I'm not paranoid. I just think people are watching me.
It's an old joke, but in these days of terrorism and surveillance, it may not be so off the mark.
When we think of surveillance by government or law enforcement, we think of wiretaps. But wiretaps are only the top of the pyramid.
Wiretapping is accessing the content of your communications, be it telephone calls, e-mails or instant messages. Permission to wiretap is the hardest to get. It requires that a warrant be issued by a court and has stringent requirements for proof. According to a report to Congress in 2007, every installed wiretap intercepted the communications of an average of 94 people. Despite the restrictions on wiretaps, the law can be flaunted, as we learned in 2005, when it was revealed the National Security Agency was wiretapping millions of Americans without warrants in the name of fighting terrorism.
Information on your communications can be obtained even if you aren't the subject of a wiretap. And there are ways that information can be collected on your communications without a warrant.
In 1979 in Smith v. Maryland, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that monitoring the phone numbers of incoming and outgoing calls was not a search and not protected by the Constitution. Since you know such numbers are recorded by the phone company, you are voluntarily providing them when you dial, the court reasoned.
This type of surveillance is called a pen/trap tap. With a pen/trap tap on your phone, authorities can intercept phone numbers you call, numbers that call you, the time each call is made and call length. They cannot access any of the contents of the calls.
After the Supreme Court removed constitutional protections against pen/trap taps, Congress moved in to restore some privacy -- but not much.
In 1986, as part of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, Congress passed a Pen Register Act that said authorities needed only to certify to the court that the information was relevant to an investigation to get a pen/trap tap. They don't have to report back to the court what they intercepted nor notify targets of the surveillance after it is over.
In 2001, as part of the USA Patriot Act, these rules were specifically extended to all forms of electronic communications, including those over the Internet.
With a pen/trap order, authorities can see e-mail addresses of people you send mail to and who send mail to you, the IP address of your computer on the Internet and of any computer with which you exchange information.
Pen/trap orders can also be used to monitor which websites you visit, but a wiretap order is usually obtained to see what page or file you are viewing.
Although the Pen Register Act does not allow access to content of your communications without a warrant, the second section of the ECPA does allow such access in limited circumstances. The Stored Communications Act concerns records and content that is stored by your Internet Service Provider or other services on a remote computer.
Again, the reasoning is that full Fourth Amendment protections do not apply because you knowingly allowed a third party to store this material.
The Stored Communications Act does allow access to content of messages without a warrant in certain circumstances.
If e-mail or voice mail messages are unopened or unlistened to and have been in storage for 180 or fewer days, a warrant is required for authorities to obtain them.
The government maintains that if the content has already been accessed by you and is stored less than 180 days, it can be obtained by a special court order called a "D" order, or by a subpoena. Both of those require less stringent proof than a warrant. As with a warrant, you must be notified, but notification can be delayed up to 90 days.
However, access to communications that you have opened and have been stored less than 180 days is fuzzy because at least one court has ruled that it requires a warrant.
For communications stored more than 180 days, a subpoena or a "D" order is required. Again, notification can be delayed up to 90 days.
But the government doesn't consider records of your searches kept by a search engine to be stored communications and thus are not protected by the act.
So what is TechMan's point in all this? Simply that as a citizen your communications have some protection under the law, but you should know your rights and pay attention when laws are changed.
Next week: The rules for tracking your location.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.