurt sales of higher-priced printed copies but also drove small e-book sellers, who could not compete with that bargain price, out of the business.

Printed books are sold under the wholesale model: A publisher sells a book to the retailer at a fixed price, and the retailer can sell it for any price.

This was the model being used when Amazon's Kindle e-book reader hit the market. It allowed Amazon to sell e-books for $9.99, sometimes by taking a loss that would be made up by its Kindle sales.

When the agency model took effect, prices immediately rose to $12.99 to $14.99, and Amazon was forced to go along because the publishers had agreed that no retailer could sell e-books for a price lower than Apple, the so-called "most favored nation" clause.

Advertise with us

The Justice Department on Wednesday revealed the terms of its settlement with Hachette, HarperCollins and Simon & Schuster, Wired.com reported. The settlement terms show what is being sought in the lawsuit from Apple and the other two publishers.

Terms include termination of current contracts with Apple and any other contracts with e-book retailers that restrict the retailer's ability to set final prices for books or contain a "most favored nation" provision. Also, any renegotiation with Apple or other retailers would have a two-year prohibition on any contract that prevents retailers from discounting retail prices.

The settlement doesn't kill the agency model outright, but does modify it significantly.

Under the agreement, if a publisher prices a book at $10 and a retailer agrees to a 30 percent commission, or $3, the retailer would be permitted to sell the book below list price, by taking the discount out of their own $3 commission. The publisher would still net $7 but would lose its ability to maintain prices, Wired said.

As part of the lawsuit, the Justice Department may use material from Walter Isaacson's biography of the late Apple CEO and chairman, Steve Jobs. The book says Jobs, who died in October, was aware of publishers' frustration with Amazon.

Advertise with us

It quotes Jobs as saying: "So we told the publishers, 'We'll go to the agency model, where you set the price, and we get our 30 percent, and, yes, the customer pays a little more, but that's what you want anyway.' ... So they went to Amazon and said, 'You're going to sign an agency contract, or we're not going to give you the books.' "

Connecticut Attorney General George Jepsen said about the state lawsuit that a payback to buyers would be either a credit toward a future e-book purchase or a check. Publishers Hachette and HarperCollins have already agreed to such a deal, CNet.com quoted Mr. Jepsen as saying.

U.S. acting Assistant Attorney General Sharis Pozen said the investigation found buyers to be spending about $2 to $3 more per title as part of the alleged price-fixing scheme, with some books shooting up nearly $5 in price.

Sales of e-books rose 117 percent in 2011, generating $969.9 million, Publishers Weekly reported on Feb. 27. By eliminating printing and shipping costs, digital versions generate higher profit margins than physical books.