The debut last week of Rupert Murdoch's iPad-only newspaper, The Daily, was studded with hyperbole, just like any product launch.

Words like "magic" and phrases like "new journalism" and "a new form of media" were bandied about.

After several days of reading the new publication, here are some thoughts on what The Daily is and is not:

The Daily is a trailblazer in iPad distribution, the first publication that allows readers to subscribe on iTunes and have new editions delivered overnight. Apple says it will roll out this ability to other publishers soon.

Advertise with us

The Daily is reasonably priced -- 99 cents a week or $39.99 a year, about 11 cents an issue for a yearly subscription. The first two weeks of publication are free, underwritten by Verizon. Its price reflects the cost of delivering newspaper content without printing presses, delivery trucks, ink and paper.

The Daily is innovatively designed and has the feel of a magazine rather than a newspaper. Its news coverage is much less comprehensive than a daily newspaper. It makes full use of the iPad's unique capabilities -- swiping, coverflow navigation, hot spots to pop out additional text and fade-ins and morphing of images. Video, color and panoramic photography and graphics are often stunning on the iPad's excellent screen.

The Daily is updated, according to editor-in-chief Jesse Angelo, who said it would change during the day to reflect breaking news, although that hasn't been evident yet. Even with breaking news in a crawl across the bottom of the screen, The Daily seems more static than other constantly refreshing Web news sites. Major changes in content occur once a day, like a printed newspaper.

The Daily is social in a limited way. You can send story links to Twitter and Facebook. You can comment within the app, and Twitter feeds are used to supplement some articles. Social media are not fully entwined in the design.

The Daily is divided into sections like a newspaper: news (about 20 full-length stories plus briefs, heavy on news features, light on analysis), sports (solid coverage), gossip (tabloidesque), opinion (middle of the road so far), arts&life (heavy on celebrities and entertainment) and apps and games (crossword, sudoku). Business coverage is sketchy and technology news and food seem absent.

Advertise with us

The Daily is probably going to make some money. Mr. Murdoch said he spent $30 million in creating it, and it costs about $500,000 a week to produce. It is supported by a combination of subscription and ad revenue.

The Daily is not groundbreaking in its coverage or writing, at least so far. Its news writing seems like standard wire story fare, and its feature writing is good at times -- the story about an Amish farmer smuggling raw milk to New York foodies -- and pedestrian at other times. But each issue has been generally a good read. Don't expect hard-hitting investigative journalism. The staff of about 100 includes editors, designers and technical people, mostly hired from major media outlets. Its number of reporters is smaller than a major daily, even in these days of reduced staffing. Staffing of the Egypt story, for example, seems to be one reporter on the ground with help from stringers.

The Daily is not groundbreaking in news photography. So far its news photos have been Associated Press or Reuters, available to any newspaper. It does seem to do its own on-scene panoramic photography.

The Daily is not a threat to local newspapers. Three words: No local news.

The Daily is not currently available in back issues. Also I am assuming that if you don't fire up your iPad for a day, you miss that issue. You can save stories.

Advertise with us

The Daily is not self-contained. You can view stories and photos without an Internet connection. But videos, social media interactions and some other special features require a Web connection and a fairly robust one. No problem for someone with a 3G iPad, but a concern for WiFi-only owners.

The Daily is not a savior of the newspaper industry nor the new form of newspapers. Perhaps when the Internet is ubiquitous, iPad-like devices are cheap and can be rolled up and stuffed in a pocket, that will be true.

For now, The Daily is traditional journalism in a very appealing wrapper.